Open 720: NOIR (GAME OVER)

[the worst]

In general your content has been lacking and your read list has been very inoffensive. We're less than 48 hrs into the game so I'm not super worried about people's ability to scumhunt or anything but from a holistic pov I'm like ._.

[the worst]

Strong town read

fumuki-I know he claimed scum, but this guy is obv!town.

town reads

(less light, not strong)
vivi - reasons

town lean

Alonzo - no change
korina - I was getting comfortable with a town read but then 208 happened
sando - He and I independently arrived at the same conclusion about mutantdevle, at least until Sando did the meta read through). I like a lot of his thought processes, even though I don't actually agree with some (most?) of his conclusions. This is difference in opinion on what is/isn't alignment indicative.

null

mutantdevle - I'm townleaning this conditional on him having played 0 games with fumuki and conditional on me reading that game that got linked of his.
the worst - He's really helpful. Not so sure about the scumhunting.
Quick - I kind of want to say he really did town slip, but ehh there will be better things to build a read on.

I probably agree Fumuki is a good townread. Ceejay is fine. Sando and Korina are fine. Alonzo null at best. Quick read I don't like much

[the worst]

What do you think about the duckling not really game solving?

Why this post, talk me through what made you think it was a good idea to ask pingpongchurro

[pinturicchio]

lolol you better make some great hats this game.

What do you think about the duckling not really game solving?

Actually, Duckling/Not_Mafia is my first conspiracy theory of this game. I was townreading Duckling for his suspicions on Mutant as I'm scumleaning him too, but I now noticed that he said something like "I may be biased about him" and me no likey.

Duckling's RVS vote was on Not_Mafia and his next interaction with him was "Oh i forgot you were here!"; Ducking says he would policy lynch NM if we don't have a better scumread, then says the benefits and cons of policy lynching NM.

Duckling start building a townbloc with Quick, Sando and someone else, pretty early game to start doing this, and Quick seems a good player to pocket

[pinturicchio]

pingpongchurro

These are getting out of hand, and I love it

[Oxy]

@the worst He's here. I'm here. I want him to talk. I like Pin as a person and want to play with him. What do you think about Korina's 208?

p.edit @sordicchio How did I know you would go there with your first? Am I starting to think like you???? Why is Quick a good pocket?

[the worst]

Do you find asking evasive players very specific questions is a good way of sorting them?

[the worst]

@the worst He's here. I'm here. I want him to talk. I like Pin as a person and want to play with him. What do you think about Korina's 208?

Garbo tbh.
you?

[pinturicchio]

p.edit @sordicchio How did I know you would go there with your first? Am I starting to think like you???? Why is Quick a good pocket?

Tinfoil hat is a way of life, yo.

About Quick, he's loud. These are the best players to pocket, for they are hard to mislynch from scum perspective, and they can push mislynches for you and get away with it. So if Duck/NM are scum, they will give him an early townread (both of them have done this) and try to do some inception shit on him so he goes to the wrong directions

[the worst]

Hilariously, I just finished a scumgame with NM the other week. Want a link?

[Oxy]

Yes. The specificity of the question should be inversely proportional to the ease-of-engagement factor for the player being questioned. It's all in my book, Marrington on Mafia.

p.edit @the worst same. do you scum read him?

[Oxy]

No, I've read enough Not_Mafia.

[the worst]

Thats a lotta words, Im a simple fluffy baby bird

Is this your firsr scum game?

[Oxy]

I'm sorry the joke went over your head =/

[the worst]

Na I'm nulltownish on Korina. His content is hard to gauge consistent feeling from so far. Still early days but I like more than I dislike I think.

All the same people pretending to have reads on him needa chillllll

[the worst]

Yes. The specificity of the question should be inversely proportional to the ease-of-engagement factor for the player being questioned. It's all in my book, Marrington on Mafia.

p.edit @the worst same. do you scum read him?

Thats a lotta words, Im a simple fluffy baby bird

Is this your firsr scum game?

What makes you think that went over my head?

[Quick]

Strong town read

fumuki-I know he claimed scum, but this guy is obv!town.

I think you are judging them far too quickly. This is a player who has a lot of Skill and I would not just presume they are Town.

town reads

(less light, not strong)
vivi - reasons

Oh a person I didn't know was playing, how nice.

town lean

Alonzo - no change

I have no idea how you have this read on them.

korina - I was getting comfortable with a town read but then 208 happened

I would put this a lot higher, but you do you.

sando - He and I independently arrived at the same conclusion about mutantdevle, at least until Sando did the meta read through). I like a lot of his thought processes, even though I don't actually agree with some (most?) of his conclusions. This is difference in opinion on what is/isn't alignment indicative.

He's an ultra vet and you are judging him way WAY too quickly.

null

mutantdevle - I'm townleaning this conditional on him having played 0 games with fumuki and conditional on me reading that game that got linked of his.

OK, so based on these "conditions" how would you read them?

the worst - He's really helpful. Not so sure about the scumhunting.

Good point on the Scum hunting here, but they seem to have pretty believable thought process.

Quick - I kind of want to say he really did town slip, but ehh there will be better things to build a read on.

I don't mind this.

[pinturicchio]

Hilariously, I just finished a scumgame with NM the other week. Want a link?

Funny you ask when you already posted a game where you were town and NM was scum.

Sure, gimme some links. Do you have the scum PT of that game? Better yet if you have this game's scum PT

[the worst]

Many words

I read every word of this.

What were you hoping to achieve with this post?

If you had to guess what Quick wanted to achieve with this post, what would your guess be?

I'm enjoying talking to you btw

[the worst]

viewtopic.php?f=23&t=75184
game link

viewtopic.php?f=90&t=75173
scum pt

Check your inbox for this game's

[Oxy]

Oh a person I didn't know was playing, how nice.

Vivi:

Spoiler:

[Oxy]

OK, so based on these "conditions" how would you read them

0 games with fumuki plus I don't find a meta reason to scumread, and I would town lean him. (like i said in the line about him)

[the worst]

If I remember I'll reply in detail tonight

Phoneposting at work most of the time when youre all on

[Oxy]

Many words

I read every word of this.

What were you hoping to achieve with this post?

If you had to guess what Quick wanted to achieve with this post, what would your guess be?

I'm enjoying talking to you btw

Nah. I thought the post had already been responded to, and have interrupted enough. Let them have their interaction.

And I, you!

[Quick]

p.edit @sordicchio How did I know you would go there with your first? Am I starting to think like you???? Why is Quick a good pocket?

Tinfoil hat is a way of life, yo.

About Quick, he's loud. These are the best players to pocket, for they are hard to mislynch from scum perspective, and they can push mislynches for you and get away with it. So if Duck/NM are scum, they will give him an early townread (both of them have done this) and try to do some inception shit on him so he goes to the wrong directions

M8, it sounds like you know I am Town here. I'm half tempted to jump off NM just for this!