Open 724 - Pick Your Power X/Y [Endgame]

[Eddie Cane]

Taly is one of the most obnoxious people ive seen lmao what the fuck

It's like that kid who tells the teacher you came in 30 seconds late or rattles on you for shoving Jimmy

[Ircher]

D1 Taly Full Readslist

Town

Math - Strong Townread

- While I don't fully agree with their approach on setup right now, I think it's largely based on playstyle and I feel like he's put forth a strong voice within the playerlist and he's done the most to expand on his thinking. He's also thought of the other possibilities in a game which tells me he's looking beyond the surface level in order to solve it.

Fair enough.

Ircher - Strong Townread

- I think I've beat this to death so far,

if anyone has questions; then

PLEASE TALK TO ME.

Janitor - Moderate Townread

- Very similar case; don't agree with the suspicion on them and I feel like they're actively working to gamesolve.

I mean, I do agree they are putting forth some effort and are trying to some extent to gamesolve.... But at the same time, I don't think they are actually keen on solving the game... Not sure if you understand what I'm saying here...

Ausuka - Moderate Townread

- I'm pretty familiar with

Ausuka

; her being quick to try and gauge for information through wagons while also going into great depth about her perceptions give this a solid townread on her. This is partially meta, but with in-thread game evidence, I feel like this is town either way.

Okay.

the worst - Moderate Townread

- Slightly questioning this a bit; but I think the worst's mentality of being laid back while engaging is town-motivated. I think he's pushing boundaries in order to improve his vision of the game.

Any particular reason you are questioning this?

Eddie - Slight Townread

- Made self a very prominent presence amongst their little time being among the playerlist. Giving reads and most definitely displaying a forward gamesolve standpoint.

Not sure I would consider this a strong enough reason to townread a person, but okay.

Null/Questioning

Saske - Not Confident, Lean Town

- Probably one of the most volatile reads I have. I don't always see the reasoning behind their thoughts and I feel like they've voted with the flow of the town. However, they have been responsive and they are generating assessments to help further the gamestate. I had a hard time placing this as town or not.

I can see where you are at; however, I kinda consider them more of a town leader versus going with the flow. Furthermore, I feel they are actively trying to gamesolve and are careful not to be too judgement, and they are always open to discussions.

Dave - Not Confident, Lean Town

- I don't like to read replacements like their predecessors. I was iffy on

Almost50

but I felt they were genuine. I also feel the same thing for

Dave

, but they haven't posted enough to sway me strongly.

Interesting...

Mylo - Null

- Similar to my

Dave

read but with a lot less content to judge off of.

Makes sense. Any thoughts on Beefster though? (I'm sure you provided them before...)

Mutant - Not Confident, Lean Scum

- They're borderline voteparking on

Ircher

, someone I strongly feel is town, and while I do like they're content through Page 10, I haven't seen much beyond that that strikes me as towny.

Also an interesting read....

Scum

Lovebird - Slight Scumread

- Literally posts

"this is town" and "this is scum"

without giving reasons and then disappears. Unhelpful, and I question how genuine their reads are.

I think this is how Lovebird plays in general, so I don't think this is alignment-indicative?

Iconeum - Slight Scumread

- Probably the least confident of the scumreads, they're the most forward players out of my scumreads. But I still don't get their insistence on

Janitor

or their read progression.

Not sure if I agree with this read or where it is coming from... Are you sure this isn't just a case of "I disagree with their reads, so I think they are scum?" (It happens from time to time for all of us.)

Lalendra - Slight Scumread

- Mash my

Lovebird and Mylo

read together while looking at how quickly built their wagon was created, and then weakened - and that makes me think this is a worthy potential lynch and scum.

Interesting...

:/ My townreads are stronger than my scumreads currently, which I don't like at all, but I'm working to change that.

Of course, several reads are liable to change soon.

Comments are bolded and in purple.

[Mathdino]

Im not seeing the analogy, what part

[Taly]

Scum
Lovebird - Slight Scumread - Literally posts "this is town" and "this is scum" without giving reasons and then disappears. Unhelpful, and I question how genuine their reads are.

Lol.

Yeah responses like these aren't changing my mind in the slighest.

You really think those things you said had to do with if I'm scum?

Yeah I do, you're making definitive statements without going in full depth about your reasons or questions, and your responses thus far have been vague.

Your posts serve to generate a dichotomy or a discredit because you've also kept your vote on

Ausuka

since 273 without going into depth on why she's scum to you. I'd like you to elaborate on your thoughts in full.

Taly is one of the most obnoxious people ive seen lmao what the fuck

It's like that kid who tells the teacher you came in 30 seconds late or rattles on you for shoving Jimmy

Respond to my question on your

Janitor, Lovebird, Dave and Ircher

reads and maybe I'll entertain you.

