Open 71 - Jester Mafia (FINISHED!!!) before 586

[Surye]

/con-to-the-firm

[Surye]

All Abord.

Vote: Hasdgfas

[Surye]

Meh, L-3 isn't scary, I'm surprised anyone even made a fuss of it. Where would you have me place my vote then?

[Surye]

Lquiz, I hope you can back up what you've done, if you're jester, you're dumb and won't get lynched, and scum will just off you tonight, if you are scum and trying to look like the jester, and you don't die tonight, you'll get lynched tomorrow...

[Surye]

/prodded.

I would really like to comment, but I see nothing worth commenting on.

You have got to be kidding me.

What? it's mostly "playstyle", "LQuiz is jester" and "random voting is bad". Until something else happens, I think I'll stay on the sidelines.

I wonder if this scum-tell is supposed to be this obvious...

[Surye]

Lquiz didn't overreact to my post, and is not being too insistant, so I think I'll buy he was joking for now.

Given that,

FoS: Natriasha

, but I'm not sure for what anti-town role yet. I have a feeling he's too smart to be using "I think I'll stay on the sidelines" as scum, so I am leaning to Jester-tell, but even then, only 30% sure on that one.

[Surye]

What? it's mostly "playstyle", "LQuiz is jester" and "random voting is bad". Until something else happens, I think I'll stay on the sidelines.

Well I'd say let's get you involved. See how you handle the hot water. If you were town surely you'd be actively sniffing scums out rather than sitting out on the sidelines?

Vote: Natriasha

But, outside LQuiz, I've found nothing that screams "scummy", and even his is more "jester!" So, um...yeah.[/quote]

So you want the rest of us to not post when nothing screams "scummy"? Where would we be? How about you play the game too, thanks.

[Surye]

And I forgot to fix the damn quote D:

[Surye]

guys, Natirasha is scum and Lquiz is Jester.

This is correct. I'm ready to lynch Nat when I'm convinced we won't be able to find his buddy today.

[Surye]

Welp, how I see it, Celeb is either scum, or Jester. I doubt he would hammer his buddy like that against the grain, so Jester seems highly likely.

Or he honestly made that mistake. But I'm a little concerned about believe that as a given.

[Surye]

So, either you are breaking the rules [play to win] or you're using a really lame defense, and now I'm happy and confident of this lynch.

[Surye]

Not to mention the HUGE WIFOM this attempts to create. I honestly don't care at this point if Celeb's vote goes through, it'll be good to get some scum lynched.

[Surye]

Lquiz was masquerading as Jester, he's definitely scum.

On a side note, we lynched a Jester, WHILE THE JESTER HAD A VOTE ON HIMSELF. We suck.

[Surye]

Take note of the order of voters when i'm found to be townie.

Wow, this is pretty scummy Lquiz.

[Surye]

Take note of the order of voters when i'm found to be townie.

Wow, this is pretty scummy Lquiz.

Yes, everything i seem to do in this game is "scummy" accroding to you. Do you think accusing other people is a good way of taking the heat off yourself? You never say anything as to WHY it's scummy, and i;m starting to think you're pretty scummy, you and Inquisitor, always flawlessly backing eachother up, i wouldn't be the least bit suprised if you're the mafia.

Vote: Surye

You're making such silly mistakes, I forget I should elaborate, sorry.

It is never good, especially this early, to be thrown in the towel as town, and threaten the voters. Of course if you came up town we would examine the voting patterns, this IS mafia after all. All your post serves to do is try to scare off voters.

Nice try.

[Surye]

The purpose of any defensive post is to scare off voters, purely by making it clear that by killing a townie, they will have doomed themselves.

And your post even CLOSE to proves you are town how? All you are saying is "Lynch me to find out I am town", which is not very pro-town, ESPECIALLY in this small of a game.

You did not use logic to dissuade voters, you threatened them, that is different. That is scummy.

[Surye]

This game is dead. The only reason i'm being suspected is because i post often, there are only 4/10 of us saying anything.

No, you were suspected when all you post is scummy things. :/ This included.

[Surye]

Too bad we didn't flip the lynch order. Oh well, hammer was well orchestrated, so no suspicions there yet.

Seems like as we got closer to the end, Inquisitor JL was bussing LQuiz. Lets see what the night holds..

[Surye]

And Celeb's play feels a bit bussy to me too.

[Surye]

What? I was congratulating the scum for winning. "Scum for the win!"

Ah, well, I misunderstood, we'll see at night fall. Anyways, you're pretty arrogant to think you dieing means we loose after we showed you we were not lynch or lose.

[Surye]

Hmmm.. This is not good. We've had so many bad plays, I'm losing faith in this game. I really hope town starts playing town (and stops hammering jesters ;P).

I will do a reread tonight, but the high replace rate in this game is making it hard to see consistancy in play also.

[Surye]

Funny how this is now the same setup as the Newbie game with 2 scum and 5 town =)

I actually like that idea, it's like a game with context, and no random voting stage.

[Surye]

CO and Celeb feel like there's some forced distancing going on. Celeb is on my suspicion list for obvious reasons.

It looks like CO is ready to bus Celeb even

[Surye]

you all want to believe I'm scum then just do it and find out that you just lynched another townie.

