Open 720: NOIR (GAME OVER)

[Mathdino]

Votecount 1-9

pinturicchio

-

(1)

: Not_Mafia

mutantdevle

--

(2)

: Iconeum, pinturicchio

Oxy

----------

(3)

: Korina

the worst

----

(2)

: Oxy, Alonzo

Sando

--------

(1)

: Quick

Iconeum

------

(3)

: MOMOMEN, the worst, Sando

Not Voting

---

(3)

: randomidget, ceejayvinoya, mutantdevle

With 13 alive, it takes 7 to lynch.

Deadline: (expired on 2018-04-24 12:00:00)

Mod Notes:

- None!

[Quick]

How on earth is

Oxy

Sando the Scummiest person in the game when you have:
duck
NM
Spartan slot
Pin
Korina

Kgo!

Now you are shifting the goal post.

[Quick]

Pretty much all your arguments are based on a "reasonable" PoV and given people in general are NOT rational

Hahahahaha, you're definitely being nominated for funniest scumread.

So I'm too rational for you and that must be scummy. Righto.

This is a misrep if I ever saw one.

[Quick]

the duck has a good wolf game. they might be the deepwolf i was missing. adding them to unsorted. ice is likely wolf here. N_M feels not as appeasing as his scum game. he's egging on violence rather than trying to be more peaceful town.

i'll have game locked soon enough. VOTE: Ice

This post sucks eggs.

[Quick]

Finally, something fun to read instead of that painful 1v1 between Quick and Sandro

Hydra, what do you think about Not Mafia? Have you played with him before?

In my experience when I am in a "painful to read" 1v1 with someone they are really likely to be Scum.

[Quick]

I'm super confused by the Quick + Oxy team here, it makes zero of the senses.

I'm cool with Ico.

VOTE: Iconeum

Momo I haven't seen your read on Oxy?

This is really really bad. Pretty much naked vote after Sando and I hashed out for like 2 pages our read on Oxy. So for Sando to just up and "I will vote lurker now" is not a good look at all.

[Quick]

The dude literally SRs and nitpicks me because he finds my posting style disagreeable idek what else to do here

I think I know what he is doing. I think your fine. Some things you have done kinda worry me, but on the whole I like you for Town.

[Oxy]

Have a few minutes this morning.

viewtopic.php?f=3&t=75246

There we go
I attribute it largely to confidence, I am new.

i only got one question. why are you bussing your partner?

Hm?

I'd expect town to react with amusement, not "what was that?". His Majesty's question is pretty plain. I'm sure if you reacted with just your post 769 Oxy would have ignored you.

Pretty much any other reaction. I've been thinking that the "lol, who's your partner" type questions are useless as reaction tests because no one fails them, but I was wrong!

[Oxy]

UNVOTE: Quick

In all honesty (since I'm mobile posting rn), that was a pressure/reaction vote.
I wanted to see what people would do in reaction to what I said.

I'll post what I got from it later when I have my laptop.

Also NM being trolly fuck again, I see.

This post is Scummy af... who else thinks so?

I thought it was pretty bad - pointed it out earlier. That korina town read started falling off as soon as I gave it.

[Eddie Cane]

@quick I've never played with a hydra before. Any advice on dealing with them? Like just treat them like anyone else?

I don't distinguish between heads when I play with Hydra's. That said, it's probably Eddie talking.

Nope, this ismy first post and ego. I'll log into the hydra and catch up later busy rn

[Oxy]

mutant's reaction is not that of someone who's played with Fumuki before

Correct, I haven't played with Fumuki before. Looking at his join date I wouldn't have thought anyone has (unless you count on going games). It always takes me a while to adjust to troll posters. Eg. I didn't realise Not_Mafia was a shit poster until halfway through the first game I played with him.

Do not like the lack of possibility that Fumuki could be an alt. Don't like that at all.

I thought this was a safe assumption. Isn't there a way to know if someone has other accts? sorry for newb

[Oxy]

Wait so now him pushing against my TR is, in fact, rational?

You can make this argument if you want, but it's going to get pretty thick in here if you do.

Lol nah I don't really care, that was just a troll, this has gone way too far down the rabbit hole to be useful, and he's stated himself it wasn't a rational conversation. I'm comfortable with where I'm at, he's staying in my lynch list, and I've gotten out of this what I wanted.

I seriously don't get the Town motivation here of Sando not wanting to hash out his biggest SR.

Is being stubborn always alignment indicative?

Like, I can completely see his reaction to your pressure coming from stubborn town. What motivation does scum!Sando get from laughing you off when you say you have trashed his read and that town!sando should reconsider?

I dunno, it's definitely not an unambiguously rational play from either alignment (lol)

[Oxy]

I'm super confused by the Quick + Oxy team here, it makes zero of the senses.

I'm cool with Ico.

VOTE: Iconeum

Momo I haven't seen your read on Oxy?

This is really really bad. Pretty much naked vote after Sando and I hashed out for like 2 pages our read on Oxy. So for Sando to just up and "I will vote lurker now" is not a good look at all.

okay yeah, this is not a good look

[Quick]

mutant's reaction is not that of someone who's played with Fumuki before

Correct, I haven't played with Fumuki before. Looking at his join date I wouldn't have thought anyone has (unless you count on going games). It always takes me a while to adjust to troll posters. Eg. I didn't realise Not_Mafia was a shit poster until halfway through the first game I played with him.

Do not like the lack of possibility that Fumuki could be an alt. Don't like that at all.

I thought this was a safe assumption. Isn't there a way to know if someone has other accts? sorry for newb

Only reason I bring it up is cuz I have someone in mind, but given they are not in many other games, that read is pending. Theory is they want to just play certain roles with that alt, but that's tin foil, admittedly.

