Open 729 - Cul de Sac!

[mutantdevle]

Lucky guess of PoE in my head says Scioness Sajj, BuJaber and ArcAngel9.

[Scioness Sajj]

me, bujabber and aa9 are your picks for scumteam?

[mutantdevle]

Of the top of my head with nothing backing it up ruling everyone else as town through various shitty poorly reasoned methods, yeah, simple shitty not even quarter-assed PoE. Why, does it bother you?

[Scioness Sajj]

it doesn't really. couldn't tell if it's your pool or you are just unaware.

it's 11:2, not 10:3.

[mutantdevle]

Oh yeah forgot about that. I do know it I just forgot :3

Scratch out ArcAngel9 then since they've done fuck all.

[Awoo]

I can kinda respect that.

[UglyDuck]

yeah, I am heading out now, so reasons to follow but I am gonna go with a

Vote: Mutant

after reading through.

[BuJaber]

Math am I finally seeing your scum game?

So sajj and I are the scumteam and instead of coming up with good theatrics to distance each other with a fight that looks like TvT, we instead come up with one where I ask technical questions about stefan's posts to my partner in the game thread first without scum PT so I can build an elaborate case on someone with 0 votes on them and then have my own partner shut that case down immediately?

Mutsnt has either ran out of any motivation to actually play the game or he is scum trying to be 'too scummy to be scum'.
How is doing nothing a town tell? You honestly think there is no scum among the lurkers? There are players with less than 10 posts in 18 pages.

I haven't voted for arc because I wanted to see his reaction to people talking about his post. But his absence is looking suspicious on it's own.

[Mathdino]

sup, still kinda bored with this game

- my playstyle has probably changed in the months since we last played a real full game together. if anything i think i was scummier when you were townreading me, and townier when you were scumreading me. i'm biased by what i know i do as town though

- i never said you and scioness were the scumteam, wat? please indicate who you're talking to each paragraph thanks

- there are different kinds of doing nothing. some nothingdoing is scummier than other nothingdoing. appearing active but not really pushing the game in any meaningful way is a major red flag. but being super passive personality-wise is kind of a towntell. (passive people tend to be less passive when they're scum. they find it

freeing

)

- aa9 is a girl

people asked me a bunch of shit that i forgot, reading through tonight

[BuJaber]

Yeah sorry Math only the first line was to you. The rest was @mutant.


And sorry Arc. I wasn't sure about the pronoun and you have so few posts I was too lazy to look for one to check. It won't consciously happen again I promise.

[BuJaber]

@math I actually think I know how to read you somewhat (with a lot of uncertainty and paranoia for sure) I just like to see reactions of people when I talk about you. It's especially important for NK analysis because of who you are. You are just someone we should expect to die at night and if not we really should question why. As in I would be comfortable with you as a backboard in lylo but I would never want you to actually be alive at lylo because I wouldn't be able to believe that scum left you alive that long.

And yeah obviously my play has dropped significantly and I don't play as much as I used to at the beginning of the year so it's fair to accept your meta has evolved without me witnessing it. I do keep that in mind.
Biggest thing that pings me about you is how weird you got about people townreading you and scumreading wave in the early game. It felt way too exaggerated and defensive. The arguments you had together were not even that polarizing in terms of alignment because it was theory stuff on PTs. People were calling wave scummy because they disliked his attitude and his implication that we will get nothing out of PTs this game. Scumreading him for that would not imply a townread on you. The fact that most people who commented on that stated they townread you and scumread wave was a coincidence.

Apart from that I am used to you being more involved but this game does not help keep discussions going so it's hard to judge. Also I don't like how some seem to be basing some reads on opinions you've stated without much reasoning. I can only conclude that people of both alignments are sheeping you and I just wish your reads had more content with them so that the sheepers are forced to actually show their agreement to the more specific arguments and show their true opinions.

[BuJaber]

I think the choice of who to lynch should be between Arc and Catgirl. Nobody has provided any reasons why they're town when they claim they TR them.

Alternative would be uglyduck who seems to be controversial so there's stuff to analyze after his flip.

[HeWhoSwims]

VC6

UglyDuck(4) (L-3)

: wavemode, ArcAngel9, BuJaber, Invisibility

ArcAngel9 (5) (L-2)

: wingedcatgirl, Mathdino, UnrealSeal, Awoo, Scioness Sajj

mutantdevle (1) (L-6):

UglyDuck



Not voting: Myloninja13, northsidegal, mutantdevle

ArcAngel9 is at L-2!

[BuJaber]

Duck if I vote arc are you gonna hammer her?

[UglyDuck]

Duck if I vote arc are you gonna hammer her?

Currently, no chance.

[UglyDuck]

I also find that like kind of an odd question to need asking since the only people that could hammer would be :

Me - saying no
AA - obv not
WAVE - skum reads me and town reads AA
Invis - Skum reads me, no opinion I can find on AA


What is your worry? If I am skum I would obviously have some agenda regarding my answer. Given the game state the town thing here would of been to just put them at L-1. All you have accomplished is making it seem like you are willing to. And, as I am sure you are aware, as I am the counter wagon it would appear skummy for you rn to actually vote for AA and put them L-1.

VT game - town shouldn't care about appearing skummy.

[Myloninja13]

It'd kinda suck to lose one of my neighbours now, but like it wasn't as if they were really talking to me lol.

[UnrealSeal]

AA - obv not

not to be pedantic here but if AA gets put to L-1 and she's scum she would probably self-hammer.

[Scioness Sajj]

let's put her to l-1 then

[Myloninja13]

I could vote for them if you wanted me to?

[BuJaber]

I still wanted your answer on the record, Duck. As you can see arc isn't afraid to vote her counterwagon. You voting for mutant at this time seemed odd. I wanted to throw out a weird question to see how you'd respond.

And it's funny you say that town shouldn't worry about looking scummy when you answer in such way. You seem the one worried.

I don't want the day to end yet. Pretty much anyone else that isn't you quickhammering would be scum claiming. The only unpredictable vote was yours as a townie in your situation might hammer (shouldn't but some players do), and obviously as scum you would hammer but you would either not respond to the question or lie or the more likely option: once I ask you this question you can't hammer anymore as scum because I put you in the spotlight.

[BuJaber]

I could vote for them if you wanted me to?

You should vote for them if YOU want to

[Myloninja13]

I don't really want to? I like having neighbours, it's fun.

[Myloninja13]

But like, I don't actually find their play townish lol.

[Awoo]

Let AA post again before we lynch her, wtf?