*wince* I really hate when people say that. I would vote you on that alone, but everyone in this game seems to be using that damn ineffectual, emotional, threatening argument. It's not a protown argument.

Anyways, I do think CO is scum, but only 60/40, not enough for a vote yet. I'd like to see more activity from all the players first.

[Surye]

Funny how ChaosOmega suspects the same people...............

Surye, why do you give percentages? Earlier you thought Natasha was like 30/70?? Jester? Now you're only a little bit sure that you think CO is scum? Why??

I think you should have a stronger opinion, and not be afraid of what might happen if you go all-out-attacking on a certain player. It seriously makes you look like you don't want to make a huge mistake and attack someone.

You want me to make a huge mistake?

[Surye]

As in, purposely go after someone's case because you definitely think they are worth going after.

You've seen me go full steam against someone I thought was

definitely

worth going after. I don't think anyone is at this point. What's your problem?

[Surye]

who flew below radar while I had all the attention.

more like "who lost interest in the game and quit following the thread."

The way things are going right now, scum don't even have to post, they can just sit back and let the town kill itself off.

Like you've been doing?

[Surye]

@Surye: you too. at least we're posting.

My point is you're just describing the whole game, not a tell.

What we need is some real content, but I'm not sure where to get it or how to generate it in a game like this.

[Surye]

AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAND WERE BACK.....


After seeing what has happened, I see a bit of a pattern here, so I have my suspicions of who the two scum are, so to get the first one out

VOTE: SETHANIEL

and for his partner

FOS: SURYE

These two have done a masterful job of having the town kill themselves. How much prodding have the two of them done, and then only have one vote to lynch when it came time to do so?

Grimmy
keeping his eye on these two

No, two townies have done a wonderful job of playing the worst townies ever. That is what happened if you read this game. Can you point out anywhere that the case against them had flaws that isn't just "they are town in hindsight"?

[Surye]

Well in this case, surye, you should feel safer if Seth comes up as town, because that would kill my theory of the two of you.

I figure that this group has been spllit up into three sets of two.
If one is guilty, then the other would probably be guilty too.
Seth & Surye
Celebloki & JL
CO & Mellow.

So if one of any of therse pairs gets lynched and found guilty, my vote will IMMEDIATELY be placed for the other.
And the opposite is true. If one is innocent, then the other is off the hook in my eyes.

Grimmy
growing three sets of eyes

Interesting system. Though policy lynches this close to LYOL sounds dangerous. But as stated before, I'm not liking Sethaniel a whole lot, and perhaps a bit of pressure might not be bad in his direction, though I suggest we look to Celebloki next, he's got all the charactaristics of play that you pointed out in us, and he also made many CYA moves to fall back on.

[Surye]

Vote: Sethaniel

Forgot that. Oops.

[Surye]

Didn't I say Celebloki

next

after we put pressure on you? Your lynch plan is a plan for disaster at LYOL, and therefor you are my #1 right now.

[Surye]

Your lynch plan is a plan for disaster at LYOL

What are you talking about? I don't have a lynch plan.

I don't even know how to respond to this blatant lie.

[Surye]

@Surye: How about by quoting the post where I say this supposed lynch plan?

Grimmy is the only one I can remember with a lynch plan. He's the one who said

I figure that this group has been spllit up into three sets of two.
If one is guilty, then the other would probably be guilty too.
Seth & Surye
Celebloki & JL
CO & Mellow.

So if one of any of therse pairs gets lynched and found guilty, my vote will IMMEDIATELY be placed for the other.
And the opposite is true. If one is innocent, then the other is off the hook in my eyes.

Sorry, it seems I got confused while skimming I guess.

Unvote

Grimmy, at LYOL, why would you setup policy lynches?

[Surye]

So now everyone knows where my votes will be on the next two days.

Only one role in this game can make you so sure you need no more information for DAYS to lynch.

Vote:Grimmy

[Surye]

I swithced my vote for Grimmy because that post set off many alarms. As stated, there is no reason for a townie to already plan a lynch for two days in a row, with no good reasons or logic whatsoever.

qft

[Surye]

Grimmy's reason: ? He has a lynch plan. I don't know why I'm at the top, or why he's so sure clearing me would automatically clear Surye.

Surye's reason: Apparently, he thought Grimmy's lynch plan was my plan. Therefore, I think it makes sense for him to change votes to Grimmy.

Mellow: Again, ? He never posts a case against me. The closest he gets to a reason is "yeah, that's right, it's L-1."

Grimmy, Surye and Mellow,
Are these indeed your reasons for voting Seth or do you have any thing to add here?

My vote was on him originally because I didn't like a few posts as I pointed out, but then I stayed on the wagon due to the confusion he pointed out, and promptly hopped off when I realized my mistake.

[Surye]

but noone really has a solid idea of who the scum DEFINITELY are.

Ill keep my vote out there, but if more solid proof is shown, I will change it for the good of the town.

Grimmy

Except of course scum.

And this last part felt really scummy, for much the same reasons MM pointed out.

[Surye]

Surye voted seth also by MISTAKE

My vote was on him originally because I didn't like a few posts as I pointed out, but then I stayed on the wagon due to the confusion he pointed out, and promptly hopped off when I realized my mistake.

Not quite.

[Surye]

BH