[Ircher]

Why not? It is not necessarily (at least imo) that you have acted scummy so much as being hard to read.

I'm not hard to read. People done it easily before.

Yeah, but you are hard

for me

to read.

[Eddie Cane]

This isn't how you played before.

Why is Ausuka scum? And Ico? And you townread a scummy slot. Hng. Fos Lovebird.

Played before when?

Boon game.

Oh yeah. Idk what difference you see. My games are too much reading now, though.

You were a much more relevant presence there from memory. You also correctly sorted my slot and generally gave me the impression you're a decent player. Here you have done jack ehit and your reads are almost backwards from mine.

Also yes, taly, you're scumreading playstyle.

[Lovebird]

Your posts serve to generate a dichotomy or a discredit because you've also kept your vote on Ausuka since 273 without going into depth on why she's scum to you. I'd like you to elaborate on your thoughts in full.

What?

[Ircher]

Just let it slide @Lovebird

[Lovebird]

This isn't how you played before.

Why is Ausuka scum? And Ico? And you townread a scummy slot. Hng. Fos Lovebird.

Played before when?

Boon game.

Oh yeah. Idk what difference you see. My games are too much reading now, though.

You were a much more relevant presence there from memory. You also correctly sorted my slot and generally gave me the impression you're a decent player. Here you have done jack ehit and your reads are almost backwards from mine.

Also yes, taly, you're scumreading playstyle.

This game is faster. Or maybe I just have less time.

Maybe you're scum. Or maybe I'm just dense.

[Eddie Cane]

Scum
Lovebird - Slight Scumread - Literally posts "this is town" and "this is scum" without giving reasons and then disappears. Unhelpful, and I question how genuine their reads are.

Lol.

Yeah responses like these aren't changing my mind in the slighest.

You really think those things you said had to do with if I'm scum?

Yeah I do, you're making definitive statements without going in full depth about your reasons or questions, and your responses thus far have been vague.

Your posts serve to generate a dichotomy or a discredit because you've also kept your vote on

Ausuka

since 273 without going into depth on why she's scum to you. I'd like you to elaborate on your thoughts in full.

Taly is one of the most obnoxious people ive seen lmao what the fuck

It's like that kid who tells the teacher you came in 30 seconds late or rattles on you for shoving Jimmy

Respond to my question on your

Janitor, Lovebird, Dave and Ircher

reads and maybe I'll entertain you.

Hmm.. Dunno, try reading my catchup? I talked about my reads on all of these except Dave who is a townread via Mathdinkle. Dont ask me stupid shit.

[Lovebird]

Why not? It is not necessarily (at least imo) that you have acted scummy so much as being hard to read.

I'm not hard to read. People done it easily before.

Yeah, but you are hard

for me

to read.

Ok, makes sense for you. But, just for you being hard isn't reason to vig me.

Just let it slide @Lovebird

Idk what you mean.

[Eddie Cane]

This isn't how you played before.

Why is Ausuka scum? And Ico? And you townread a scummy slot. Hng. Fos Lovebird.

Played before when?

Boon game.

Oh yeah. Idk what difference you see. My games are too much reading now, though.

You were a much more relevant presence there from memory. You also correctly sorted my slot and generally gave me the impression you're a decent player. Here you have done jack ehit and your reads are almost backwards from mine.

Also yes, taly, you're scumreading playstyle.

This game is faster. Or maybe I just have less time.

Maybe you're scum. Or maybe I'm just dense.

I'll look back on that game when I'm on a computer and get back to you.

[Lovebird]

Subject: Vengeful Mafia (2x games) - GAME OVER

VOTE: Ausuka

Serious vote.

Subject: Mini Theme 2001: Mafia Month [game over]

VOTE: ausuka

[Ircher]

Meta based read on Ausuka? Sorry, I'm too lazy to actually conduct metadives; instead, I construct a working sense of one's meta.

[Mathdino]

Taly is one of the most obnoxious people ive seen lmao what the fuck

It's like that kid who tells the teacher you came in 30 seconds late or rattles on you for shoving Jimmy

Im not seeing the analogy, what part

[Eddie Cane]

nitpicking kverprivelegaed generally annoying to talk to or coexist with

I gave an analogy because I dont wnat to be toxic

[Mathdino]

How do you deduce percentages of someone being scum FROM RANDOMIZED NUMBERS?

i just wanna quote/pagebottom this for emphasis on hilarity:

taly seems to think that the draft numbers are randomized

[Taly]

Ircher

901

1) Janitor Comment:

I can see where you're coming from but I feel he's genuine and IS actively working to help perception in the game and solve it, so I do feel a townread is warranted.

2) The Worst Comment:

Don't know about their votes, I don't see a lot of independent thinking here, but I still think the majority of their posts come from a town mentality.