[Eddie Cane]

I have some feels on some of the players who have posted so far, but keeping those gut reads to myself for the time being.

This feels like you are trying too hard.

VOTE: Fast

Nah, it is just quick being obnoxious. He's good at that.

[Oxy]

mutant's reaction is not that of someone who's played with Fumuki before

Correct, I haven't played with Fumuki before. Looking at his join date I wouldn't have thought anyone has (unless you count on going games). It always takes me a while to adjust to troll posters. Eg. I didn't realise Not_Mafia was a shit poster until halfway through the first game I played with him.

Do not like the lack of possibility that Fumuki could be an alt. Don't like that at all.

I thought this was a safe assumption. Isn't there a way to know if someone has other accts? sorry for newb

Only reason I bring it up is cuz I have someone in mind, but given they are not in many other games, that read is pending. Theory is they want to just play certain roles with that alt, but that's tin foil, admittedly.

Oh - is this taking into consideration that Fumuki replaced out? Because he did that across all of his games, so that's NAI.

[Quick]

mutant's reaction is not that of someone who's played with Fumuki before

Correct, I haven't played with Fumuki before. Looking at his join date I wouldn't have thought anyone has (unless you count on going games). It always takes me a while to adjust to troll posters. Eg. I didn't realise Not_Mafia was a shit poster until halfway through the first game I played with him.

Do not like the lack of possibility that Fumuki could be an alt. Don't like that at all.

I thought this was a safe assumption. Isn't there a way to know if someone has other accts? sorry for newb

Only reason I bring it up is cuz I have someone in mind, but given they are not in many other games, that read is pending. Theory is they want to just play certain roles with that alt, but that's tin foil, admittedly.

Oh - is this taking into consideration that Fumuki replaced out? Because he did that across all of his games, so that's NAI.

I didn't know if we were allowed to say that or not.

That said, if you are looking for it, it's pretty easy to see that Fumuki could very well be an alt here.

[Oxy]

In post 328, mutantdevle wrote:
In post 181, Sando wrote:
mutant's reaction is not that of someone who's played with Fumuki before

Correct, I haven't played with Fumuki before. Looking at his join date I wouldn't have thought anyone has (unless you count on going games). It always takes me a while to adjust to troll posters. Eg. I didn't realise Not_Mafia was a shit poster until halfway through the first game I played with him.

Actually, I don't think this is dependent on Fumuki being an alt.

Either way it's an unknown name and play style, and that is what mutant would have been reacting to here.

[Quick]

In post 328, mutantdevle wrote:
In post 181, Sando wrote:
mutant's reaction is not that of someone who's played with Fumuki before

Correct, I haven't played with Fumuki before. Looking at his join date I wouldn't have thought anyone has (unless you count on going games). It always takes me a while to adjust to troll posters. Eg. I didn't realise Not_Mafia was a shit poster until halfway through the first game I played with him.

Actually, I don't think this is dependent on Fumuki being an alt.

Either way it's an unknown name and play style, and that is what mutant would have been reacting to here.

Uh... quote fail?

[MOMOMEN]

Read page 9: Oxy and Quick are town. NM town lean actually. CJ and Mutant scum lean.

I can't do a proper catchup because some DUMBO didn't give me the hydra PW lmao.

Read Page 17: Sando, Oxy, Quick, slight NM town. CJ, Mutant, Worst, Ico scum lean. No idea on Pintu, Korina, Random, Alonzo

Caught up: Oxy and Quick are still town, so Sando either needs to fuck off with that or lose his town status. NM seemed townie from the couple posts they had, but its the weakest read possible and if trackvig chooses vig he should be shot tonight on policy. My reads are mostly still the same; CJ, Mutant, Worst, and Ico is my scum pool, and the fact KTS got to the same conclusion is awesome because I did NOT read his posts before catching up nor have we communicated aside from meming. I don't know how to read Korina aside from "annoying", Pintu seems very slight town I guess ???, I will need to check but if I'm remembering right Random dislikes scum so that's a thing for why he hasn't posted yet (not voting there today though because he's the only player in this game I have any respect for or knowledge of going into the game who knows maybe one of you will earn that by the end!), Alonzo is a scum lean I guess I didn't Tr any of his content and KTS has him as scum.

[MOMOMEN]

what game did we play tw? idr.

newbs, dont take advice from lq. there's an argument to be made for ONLY outing scumreads d1 (dont tell scum who to kill) unless your townreads get wagoned. Only doing townreads is stupid. nobody cares how accurate you are, first of all your trs are like 75% likely to be right anyways on math and second of you're wrong on one it doesn't matter because scum will kill the others. I do full reads lists d1 becaus people BoP me and I like it anyways, but only trs is stupid. if you know you are often wrong with scumreads learn when to sheep people and that's that.

[Quick]

Why on earth is NM Town?

BoP... ROTFLMAO.

[MOMOMEN]

I will post below assuming I am vt. if I am a pr, its referring to me in the third person.

trackvig, if we lynch a scum today pick tracker 100% of the time. if we dont, your call. we will know tomorrow if there's a vig kill anyways. if you pick vig make sure you aren't retarded that's about it

hider, make sure u have good crumbs. I think it might be optimal for every player itg to do something like hide behind the person after them on the game list so hide doesn't need to crumb and not get caught, I'll think on it.

docpsych good luck. no advice to give.

mafia, kill us n1. my only advive to you.

[the worst]

Cool hydra obvtown

It was resistance and you yelled at me then Katyusha rolled us lmk if you want the link

[MOMOMEN]

I remember now ya, it was the only marathon game I played properly

I dont think you're town though my guy.