I mean, at any rate you kill EP before me, so I'm not in consideration for today. I can only be scum if he's lying about his role. I'm definitely leaning maria/ep atm though. I believe the mastina investigation from Una, and the step didn't really make sense to me before his claim. I wish I had seen the daytalk thing before saying as much in the PT though. Showed too many cards if hes scum with you.
In post 604, UnaBombaH wrote:I think the key here is to reread the interaction D2 when you outed your hood.
Will be back with that within a few days.
I outed it, I was not comfortable with it at all. His choices have been weird too. He asked me 'who would you neighborize?' I say 'Cheeky or Una, Una most likely' and then Cheeky dies, and EP is recruited.
Ep claimed to be an ascetic to mafia actions. So because my action successfully resolved on him, he's either lying or I'm town.
In the PT I said if you claimed VT I thought it would be you 2(ranmaru/una), because the roles maria/ep claimed + mine didn't really add up to enough power with any 2 of us.
In post 514, chamber wrote:I'm reasonably tempted to just hammer mastina here.
Do you have a way to describe your activity pattern mastina?
I just want to re-iterate that this was scum-sided, as I was about to post a reads list, and swing the wagon. Yet Chamber hammered. He also didn't try to push Maria as hard as I thought he would.
In post 514, chamber wrote:I'm reasonably tempted to just hammer mastina here.
Do you have a way to describe your activity pattern mastina?
I just want to re-iterate that this was scum-sided, as I was about to post a reads list, and swing the wagon. Yet Chamber hammered. He also didn't try to push Maria as hard as I thought he would.
Your read list is still accessible to everyone, and mastina needed to die. Had una claimed we could have looked elsewhere (and I probably would have as him, but I can see him taking his line).
And don't those points only make sense in a me/maria paring which is impossible at this point? (From a neutral perspective I can only be scum with EP).
In post 614, chamber wrote:I think you overvalue your ability to control the direction of the game.
No I'm actually pretty humble about my own abilities. What's the purpose in you stating this?
Your point is partially predicated on me fearing a direction shift brought about solely by you stating your reads. I don't think that was very likely to have happened. So it's relevant.
In post 617, chamber wrote:And don't those points only make sense in a me/maria paring which is impossible at this point? (From a neutral perspective I can only be scum with EP).
I could have either pushed Maria or Errant at that time since I was scumreading them at the time, safer bet to just hammer in the case I do push Errant (and I was going to).
In post 620, chamber wrote:Your point is partially predicated on me fearing a direction shift brought about solely by you stating your reads. I don't think that was very likely to have happened. So it's relevant.
Your justification for Mastina dying at that point is very weak.