Newbie 1934 Dead PT

[Ausuka]

You're dead! You may discuss the game here.

Spoiler: Spoilers for those who want them

Please do not discuss the contents of this spoiler without using spoiler tags. You can use spoiler tags with

Code: Select all

[spoiler=][/spoiler]

Player	Role
Menalque	Vanilla Townie
Cinnamon	Vanilla Townie
Eggs	Vanilla Townie
teacher	Vanilla Townie
Irrelephant11	Vanilla Townie
Flavor Leaf	Vanilla Townie
Voted	Town Cop
Pine	Mafia Goon
Baezu	Mafia Goon

[Ausuka]

Not Voting (2) - Flavor Leaf

imagine being active and not voting 4 days before deadline

[Pine]

Well then, that was a nice exercise.

[Pine]

I love that they’re already arguing over whether my final statement was WIFOM or not.

Of course it was!

Muahahaha

[Menalque]

Hey, Pine. Wow FL is wrong about this game huh?

[Pine]

Yeah

Fortunately, I muddied the waters enough that Baezu has a longshot chance instead of no chance.

[Menalque]

What, if the FL lynch goes through but he throws enough suspicion on teacher that that’s the lynch tomorrow? And Baezu maybe gets lucky with killing Voted

[Menalque]

Seems like irrelephant smells blood though.

[Pine]

Yeah Irrelephant should have been the first kill. He's essentially confirmed Town right now

[Menalque]

Why do you think Baezu went for me? Throwing shade onto FL because I said that I thought he should be the lynch if your slot flipped red?

Was kinda surprised that I got killed tbh, I wasn’t on Baezu at all.

[Pine]

There’s killing threats and there’s getting rid of Townies who will never get lynched. You were universally Townread.

[Pine]

You needed to be NKed, but you weren’t a threat. I think it was a tactical error, and not what I advised her before end of day

[Menalque]

So what would you recommend in future games — do you think it’s valuable to come across as townie as possible even if that increases the odds of being NK’d or to try to seem a bit scummier to increase the odds of surviving into D2?

[Pine]

Nah, you did fine. You were killed because you immediately came across as Town to virtually everyone. That's a threat, just a long-term one. The tactical error here was killing you now, instead of later.

Keep doing what you're doing.

[Menalque]

Cool, thanks Pine.

[Flavor Leaf]

Damn, Teacher just attacked rather than tried to work around. Even when I started to see he was just being town.

Yeah, Baezu was scummy, but I couldn’t really push that without causing my death anyways.

My reads were off this game, but I did see Baezu-Pine slot pairing Day 1, but Teacher just kept coming after me, so of course I was gonna go there.

Baezu saw that I was actually objectively townie and would never play that way as scum, and abused it. Good for her.

I just didn’t want to play this game anymore, I was getting so frustrated. First mislynch in a long time.

I should have stuck with my Uncle Bob read.

[Flavor Leaf]

Yeah, I never would have voted you Menalque.

Nor would my slot have ever killed you, though, part of the reason I got frustrated. That is an objectively anti scumFL kill.

I was arguing with brick walls in Teacher/Eggs, I guess. That’s something they need to work on.

I didn’t have the right reads, but I was fluid and adapting to it, and Baezu was technically on my second lowest, but Teacher caused that.

Idk. I didn’t play well, but Teacher didn’t either.

Need to learn to adapt reads. I kept trying, and he kept forcing me back to him, and didn’t allow me to read elsewhere.

[Flavor Leaf]

Irrelephant played well.

Cinnamon underthought not overthought, but I don’t think they played poorly.

Voted is doing great.

Baezu’s playing alright, but she doesn’t win this.

[Flavor Leaf]

The fact I said Teacher/Eggs tomorrow, Baezu is almost guaranteed to die.

Teacher said Baezu was mechtown.

Considering Baezu was scum, I had to die, and I’d rather it be sooner than later here.

I think I could have lived through that day, but Teacher just got into that bad tunnel.

[Menalque]

Who do you guys think Baezu kills tonight? Maybe voted?

[Flavor Leaf]

Probably Irrelephant. He wanted her today.

My 2 mislynches throughout the past years, were both with Irrelephant, and I don’t play with them that much, so that’s interesting.

[Ausuka]

ooh i know this one

Spoiler: spoiler

it's irrelephant yeah

[Menalque]

Doesn’t that cast a lot of suspicion on her for NKing the person who wanted her the most? Especially when so many were open to lynching that slot?

[Flavor Leaf]

Yeah, but that’s a defense in itself, and a much easier defense to take than taking Irrelephant head on.

[Ausuka]

Unless something changes in the next 3 hours, this is game.