btw, @profii if you are town check out this game that just finished, american presidents mafia
i was town and i was worried about how shoshin was pushing towards my lynch on d1, and with only one or two votes on me i was already defending in a way others thought was strange
In post 634, profii wrote:I am annoyed I didn’t write this down in my PT - when I said to Stungun yesterday “apply pressure” to GIF I knew he would react in this annoying ATE way - he’s hard to lynch, I liked whoever said defeatist, that’s a good description.
Kinda not sure what to make of Shoshin/Stungun/Aronis as I would assume at least 1 of you would have seen this behaviour before - I was expecting more Kokis - people to be unfazed by it because actually...
It’s totally NAI (imo) - I would say as any alignment it’s easy to make this defence in reaction to pressure so it’s largely meaningless
What this episode has given me is that creature post - 616 - why are we lynching anyway for something that is largely NAI
I say we lynch Creature which pretty much towns GIF
Or we lynch Aronis because part of me still believes the case on GIF is good and the associations between GIF / Aronis seem to be there
I know people have a reluctance to hunt the scum team on day 1 but it doesn’t bother me - obviously I have an opinion on where the JK should go following those lynches, however I’ll not speculate too much as there is potential for me to be wrong and we don’t want to signpost our scum to easy NKs
So yea
VOTE: Creature
It also pinged me here that creature just hopped on the GIF deal
Idk creature well enough to know if he just gets bored of the day and wants a flip, or if this sneaking onto wagons without too much forthcoming reasoning is scummy
Sure it _can_ be scummy and I’m putting it out there for others to say yay or nay but I can’t conclude myself
i have already established that it would be either gif or creature. but that is for you to decide. i’m at the point where i want to trust gif does not AtE this hard as scum, so i guess then it would be creature—which would make sense given his bandwagon switch over to you and his obsession with controlling the jailkeeper jailkeeps. so if you flip town, creature is the likely scum consequence. does that add up to you?
In post 947, stungun0404 wrote:@gif, it’s because i think you would be adept at playing scum. at least from what i have heard.
@profii, i already addressed my reads list by order in a recent post; i really don’t want to requote it when i feel like you could find it.
just look at the ordering of my ...>....>... = list
i just feel like rehashing it or even making changes to it at this point would just be a provocation, so i will reconsider everything next day phase.
i’m ok with lynching profii. i will lynch anyone that is not shoshin or nsg or myself at this point.
VOTE: profii
but would like a final readslist from profii in case we are wrong
How do you expect to find the culprit when you're all worried about each other's feelings? If you're planning to expose a liar, then you have to corner them psychologically.
But why is creature saying that weird when aronis pretty much said the same thing about lynching anyone but you him and shoshin?
How do you expect to find the culprit when you're all worried about each other's feelings? If you're planning to expose a liar, then you have to corner them psychologically.
key difference: aronis is not hopping on to wagons, creature is
in lynchpin mafia where i was mislynched by an nsg and creature scum team, creature was 2nd on my mislynch wagon viewtopic.php?p=10225987#p10225987
unrealseal first,
creature joins my wagon without any reasoning other than a bunch of other players being town
he talks about whether he should pretend being the lynchpin in his iso, which is similar to here where he is trying to control the jailkeeper viewtopic.php?p=10219654#p10219654
he is similarly like that game asking “should we...” regarding town (technical power roles). he is deferring to town to figure out how we proceed with those powers as scum, while trying to manipulate things a little
i have already established that it would be either gif or creature. but that is for you to decide. i’m at the point where i want to trust gif does not AtE this hard as scum, so i guess then it would be creature—which would make sense given his bandwagon switch over to you and his obsession with controlling the jailkeeper jailkeeps. so if you flip town, creature is the likely scum consequence. does that add up to you?
