[Meta] Newbie Experience (Formerly IC replace rate thread)

[Espeonage]

I have definitely felt that the IC has been doing a shit job while I was an SE. And I ha e tried to time my SE sign up to be in newbie games with poor ICs or ICs whose skill and knowledge I don't respect to attempt to improve the quality of the teaching experience. That said I do not have any completed IC games under my belt so my teaching ability is of an undefined level.

I feel like the most important thing an IC wants is retention of players as the site loses traffic.

I have always liked ICs that do debriefs post game.

I however favour a model that has the IC outside the game who is able to answer basic questions on theory.