Spyfall - Pilot (Game Over - Spy Win)

[Katyusha]

Questioner	Question	Answer	Asked
Katyusha	When are you getting out of here?	Idk. It's up to someone else.	TheWorst
TheWorst	You come here often?	No, not at all.	Iconeum
Iconeum	How do you like the view?	There isn't much of one	Not_Mafia
Not_Mafia	Do you know anyone who might be here?	No. Not anyone I'm on talking terms.	Selynee
Selynee	Do you enjoy a snack around here?	No, gotta stay focused on the people around. Can't have them disturbing things.	Aronis
Aronis	Why are you here?	I came here to follow you guys. I would never consider going here by myself!	Felissan
Felissan	What did you just pick up?	Not here to pick up things.	BuJaber
BuJaber	Would you have a first date here?	It's... not exactly my first choice but with the right guy it could be interesting.	Katyusha
Katyusha	If I told you Selynee was the spy, would you be surprised?	No.	Not_Mafia
Not_Mafia	How do you feel when you come here?	Something between scared and amazed.	Selynee
Selynee	Will you buy anything?	From here? Nah, don't need anything.	TheWorst
TheWorst	How old were you when you first came here?	Been here as a boy but only virtually.	BuJaber
BuJaber	You have a time machine. What year do you go to?	1940	Not_Mafia
Not_Mafia	How much did you learn here?	There's not much we can learn here, everything's just there without any further context.	Felissan
Felissan	Is this place anything like what you expected it to be?	I had extremely specific expectations..... they were met!	TheWorst
TheWorst	Do places like this make you feel lost?	Not specifically, but I certainly would not wanna get lost here!	Iconeum
Iconeum	Would you host a party here?	No I don't think it would be appreciated.	BuJaber
BuJaber	Which animal would you pick from this list: Bear, Crocodile, Elephant, Monkey, Snake, Squid, Whale?	I'd pick snake.	Katyusha
Katyusha	What's that smell?	A faint of dry air.	Selynee
Selynee	Here for pleasure or work?	Work; but this is not my usual workplace.	BuJaber
BuJaber	What did you bring with you here?	Just the clothes on my back.	Not_Mafia
Not_Mafia	How much do you think this place has changed in the last 50 years?	It's pretty much the same as it's always been - though I guess most people didn't know about it before.	Felissan
Felissan	How will you feel once you get out of here?	Personally, my mood won't change much!	TheWorst
TheWorst	On a scale of 1 to 10 where 1 is obvspy and 10 is obvtown where do you think people should be reading you rn?	My guess would be 6. I believe I've given some details that would be impossible to know and difficult to deduce as spy.	Selynee
Selynee	Some people are talking about a small redecoration around here. Will you help them?	No, if it aint broke, don't fix it	Not_Mafia
Not_Mafia	If you could change one thing here, what would it be?	I'd increase the pay us employees get.	Aronis
Aronis	What's your favorite color?	Not technically a color, but I like black and white.	Iconeum
Iconeum	All this questioning is making me hungry and you promised to bring me food. What are you getting for me?	If you like steak, I have a really nice Bone-In Ribeye.	BuJaber
BuJaber	What would you tell your kids about this place?	They can come here when they miss people	Not_Mafia
Not_Mafia	Have you seen someone you didn’t expect here?	This place just lends itself to the crazy type.	Aronis
Aronis	Why would you come somewhere like this?	When you've gotta, you've gotta. I avoided it for as long as I could though	TheWorst
TheWorst	Could you please call a (lift/elevator) for me	Nobody in their right mind would even think about making an elevator shaft here.	Felissan
Felissan	When's the last time you came to another one of these?	Never been here before, luckily, and I hope it takes a while before I have to come here again.	Iconeum
Iconeum	Did you have any trouble getting here?		Aronis

[Katyusha]

tempted to vote you since i'd expect town to see why it's not tw under pressure but your last answer is decent

need to think tactically

[Iconeum]

ahhh I feel you
it's definitely one of Ico/Aronis imo

If majority goes Aronis I can help there, but i don't have a lynchpool outside of tw-aronis

[Katyusha]

Unofficial Vote Count

the worst

: Felissan, Aronis, Iconeum

Iconeum

: BuJaber, the worst

Aronis

: Katyusha

Not Voting: Selynee, Not_Mafia

Reminder: 6 votes are needed to officially accuse a spy and end the game.
The deadline stands as it is. ((expired on 2018-03-12 19:30:00) from now)

