In post 534, CheekyTeeky wrote:Ausuka seems to be talking down the possibility of a Plot lynch but with Dunn, her and myself that makes it L-2 with the potential for a lynch there.
That makes it L-1
Alisae subbed in and instead of engaging with the game started hard attacking me on a personal level to try to disengage their wagon
Yeah that pinged me too. Seemed a little forced. I also felt the argument for why my slot is scum was pretty angleshooty.
VOTE: Alisae
BUT IS ANGLESHOOTING SCUMMY?
NO, ITS NOT CHEEKY
IT ISN’T.
Cheeky you have been issued a verbal warning, any offences in the next 72 hours will result in a written warning which will stay on your record for 6 months
Also, what is NM doing? Worst play I’ve ever seen.
I can't remember the last N_M post that wasn't bland, unimaginative and lame. Some shitposters are at least somewhat funny. You are the epitomy of the type of poster that nobody would miss if you were to suddenly disappear. You never add anything of value.
I'm guessing you haven't read the game and probably never will? Why even sign up to play?
Okay well I don't. Look at the instances where Pine quotes a percentage or says "mastina says greater than random odds at being scum". Lazy mastina is scum mastina. If that's mastina at all.
In post 541, CheekyTeeky wrote:If Plot and Ali are aware of their meta, with one supposedly preferring scum more than the other, would it not make sense to go against these expectations when they're clearly both competent scum players?
CES what's your read on that slot?
Ywall are actually, really wrong btw.
Plot is willing to take a wolf PM.
In fact, the reason why we even decide to duo for this was because I wanted to learn how to effort from Plot (which I am learning a lot from btw like learning how to do charts and maps and how to analyze the maps is really cool!)
So the goal was to prioritize giving me the towngame if we happened to draw a scum pm.
It just so happens that were both town so we took the games we wanted to play (Plot took this game because he wanted to have fun with voting mechanics and I took the normal)
Like we’re both competent at this game and at wolf.
In post 407, Dunnstral wrote:I think Plotinus is scum here and they're not really engaging with the game and I don't see why he can't choose scum.
VOTE: Pine VOTE: Plotinus
They're not really engaging...
HE IS LITERALLY FUCKING DIEING AND FEELING GOD FUCKING AWFUL DUNNSTRAL
I AM LITERALLY PLAYING THE GAME BECAUSE OF THIS
AND THE BEST YOU'VE COME UP WITH IS "THEY'RE NOT REALLY ENGAGING"
Like, have you even tried to read any of his posts and try to analyze them or read into anything I told Plot or like any of the content we posted.
In fact, has the whole thread even bothed to READ any of Plot's posts?
Becuase I am very convinced that no one has made an attempt to read any of Plot's posting.
Like actually fucking READ HIS POSTS.
Not even Pine who is hard TRing us.
^I'll hammer Pine btw if it comes to it^
I don't understand how 516 leads to a vote on me considering what you quoted there and what you follow up with in 407 - doesn't it make sense that I'd be scumreading him?
I don't like how you came in just to shade Dunnstral. I wasn't aware of Plotinus' situation. If he said this in the speakeasy, shocker, some people don't want to be a part of it or be up to date with everybodies' lives.
Suggesting we ought to read minds is disingenuous. I want Dunnstral to explain his read, but his criticism of Plotinus was good.
It makes sense that you’re scumreading me from a scum perspective because you need to lynch townies to win and lynching my slot helps you further your win condition like, a lot?
In post 582, Lycanfire wrote:I don't like how you came in just to shade Dunnstral. I wasn't aware of Plotinus' situation. If he said this in the speakeasy, shocker, some people don't want to be a part of it or be up to date with everybodies' lives.
Suggesting we ought to read minds is disingenuous. I want Dunnstral to explain his read, but his criticism of Plotinus was good.
WHAT CRITICISM
What Criticism has he actually posted beyond “He isn’t engaging in the thread” which is terrible from my PoV.
Tell me
Its nothing
It doesn’t exist.
And I probably didn’t miss anything either.
But yeah from a town perspective no his read doesn’t make sense. Plot has a lot of walls you can read an try to analyze and get a read from for yourself and NO ONE IS TRYING TO READ THIS WALLS OR TALK ABOUT THEM
Like if you thought Plot’s ACTUAL CONTENT is scummy then fine, I can respect that.
But no one has actually tried to read it.
My initial read was based on Plotinus contributions in this game not matching up to what I've seen them do as town in other games, also they were letting pine spew out "plotinus wouldn't pick a scum role pm because alisae was town" and now alisae is saying that the both of them would have given Plotinus the scum pm. Alisae has given me different reasons to scumread them since they've entered
In post 589, Dunnstral wrote:My initial read was based on Plotinus contributions in this game not matching up to what I've seen them do as town in other games, also they were letting pine spew out "plotinus wouldn't pick a scum role pm because alisae was town" and now alisae is saying that the both of them would have given Plotinus the scum pm. Alisae has given me different reasons to scumread them since they've entered
In post 589, Dunnstral wrote:My initial read was based on Plotinus contributions in this game not matching up to what I've seen them do as town in other games, also they were letting pine spew out "plotinus wouldn't pick a scum role pm because alisae was town" and now alisae is saying that the both of them would have given Plotinus the scum pm. Alisae has given me different reasons to scumread them since they've entered
Your first point is meta which I can’t address. Terrible meta at that since, well, its wrong.
Your 2nd point isn’t actually scum indicative. Plot could have let Pine spew it out because hey, they were reading us correctly, so it doesn’t make any sense for us to tell them not to read us correctly?
DIFFERENT REASONS. OH BOY I WONDER WHAT THESE ARE DUNNSTRAL
In post 589, Dunnstral wrote:My initial read was based on Plotinus contributions in this game not matching up to what I've seen them do as town in other games, also they were letting pine spew out "plotinus wouldn't pick a scum role pm because alisae was town" and now alisae is saying that the both of them would have given Plotinus the scum pm. Alisae has given me different reasons to scumread them since they've entered
How is Plotinus scum if Pine is town?
I mean, they're not really linked in my eyes. That's why I'm pushing Alisae and not Pine. I keep feeling like Pine's l-1 reactions are genuine and points to him being town
In post 589, Dunnstral wrote:My initial read was based on Plotinus contributions in this game not matching up to what I've seen them do as town in other games, also they were letting pine spew out "plotinus wouldn't pick a scum role pm because alisae was town" and now alisae is saying that the both of them would have given Plotinus the scum pm. Alisae has given me different reasons to scumread them since they've entered
How is Plotinus scum if Pine is town?
Case in point.
How many times have you asked this and gotten no response?
In post 560, Lycanfire wrote:I posted a buttload of content for you to scrutinize. If you're town and think I'm scum, you do the work. If you're scum, you roll over and die. Hint: if you're town you should have tried to reason a NM lynch.
[...]
In post 557, Pine wrote:I also really dislike her close associative with my second suspect N_M.
Last edited by northsidegal on Fri May 18, 2018 2:55 pm, edited 1 time in total.