Micro 809: Greatest Idea - Game Over

[Micc]

Votecount 1.07

Invisibility (2) -

Maestro, Fredrick A Campbell

Not_Mafia (2) -

Stungun0404, Invisibility

Maestro (1) -

Not_Mafia

Not Voting (4) -

Kop, GeminiTwin12, ceejayvinoya, ManWithNoName

With 9 players alive it takes 5 votes to lynch.

The deadline for Day 1 is in (expired on 2018-06-22 00:35:00).

[Maestro]

Hello pages, I’m Maestro

[Maestro]

Why is there so much claiming, it’s an Idea game

Stop being stupid

[stungun0404]

a day vig or vigilante might be wise as of now to use it on fac, to avoid a potential use of the vengeful upon his lynch. he's also a potential lynch target.

look at the odds for some player drawing a day vig card; 3/76, almost as likely as a vanilla townie at 4/76. they are all 1-S, though.

this is why i want fac to role claim; and tell me maestro, what have you done that's even remotely town?

roleclaim (3): stungun, mwnn, gemini
don't roleclaim (2): invisibility, maestro

what is even remotely wrong with having scum suspects commit to revealing their color alignment card? reticence in giving that info is an automatic scum indication in my book.

therefore, scumread: nm AND maestro

[ManWithNoName]

VOTE: N_M

I think this is the right play.

[Not_Mafia]

VOTE: N_M

I think this is the right play.

It’s not

[Not_Mafia]

a day vig or vigilante might be wise as of now to use it on fac, to avoid a potential use of the vengeful upon his lynch. he's also a potential lynch target.

look at the odds for some player drawing a day vig card; 3/76, almost as likely as a vanilla townie at 4/76. they are all 1-S, though.

this is why i want fac to role claim; and tell me maestro, what have you done that's even remotely town?

roleclaim (3): stungun, mwnn, gemini
don't roleclaim (2): invisibility, maestro

what is even remotely wrong with having scum suspects commit to revealing their color alignment card? reticence in giving that info is an automatic scum indication in my book.

therefore, scumread: nm AND maestro

I’m happy to claim mine, just after scumstro

[stungun0404]

@ManWithNoName, what are your thoughts on Maestro?
@Maestro, what are your thoughts on ManWithNoName?

[Maestro]

What’re your thoughts on how much of an annoyingly controlling tool your posts make you seem like? I have a tech rehearsal tonight, you don’t get my time until after it.

[GeminiTwin12]

Someone seems pressed.

[ManWithNoName]

Low information. I'm not trusting it too much. I feel like he's not engaging in real exchanges of thought.

[Not_Mafia]

Someone seems pressed.

Dat edge

[Invisibility]

this is a pretty sicc game

[stungun0404]

What’re your thoughts on how much of an annoyingly controlling tool your posts make you seem like? I have a tech rehearsal tonight, you don’t get my time until after it.

1). Personal attacks have no place in this game. This is the second time you have done it. Quit, or stop playing mafia.

2). I reread the thread, and gathered some new information I wanted to explore. Questions are how you gather information for later, so I proposed one.

3). I got under your skin with this particular question, and I have a hunch as to why. I have asked you 3 questions. You didn't answer my first two, but this one got UNDER your skin. Neither of the other 2 are ones you should feel on the defense about, and I've done given you chances to voice some townreads and to make a case for yourself being town, but you answered neither prompt, and now you're defensive as hell when I ask you a question about the only person you've been responsive to in this thread, manwithnoname. You cap it off by making a personal attack on me. He's the only person you've asked a question to, and ALSO the only one you've responded to questions from. You didn't personally attack him. When you've literally made 11 posts in this thread, this is highly suspicious. What else do you want me to expect other than the potential case of you two being mafia partners? Well-played if so, because your personal attack defenses aren't gonna work.

Vote: Maestro

I insist that we lynch Maestro today, because he's scum and town would and should never have any incentive to act this way. Pure petty. ManWithNoName is possibly his scum partner, which would explain why this question got to Maestro. Clearest link I see in this game. Still, I'm willing to let MWNN make a case for himself/let a cop or something clear him because I had him as a townlean early on, but Maestro needs to get packing regardless.

[Invisibility]

not sure if that's scummy though
will have to reevaluate

[ManWithNoName]

I've been open and engaged, sharing my reads. I don't know what else I can do, someone can cop me if they want to, it will only go well for me.

I don't know why Maestro is only responding to me but I'll stick with my lynch pool of N_M, Maestro and FAC in order of preference.

[Invisibility]

yeah okay
i don't think i want maestro to the be lynch yet

[GeminiTwin12]

I'm curious as to what Maestro's reads/feelings are on players are so far, also out of Manwithnoname / Maestro, Manwithnoname gives off more townish vibes that Maestro so I'm not feeling a partner aspect there yet.

[ceejayvinoya]

I'd also like Fred to roleclaim. He does say he's fine with it, which makes me curious as to why...

[Fredrick A Campbell]

If you all want it, why not?

[Fredrick A Campbell]

Why am I suspected scum?

[ceejayvinoya]

I don't actually suspect you...

It's just that I expect someone would be more secretive about what his role is, because the knowledge that the role exists in the game and that you are of that role can be potentially exploited by scum.

[GeminiTwin12]

That's a good point.

[Fredrick A Campbell]

But if everyone wants me to do it, I don't really have a choice.

[Fredrick A Campbell]

...
1). Personal attacks have no place in this game. This is the second time you have done it. Quit, or stop playing mafia.
...

I don't think that is considered a personal attack.