I think Dong is actually 1-shot and not full-doc, because he targeted Overkiill.
1-shot doc would have known there was a hated town in the setup. Full doc would not have known if Over was town or cult at the time. I doubt he would have used a protect on a possible cultist.
Lynching Chat is not the worst idea. He's gonna self-vote as Jester if taken to lylo and win with mafia. As cult he's just gonna win if he's still alive tomorrow.
It's not necessarily the best idea either. He might be nightkilled if he's not lynched. It depends on if the mafia think Jester or Cultist is more likely. (Jester is more likely by raw odds, but that does not take his play into account)
Maybe Jester-test him and see if he self-hammers at 5 votes, then leave him alive if he's cult and let him be nightkilled? <-- He'd use the night to turn someone if he's cult, and no chance of hitting a mafioso if he's Jester is the cost here.
I'd still probs lean on trying to lynch actual mafia as town, but if ya wanna lynch him I'm not gonna fight it.
Posted: Sun Feb 10, 2019 11:20 pm
by Donempire
Chateu's play doesnt seem like it would be optimal as jester. There are many reasons, and i'll get into detail, but right now all i can say is we got the cultist
Posted: Mon Feb 11, 2019 12:30 am
by Allomancer
Ok, well if Chateau isn't a townie, VOTE: Chateau. He doesn't seem like a jester IMO.
Posted: Mon Feb 11, 2019 2:37 am
by 0verki11
tictac dont role spec like that thanks.
Posted: Mon Feb 11, 2019 3:01 am
by Donempire
I'd really like you to give more than two shits as well, overkill. I'd rather have tictac speaking rather than you not doing anything.
Posted: Mon Feb 11, 2019 5:36 am
by Chateau Lobby
VOTE: No Lynch
Posted: Mon Feb 11, 2019 8:01 am
by 0verki11
In post 257, Donempire wrote:I'd really like you to give more than two shits as well, overkill. I'd rather have tictac speaking rather than you not doing anything.
I have more time after the weekend.
Anyway all Tictac is doing currently is helping scum and feels scum motivated.
Posted: Mon Feb 11, 2019 8:03 am
by tris
In post 208, Allomancer wrote:UNVOTE:
Probably a jester here. I would doubt there was a loved Cult Leader.
In post 255, Allomancer wrote:Ok, well if Chateau isn't a townie, VOTE: Chateau. He doesn't seem like a jester IMO.
In post 257, Donempire wrote:I'd really like you to give more than two shits as well, overkill. I'd rather have tictac speaking rather than you not doing anything.
I have more time after the weekend.
Anyway all Tictac is doing currently is helping scum and feels scum motivated.
Are you thinking they're not really survivor?
Posted: Mon Feb 11, 2019 8:23 am
by tris
I guess since a jester is a liability anyway, we might as well lynch Chateau in case he's a cult leader.
In post 257, Donempire wrote:I'd really like you to give more than two shits as well, overkill. I'd rather have tictac speaking rather than you not doing anything.
I have more time after the weekend.
Anyway all Tictac is doing currently is helping scum and feels scum motivated.
Are you thinking they're not really survivor?
oh right they claimed that.
Either way its helping scum and if they continue ill vote them.