Well, we only have so many options.
I shouldn't be eliminated during the day, and while you and me have good not-partnered interactions, I actually fit as a catboi scumbuddy. Or as malefactor. And while the town may view the latter as a mislim, push come to shove, they'll take a malefactor elimination over a town elimination, and be pleasantly surprised at the result.
Whatever we do needs to make sure that I never die during the day--your death doesn't accomplish that because your death only clears me of being a mafiate, not of being a werewolf or malefactor.
Since your death doesn't clear me of being scum, we need to keep you alive, most likely.
With you being kept alive, we only have a few options available.
-You don't shoot me, but pretend you do; this makes each and every day harder to keep us both alive.
-You do shoot me
-You don't shoot me, but outright admit that you didn't; this makes each and every day harder to keep us both alive.
I don't see a way to ensure that I am kept alive after you die. Too many people are scumreading me and I fit too well as not-town, and your scumflip doesn't clear me from those suspicions.
I do see a way for my flip to clear you--you already cannot be a werewolf, and if I die, then that makes it so you cannot be mafia, either.
I realize it'd effectively be forfeiting two nightkills AND forfeiting a member. So I'll leave the call to you, but I genuinely think that in spite of the risks, it's legitimately the best play.