3) Eddie Cane Comment: Eddie

was one person I was wondering if they would be in the null category; though I don't see the scum motivation behind their posts from what I've seen so far.

4) Mylo Comment:

I don't like to read someone based on predecessors but I did agree with

Beefster

questioning the early setup spec, and I did feel like his posts were more likely town, but I haven't seen enough to solidify it.

5) Mutant/Lalendra Comments:

What's interesting about my reads there? What is your read on these two?

6) Lovebird Comment:

Elaborated on this in 903, let me know if that still doesn't clear things up for you.

7) Iconeum Comment:

This is why he's my least confident scumread, though I still want to see more before I fully rethink my stance.

Respond to my question on your

Janitor, Lovebird, Dave and Ircher

reads and maybe I'll entertain you.

Hmm.. Dunno, try reading my catchup? I talked about my reads on all of these except Dave who is a townread via Mathdinkle. Dont ask me stupid shit.

I did and my question still stands. Fucking explain them.

[Taly]

nitpicking kverprivelegaed generally annoying to talk to or coexist with

I gave an analogy because I dont wnat to be toxic

How do you deduce percentages of someone being scum FROM RANDOMIZED NUMBERS?

i just wanna quote/pagebottom this for emphasis on hilarity:

taly seems to think that the draft numbers are randomized

Yeah, I put up content

SOLELY

to get shit on.

[Eddie Cane]

yes the random caps and bold are annoying

but actually simyk is the one who told me taly is a really good player, so maybe we should look at her reads. What's wrong with Mutant? Ircher has 4 or 5 votes now including from some of your townreads (Mathdino particularly). Uou pointed nothing scummy out other than that. Also, trust me, I know Simyk very well and they're town. One of the people I can easiest read on site.

[Eddie Cane]

nitpicking kverprivelegaed generally annoying to talk to or coexist with

I gave an analogy because I dont wnat to be toxic

How do you deduce percentages of someone being scum FROM RANDOMIZED NUMBERS?

i just wanna quote/pagebottom this for emphasis on hilarity:

taly seems to think that the draft numbers are randomized

Yeah, I put up content

SOLELY

to get shit on.

OKAY your posts are

good

I'm

SORRY

[Eddie Cane]

The answer to 917 is no by the way.

[Ircher]

5) Mutant/Lalendra Comments: What's interesting about my reads there? What is your read on these two?

6) Lovebird Comment: Elaborated on this in 903, let me know if that still doesn't clear things up for you.

5) I have a readslist somewhere... Just ISO me cuz I'm too lazy
6) I still disagree; I think that is a playstyle thing for Lovebird, to give reads without explanations; no one else seems to be having issues with it.

[Taly]

If you're going to state problems you have with my gameplay then at least ATTEMPT to give a semi-impartial analysis.

yes the random caps and bold are annoying

but actually simyk is the one who told me taly is a really good player, so maybe we should look at her reads. What's wrong with Mutant? Ircher has 4 or 5 votes now including from some of your townreads (Mathdino particularly). Uou pointed nothing scummy out other than that. Also, trust me, I know Simyk very well and they're town. One of the people I can easiest read on site.

I don't bold on people's accord; if it's really that big of a deal then copy/paste my text somewhere and read it.

I'm not angry or trying to create an unreadable space, I bold and caps so I can get people's attention. Apparently, not always worthwhile ones.

And I did state my

Mutant

read clearly so far, I'd like to see them do something other than push an older wagon and I've seen

SIMYK

and

Mathdino

do more than that.

Furthermore, I don't know

SIMYK

much at all and I don't think they're clearly town like you do, so instead of dodging my question

EXPLAIN YOUR OTHER READS IN DEPTH TOO.

5) Mutant/Lalendra Comments: What's interesting about my reads there? What is your read on these two?

6) Lovebird Comment: Elaborated on this in 903, let me know if that still doesn't clear things up for you.

5) I have a readslist somewhere... Just ISO me cuz I'm too lazy
6) I still disagree; I think that is a playstyle thing for Lovebird, to give reads without explanations; no one else seems to be having issues with it.

So you're thinking this is more meta-based for

Lovebird

? I haven't seen enough to think otherwise, so I'd like to see some more explanation.

[Taly]

nitpicking kverprivelegaed generally annoying to talk to or coexist with

I gave an analogy because I dont wnat to be toxic

How do you deduce percentages of someone being scum FROM RANDOMIZED NUMBERS?

i just wanna quote/pagebottom this for emphasis on hilarity:

taly seems to think that the draft numbers are randomized

Yeah, I put up content

SOLELY

to get shit on.

OKAY your posts are

good

I'm

SORRY

Yeah, I'm already reminded once again for being

TALKED DOWN TO

for the

SECOND

time this game.

The answer to 917 is no by the way.

Cool. -_-