Minuet's Trio [Game Over]

[zMuffinMan]

and you never lynch a cop before they can get a result

yes, and this is theoretically sound because a regular cop claim is either a fake-claim OR it's going to be killed/blocked/tampered with in some way by scum and lynching it later makes sense theoretically

vanilla cops are fundamentally different (a vanilla cop isn't really a threat to scum, it just limits fake-claims) and especially in a setup with multiple vanilla cops, getting a result isn't important nor would it really tell you anything about kaede's alignment - so if you think the claim is scum, you lynch it

this should be extremely obvious to anyone who actually thinks about it. this should be more obvious to someone who is a vanilla cop himself

what i think actually happened here: you were not thinking about this in a town way. instead you saw kaede's claim, donned your lustrous white armour and took the opportunity to look gallant and chivalrous by defending what you knew to be a town claim. your immediate vote on grapes when he voted kaede (before he claimed) supports this

yes, you may have seen duplicate roles before and been wary about counter-claiming - i believe this. that has nothing to do with anything here

anywho, this isn't why i think you're scum - it's a minor additional reason

[Ginngie]

its invest, so I dont care

If you can't accept that, realize you'll just be arguing mafia theory.

and I had this methodology drilled into my fucking head since like my 3rd or 4th game ever.

I don't care how fucking scummy, I won't lynch a non-XyLo claim on principle.

Now two things

you can either A) continue your ramblings and get nothing actually done B) actually vote with purpose and talk about other things you're concerned about.

[Dunnstral]

Stop claiming vanilla cops

Even if there are more, it's not beneficial at this point

This is important. Remember that there are main characters roles in this game, and that one is confirmed town.

[Nosferatu]

at least one is town

that's legit the most useless info

[zMuffinMan]

who's scum, nosferatu?

[Nosferatu]

WAIT A SECOND LMFAOO

[Nosferatu]

who's scum, nosferatu?

do you have fun asking these questions?

we both know im not scumhunting

[zMuffinMan]

vote ginngie then

[Nosferatu]

ok?
VOTE: ginngie

idk where you wanna go with this vanity wagon

[Kaede Akamatsu]

It wont be a vanity wagon if I vote it too
VOTE: ginggie
(and hopefully others)

[Brian Skies]

I love lynching

cop

investigative claims.

VOTE: Ginngie

[grapes]

VOTE: Ginngie

[Brian Skies]

True story.

This wagon developed in the opposite order of the Nos wagon.

Lol.

[Brian Skies]

Also, I don't really have a particular reason for this, but I'd love to know Purrcocet's thoughts on all the vanilla cop business.

[Dunnstral]

at least one is town

that's legit the most useless info

Main character roles are stronger than normal roles

[Dunnstral]

VOTE: Ginngie

[Ginngie]

muffin

am about to take a nap

so if you could do me the solid of saying literally anything you think is of utmost importance

that'd be great

[Nosferatu]

at least one is town

that's legit the most useless info

Main character roles are stronger than normal roles

says who?

[Ankamius]

like aside from the AtE thing which is pretty NAI if you ask me, the reason she's being voted is pretty dumb

her voting nancy seems like a pretty fucking linear thought process? I don't see how town!kaede would not vote nancy when she did.

this could be scum

[Ankamius]

on that note, read ginngie iso and notice a total lack of anything town - only noteworthy thing he's done so far is call a few people town to seem like he's being reasonable and the way he does that isn't even town. he's just padding his post count with content that might seem reasonable when you don't examine it closely; e.g. love the totally real concern he has for where my vote is, though - 100% believe that's what frustrates him most about this game

is this really readable for ginngie though

this is generally how you catch the pure-logic type players or people roughly in that ballpark, not the more stream-of-conscious-less-serious types

[Ankamius]

grapes is town, please stop being bad. just look at the angles from which he's formed reads on this game and if you tell me scum do that with a straight face then youre lying or kidding yourself

they ease in to changing based on the main wagons

this also isn't inherently scummy, you need to support this

[Katsuki]

ok so

In queen of hearts town had a bunch of compulsive body guards
Nightengale we had a bunch of double voters

Maybe this game the "weak-ish role that town gets more than one of" is vanilla cop because
1) wis is kinda right that it aint too strong especially depending on setup and sakura fakeclaiming vanilla cop as scum is only really likely if she's actually a role cop i think (btw i think the "scum version" of the vanilla cops in this case would probably be akin to rolecop if that's in fact what's going on here)
2) I'm not sure fakegod would give scum the fakeclaim of vanilla cop to just have me CC and get a wicked easy scum lynch (thing is here, maybe he would, in queen of hearts the mafia bodyguard wasn't compulsive and in nightengale scum didn't have a double-voter, though)
3) ginngie and nos are both sorta reacting how scum would in a CC situation between 2 town



At any rate after pondering it's kinda cool that if kaeda and I are both town we both are kinda bad night kills and they can't block both of us so yippee i guess

Let's vote in android nos ginngie for today

VOTE: nos

The only fakeclaims scum had available to them in that mass bodyguard game was bodyguard. No idea what it means for this game, just throwing that fact out there.

[Katsuki]

Stop claiming vanilla cops

Even if there are more, it's not beneficial at this point

I will note that I too am a vanilla cop.

[Katsuki]

E

[Human Sequencer]

Of the claimed vanilla cops I would really rather lynching kaede

I believe both claims