FGO Mafia - Notes and Actions: Rider

[Cabd]

This Private topic is the only allowable place to speculate upon the identities of other player slots, and can be used for general note-taking. These private topics may also be used for any situation in which you would normally PM the mod, so long as you bold your request/action. As with any other out-of-game thread, directly quoting from this location is a mod-killable action, so please ensure not to do so.

[penguin_alien]

Back-up mod ego post.

[Servant Rider]

Nice one, penguin. Gettin your Gudako on.

[Servant Rider]

Hell, this is here, might as well use it.

Winning this vote is not the only way to obtain a master.

My role makes it so I want day 2 to start with all 4 scum alive.
So I would rather vote a null read in the actual voting phase then a scum read.

I just want to clarify this so I don't have to try and explain why I am not casing my scum reads down the line.

I don't get how voting a null read over a scum read helps here?

Give me Master.

It doesn't matter what your ability says or does. It doesn't matter what your upgrades are.

My master upgrade is insanely good by definition, and my role does well as confirmed unkillable town for a day or so.

Ship me the Master.

People are softclaiming "the good shit" already in a role madness game. Really? Minus points for berserker.

I think part of the decision process for figuring out who should get the master upgrade needs to be: what is their master upgrade? How useful is it? How risky to use?

In that spirit, I offer: My master upgrade would allow me to give two other players their own master upgrades. The upgrade would not include revealing their alignment. Usefulness and risk would depend on my townreading skills and luck.

Decent sounding post, but I disagree with mass claiming... anything, master powers or otherwise. That said, there's nothing saying this couldn't be a scum gambit since we don't know what powers they have or get.

[Servant Rider]

I like Lancer's #20. Possible ally?

[Servant Rider]

#25 reads fluffy. And not in the Fou way.

[Servant Rider]

What IS it with this game and people not being able to keep their damn mouths shut! Moon Cancer is fucking Summer BB!

[Servant Rider]

I think Saber is Titus.

[Servant Rider]

I'd love to know who Alter Ego is. Caster feels like someone I've played with before.

[Servant Rider]

Hoo boy. I'm backsliding on Caster like there's no tomorrow. Why did I think he was town again?

Lancer scumclaimed. I've been looking for something based off the "once is coincidence, twice is concerning, thrice is confirming" rule. He keeps accusing people of things they aren't doing using buzzwords. He did it to Berserker, he did it once to Assassin, and now he's done it again to Assassin.

Also, it most likely isn't him, but damn if Assassin doesn't remind me of KKB.

[Servant Rider]

Interesting that Caster is going after Ruler for the same exact thing Shielder did maybe a page ago. TODO: ask caster

[Servant Rider]

In the interest of sort of getting back into this game properly:

went and read read rider past when i made my notes entry and i would say they are fine. i didn't really get the early tr on caster (i am liking caster a lot more recently though). asked some decent questions of caster. made some decent points about archer. their post about berserker in 422 was kind of where i was coming down, but more in the sense of "early game looks decent but i really need to see something more from her". i don't find rider overtly suspicious but would probably want to see something more solid before i'd comfortably call them town.

Assassin wrote this about me. Several folks in thread said something similar, looks decent but would like to see more solid/more substance etc. What constitutes more substance? I'm not so much interested in looking town as I am looking for the right questions to ask etc. What can I do better?

[Servant Rider]

Right then. {Lancer, Shielder, Avenger} and one of {Moon Cancer, Archer}.
Can this be that easy?

Scumreading avenger privately might be a little OMGUS-y, but that wow you're scum post

reeked

[Servant Rider]

Add Ruler to the second parenthesis set

[Servant Rider]

No way. No WAY. Fire country? She couldn't be... could she?

[Servant Rider]

[Servant Rider]

@Mod:

use Charisma neighborize on Alter Ego

[Cabd]

@Mod:

use Charisma neighborize on Alter Ego

Acknowledged. Please hold.

[penguin_alien]

Grail-kun was getting sleepy. Maybe it was the choice to switch from popcorn to more adult beverages. Could a Grail be in its cups?

The diminished party of Servants was also running low on mana. Even with the threat of more evil amongst them, enthusiasm was dragging.

"How about the lilac-haired chick?" someone asked. "She's just kind of planted herself there, not making us think she's particularly good."

The Servants coalesced into a loose circle around Mash. They egged each other on to all focus their destructive power on her. "...I just wanted to help the Master. Notice me, Senpai!" she wailed.

The Master did indeed notice Mash, as she retreated in shame, her face purple with embarrassment. Everyone held their (mostly non-existent) breath, waiting to see how the miasma of evil might change with her elimination.

Nothing. Grail-kun yawned and vomited a bit

, spewing some onto Rider

. "How about you all spend some time getting a different perspective on this situation, look at it in your spiritual forms. Come back and see what you think later."

One by one, the remaining Servants disappeared, until all that remained was Grail-kun, a flustered Master, and a large shield, rocking slightly in a phantom breeze.

JSYK the bolded part was totally in my draft as promised/threatened. I have not forgotten!

[Servant Rider]

[Servant Rider]

No actions.

[Cabd]

Noted.

[penguin_alien]

You have one charge on your Noble Phantasm (*)

[Servant Rider]

So pertaining to a question I had:

As for Moon Cancer, I see where you're coming from, I think. Therefore, I am not going to worry about them for a while and we can revisit it once we have some more data.

I want to quote the above in my neighborhood with AE and ask her if that's where she's going with this Moon Cancer thing. It contains a crumb as to who I think MC might be, and I generally want to know if she thinks MC is that level of dangerous.

I do not want to ask her to out who she thinks it is or any such.

[Cabd]

I see nothing wrong with that post. What's the crumb?