[Katyusha]

Felissan I think we need you rn

Selynee and N_M should vote

[Iconeum]

1.randomidget Iconeum
2.BuJaber

definitely not

3.Katyusha

probably not

4.Fellisan

definitely not

5.Selynee

definitely not

6.Aronis

likely spy

7.Not_Mafia

definitely not

8.the worst I just don't see it. If it's not aronis then I think it's the worst.

likely spy

[Katyusha]

fwiw i don't think compromise voting is a good idea - if we accuse the wrong suspect then the spy guessing wrong could be our last chance to win

pedit: if we're doing readlists at this point:

{TW, BuJaber}
{Felissan} (i know, but the above two have other factors that make me 100% on them while she's 99%)
{N_M, Selynee}
----
{Ico, Aronis}

[Katyusha]

ok


on further thought i dont think this how a spy in your position acts

worst let's get back on aronis

[Iconeum]

I still believe the best strategy here is simply not voting. Force the spy to guess. It's not gonna be an easy guess.
If we majority vote, the game ends. We either win right there and then, or we lose. If we vote wrong, the spy doesn't get to guess, he just outright wins.

Pushing the wrong vote will make the spy win.

Am I reading this wrong?

[Iconeum]

yeah, I'm right. If we guess wrong, spy auto wins. Let him have his guess.
If he outright knows the location already, he would have taken a guess.

UNLESS town is on the wrong lynch track, then he can just ride that 'lynch' to a victory

[Katyusha]

it's a pros/cons thing

pros of voting is that the spy doesn't get the chance to win on a wrong guess, cons is we're fucked if we pick wrong

pros of stalling is that the spy might get it wrong, cons is we may have given too much data

i'm pretty sure there's enough data to make a guess in 24 hours

pedit: I would think a townread spy stalls it out regardless, and even a scumread spy stalls if they can push a wagon that won't go through (the worst COUGH)

[Katyusha]

i really wish i didn't have to be cryptic about the worst as locktown

[Iconeum]

That's right, a spy would never guess before deadline, UNLESS they have a decent chance of being 'lynched'

OK i'm doing one more reread on the worst.

[Katyusha]

like i think a spy only reveals when someone slips (WOULD YOU SAY THIS PLACE IS........ SUPER?)

pedit: yeah

[the worst]

you're reading this right which is why you need to unvote me right now.
if the majority wagon is pushing on me I'll give away why I'm town af while giving away as little as possible about the location ;n;

cheeky meta pings on ico, he's not clear for me but... workingpeople of all countries unite, and all that! VOTE: Aronis

stealing Katyusha's idea my full reads are.....

{BuJaber, Selynee}
{Felissan, Katyusha}
{N_M}
----
{Ico, Aronis}

fite me

[the worst]

(WOULD YOU SAY THIS PLACE IS........ SUPER?)

it never gets old

[Iconeum]

205... I mean, it's a good case?

[Katyusha]

i think selynee being lower for me is part of why i have n_m higher LMFAO

pedit: no it's not.........................................

[the worst]

that is a bad case

[the worst]

i think selynee being lower for me is part of why i have n_m higher LMFAO

if I'm reading inbetween the lines right here, this is why N_M is out of my lynchpool :3

[Katyusha]

sounds like it!

[Iconeum]

VOTE: aronis

personally would be happier to let the spy have his guess at deadline, because I'm not sure here myself.

This game is harder then I thought it would be

[Iconeum]

I'll try to prove I'm not the spy right here and now:

Look at my earlier readlist, and where my vote was (or where I was willing to vote). Compare that to my list now, and see what changed.

[the worst]

Buj has nailed it a few times with his theoryposting, hunt through that if you want some food for thought
the way I've played if you're town you SHOULD be able to work out what is motivating me to post the way I'm posting

[Felissan]

In terms of answers, TW is the only one I wouldn't be uncomfortable lynching, since everyone else has made it very obvious they know where we are. That includes Aronis - his answers might seem counterintuitive, but I can think of a specific role that's very likely to be in the place's role pool, where they all fit perfectly. TW's answers, on the other hand, would fit this place just as much as an iceberg or a WW1 trench, as he hasn't given a single detail other than the place being generally unpleasant, which is free info with everything that was said so far. I'm not changing votes until he gives a better answer to a question.