Open 730: Donner Party [Terminado]

[ManateeDude]

Im actually confident this flips scum tbh

[Sando]

NM is just pissed someone took his lol hammer glory.

[ManateeDude]

NM is just pissed someone took his lol hammer glory.

Feelsgoodman

[Not_Mafia]

MM may continue posting until their role is flipped btw

Twilight posting is also fine with me, all rules still apply though

Twilight is the time between a hammer and mod coming to the thread, not whatever this is

R u the mod?

No but twilight is an objectively defined thing, it's not something mods can change on the fly

[UnrealSeal]

god fucking dammit.

i leave for a few hours and stupid shit happens.

i'd bet money this flips town.

[ManateeDude]

god fucking dammit.

i leave for a few hours and stupid shit happens.

i'd bet money this flips town.

( ._.)

[Korina]

Locking thread.
Flip + Flavor comes in about 10 minutes, maybe less depending on if I can think of something good.

[Korina]

A plane crash. Not just any plane crash...

the

plane crash. The one that had killed his family all those years ago... How he despised what he had to do in order to survive.

Eating your family? Just to survive what should've killed him?

Weeks passed until he was found. Three weeks MM had to eat just human flesh in order to survive. When the rescuers finally arrived all he felt was rage. Why hadn't they rescued him sooner? Before he became... this monster?

They say that once you've had human flesh for the first time, you don't ever want to try anything else...

So, is it really a surprise to see that Marshmallow Marshal was a...

Spoiler: Flip

Cannibal Mafia Goon

?

Mafia Goon

Welcome, Marshmallow Marshall. You are a

Cannibal Mafia Goon

, along with your partner, [REDACTED].

Abilities:

1. Factional communication: At any time in the game, you may talk with your partner here.
   
2. Cannibal nightkill: Each night phase, one of you or your partner may perform the factional nightkill. You will receive back either a PM indicating that the target did not die, or a PM containing their role/alignment information, and if they were a Cannibal, the role/alignment of all bodies they possessed when they were killed.
   
3. The role/alignment of your night-kill targets is not shared with the town.

Win condition:

- You win when

all other killers are dead and you control 50% of the town or nothing can prevent this from occurring

.

To confirm you exist, tell me your partners name, and a joke.

We did not find any partially eaten bodies with their corpse.

Their joke was:

Your partner's name, and a joke.

Night 1 Begins! You have 48 hours to submit actions.
(expired on 2018-07-02 23:55:00)

[Korina]

MathDino and Shizune are being replaced by my discretion. Please do remember, this is a commitment. If something does come up, claim V/LA, do not suddenly disappear.
Ty in advance.

Eragon replaces MathDino.
OkaPoka replaces Shizune.

Shizune has been graylisted for one month for the following reasons:
1) Activity on-site without activity in-game. (Shizune got on the 30th before hammer, did not post anywhere on forum nor message me to declare a V/LA)
2) Presumable 96 hour rule infraction.

Graylist ends in: (expired on 2018-08-02 03:40:00)

[Korina]

Night results coming out in a few. No news is good news. (Meaning if you just get the day start PM, as far as you know, nothing happened to you)

[Korina]

As all of you wake up the next morning to greet one another, you all are instantly shocked by the disappearance of BlackStar. He didn't show up this morning.

You all choose to go investigate his bedroom to see if mayhaps he overslept, (the less grim and more innocent possibility). When you all arrive at his bedroom, all that is left in his room is a bloody trail to the door and a large bloodstain on the bed.

It seems BlackStar was murdered last night.
We have no idea what he was.

No-one else has died.

Day Two begins and ends in (expired on 2018-07-17 00:13:00).

[Eragon]

damnit

backstar was p.much

confirmed town

[Eragon]

Spoiler:

AP- >I have a bad gut feeling on his post 53 about the set-up. Its likely It was a joke, but It feels off to me. >Oh great, AP just got spewed town by Marshmallow in 58. >I still don’t like his posts but I feel he is spewed town. >88feels very towny to me and from a town PoV

2. Ceejayvinoya-
>I see a vote on lucky otter that strikes me as odd, but I don’t see scum voting for that reason.
>I do see explanation and it is good to have some discussion among us, so lite town for now.
>votes unreal seal for the exact reasons I was pinged by. Nice mind meld
>im really liking ceejay’s posts and see him very towny
>113towny and good feeling for me
>i dont really like his 180, but I can see reasons for the vote itself
>Spewed town from 127
>170 and 169 are both awkward, but still towny-ish
>177 so you are saying you didn’t agree with Seal??? But you sheeped his vote???? This is off-putting

4. UnrealSeal-
>108defends MM by saying they are noob town for hopping votes. Shades otter’s response and vote and then votes otter. I find this post wolfy
>112 I dont see the point of this at all
>114 blatant wolfy misrep saying otter posted directly after 101, otter posted at 105
>not a huge fan of 118, and I don’t like the stuff about Not_Mafia, seems a bit TMI tbh.
>129 spews both Lucky and Unreal town
>204 wtf is this post?? Betting money MM flips town. My question is, does scum make that post post-hammer

5. BlackStar-
>started off RvS on a scum. I would like to call this townie but could have had ulterior motives.
>Oh, ok, nvm, BlackStar is town from MM’s flip.
>71 and 72. Yep, def. town.
>Also cleared by MM spew in 78
>120 “This feels like TvT” good post
>139calls out marshmellow, def. town
>calls out marsh again
>155 absolutely, 100%, lock town

6. Ejjinami-
>towny ideals on Hypoing.
>He hits me with a Town Tsunami in 63, even if he was wrong on MM. He saw what I did with MM/AP, and brought up a good point about sando
>143 makes ejji likely town but not strong enough
>144-147 absolute mindmeld. Towny read

7. Not_Mafia=ahhh naked votes :/ I don’t like his vote on CJ tbh
>voted MM, towny

8. Eragon1329-
>i cant say anything because its my slot but I feel I’m spewed town from MM voting my slot for activity

9. Sando-
>not doing too much in the beginning of the thread to advance, just theory. >90 makes Sando quite towny but not enough to merit a strong town.
>176whats with this? It feels slightly off to me



10. ManateeDude-
>asking about hypoing is towny IME.
>Voted MM, and 106is odd but I feel it comes from town!manatee’s perspective.
>Votes Ceejay b/c the 180, which pinged me as well, but remember, CJ had otter as a SR too.
>186 feels towny and mind melding



11. LuckyOtter-
>im not sure what to think about his gut vote on AP, but certainly isn’t a scum tell.
>Towny vote on MM.
>Excuses for being inactive, and shades shizune for being inactive too.
>117 is pretty good as well, but a couple things pinged me.
Mainly “I have other reasons for calling out shizune that will be apparent shortly.“ I dont see how this could work, Ima have to read this.
>119 gets a bit defensive, but I wouldn’t say too much. I really really don’t like the OMGUS though
>129 spews both Lucky and Unreal town
>152 I really like this post and these reads and the vote on MM

12. shizune

notes:
>I dont like all the talk about crumbing, because it just gives mafia and SK targets to kill. BTW. I hard claim Gun Smithilante blocker.
>thanks for making the game EZ MM
>when I saw “Spews town” I mean, spews not mafia, could still be SK
>i honestly feel MM’s wagon was not bussed by fellow mafia. Could be sk there tho.

[Eragon]

oh, I never said hello


hello and happy eater-huntings


also good job D1, though it was kinda obvious

[OkaPoka]

VOTE: not_mafia

why are u doing naked votes and doing nothing of substance

[Korina]

Votecount 2.0

Not_Mafia(1)

~ OkaPoka(1)

Not Voting (9): AP(0), ceejayvinoya(0), UnrealSeal(0), ejjinami(0), Not_Mafia(0), Eragon(3), Sando(0), ManateeDude(0), LuckyOtter(0)

With 10 alive it takes 6 to lynch.

Day 2 deadline is in (expired on 2018-07-17 00:13:00)

MOD REMINDERS

The serious flavor from me is only because I'm really tired rn and am about to fall asleep at my desk.
The typical, comedic flavor from me resumes later when I'm not falling asleep.

[ManateeDude]

I think decent chance of scum in ejj/MM, and I don't think they're scum together. 44 through 49 did not feel organic to me and I'm trying to put my finger on anything specific in there, it feels a bit buddying to me. They're both disagreeing with a hypo claim (which is fine to disagree with) using talk about whether the

cop

GS should claim or not if threatened with lynching (which is not a fine conversation, obviously they should and that has no bearing on us hypoing or not). They also both focus on the

cop

GS while ignoring the other PRs, who is the biggest threat to SK since no block there, and obviously a big threat to Mafia as well

This was the only comment sando made on MM, and later in the day didn't comment at all. I feel like this was a weak attempt at distancing. Also the excessive on smth I felt was T v T gives me scummy vibes.

VOTE: Sando

Also agree with eragon wagon was probably pure of mafia.

[ManateeDude]

VOTE: not_mafia

why are u doing naked votes and doing nothing of substance

I'm told it's his meta and NAI.

[OkaPoka]

VOTE: not_mafia

why are u doing naked votes and doing nothing of substance

I'm told it's his meta and NAI.

ive played with him a couple years back and although he was trolly he was a lot more substantive

[AP]

About the Night action: 1 NK only either means (a) Mafia hit the SK & Vig got RB'd, (b) Vig hit the SK & Mafia got RB'd, (c) both SK & Mafia targeted Blackstar & Vig got RB'd (can't see the town Vig targeting Blackstar to be honest), (d) Someone holstered (and you can repeat all possibilities for where the other NK went).

Basically, the RB needs to target someone other than their N1 target and the Vig needs to retry on the same target (unless they get a clue their target on N1 isn't the SK).

Obviously, at this point the Vig doesn't know whether to complain about the toothache or moan their luck of being the RB's target.

OK,

gun to my head

I'd say Unreal is the other Mafioso and OkaPoka "maybe" the SK (who didn't submit a kill).

P-edit: Maybe Manatee's got a point.. maybe not. I'll hold off my vote for now.

[Eragon]

Towncore
—Eragon
—AP
—Ejjinami

Town Lean
-LuckyOtter
-Sando
-ManateeDude
-UnRealSeal

Null
-okadoka
-Not_Mafia

Neutral null(less not-read and more I could go either way so convince me)

-Ceejay

[OkaPoka]

vote nm and get him talking

[Eragon]

god fucking dammit.

i leave for a few hours and stupid shit happens.

i'd bet money this flips town.

would Scumbuddy!UnrealSeal make this post after hammer?

[OkaPoka]

Towncore
—Eragon
—AP
—Ejjinami

Town Lean
-LuckyOtter
-Sando
-ManateeDude
-UnRealSeal

Null
-okadoka
-Not_Mafia

Neutral null(less not-read and more I could go either way so convince me)

-Ceejay

why do u only have town reads and null reads and no scum reads

[Eragon]

thats literally the only reason I don't want to Lynch unreal as maf buddy(ok maybe a few but thats the main thing)