Open 726 - Revenge of the Vengeful (Endgame)

[Enigma]

MM in you are in mini game!! I like this pace haha, I read once an evening and post. Go join the large themes and you'll have 100+ pages of fun (well not fun for me, maybe fun for you).

Could do a Trinity lynch. Would much prefer Oath to get vengekilled, though lynchable also.

Could be convinced for A50 and Rei as well.

People I don't want to see lynched or shot today: NM, M_M, Iceman, RC

[Oath]

Oath, I'd like to know: are you 100% new to Forum Mafia?

No, but I did just come out of retirement and jumped into 6 games.

[Enigma]

VOTE: Trinity

[Ankamius]

Vote Count 1.9

[2]

Marshmallow Marshall

- Almost50, Rei

(L-3)

[2]

Rei

- Oath, Marshmallow Marshall

(L-3)

[2]

TrinityNZ

- RadiantCowbells, Enigma

(L-3)

[1]

Not_Mafia

- TrinityNZ
[1]

Oath

- Not_Mafia
Almost50 -
Enigma -
IcemanCh -
RadiantCowbells -


Not Voting (1): IcemanCh

With 9 alive, it takes 5 to lynch.

Deadline is (expired on 2018-07-24 11:30:00) from now, or July 24th, 10:30 AM CST (GMT-6).

Prodding: N/A
Replacing: N/A

[Marshmallow Marshall]

MM in you are in mini game!! I like this pace haha, I read once an evening and post. Go join the large themes and you'll have 100+ pages of fun (well not fun for me, maybe fun for you).

Could do a Trinity lynch. Would much prefer Oath to get vengekilled, though lynchable also.

Could be convinced for A50 and Rei as well.

People I don't want to see lynched or shot today: NM, M_M, Iceman, RC

What you call a mini game is the normal population of the games I'm talking about though...

[Marshmallow Marshall]

Oath, I'd like to know: are you 100% new to Forum Mafia?

No, but I did just come out of retirement and jumped into 6 games.

Oh lol, okay. I guess that explains a bit

[Oath]

Oath, I'd like to know: are you 100% new to Forum Mafia?

No, but I did just come out of retirement and jumped into 6 games.

Oh lol, okay. I guess that explains a bit

What exactly does it explain?

[Marshmallow Marshall]

Oath, I'd like to know: are you 100% new to Forum Mafia?

No, but I did just come out of retirement and jumped into 6 games.

Oh lol, okay. I guess that explains a bit

What exactly does it explain?

The fact that you're inactive.

[TrinityNZ]

VOTE: Trinity

Hey Enigma, what’s the reason for the vote on me?

[Almost50]

VOTE: Trinity

Hey Enigma, what’s the reason for the vote on me?

VOTE: Trinity

I don't have a reason

not to

at this point. I don't think MM is scum anymore.

[IcemanCh]

I'm reading to catch up. Been busy at work. Give me a few and I'll get through my reads.

[IcemanCh]

Well that didn't take long lol. Here is my reads and where I"m currently at.

Rei - Town - Pretty obvious.
RadiantCowbells - Slight Town - Good content and reads on everyone. Fairly consistent in his position.
Enigma - Slight Town - Has a lot of posts but honestly not a lot of content. I suspect town but, there's just not much to go on.
MarshMallow - Nuetral - A TON of content. Almost to much. Seems to be putting a show. Lots of posting, postulating, and moving about but not much productivity. I'm skeptical of town but, that might just be the cynic in me getting in the way. It just seems to be over the top.
Almost 50 - Nuetral - I want to lean town but, the confusion seems fake. Giving the benefit of the doubt and shoving the cynic aside I'm going to say Nuetral for now.
TrinityNZ - Scum Lean - I've seen her other games. Kind of all over the place when she's on her own. She seems slightly more together in this game. I'm wondering if it's because of being coached in the background.
Not_Mafia - Scum - Zero content. At this point has to be scum. Can't figure out any reason for the absolute radio silence.
Oath - Scum - Same as NM

[IcemanCh]

ehh

for the record I just got annoyed that you were voting for oath and knee jerk called you scum, after review I tentatively think that you're town. you need to do more though.

can you give me like a readslist with reasons?

Oath - scumlean, has pretty much done zilch so far.
Marshmallow Marshall - townlean. Seems pretty engaged, his posts are a bit too arrogant for him to be wanting to draw attention to himself as scum.
Radiant Cowbells, IceMan, Enigma, Rei - null - they seem to be engaged and strategising, but I don’t have any real reasons at this point to go one way or the other.
Not_Mafia - scumlean - lack of posts does not seem very townish.
Almost50- scumlean - again, not engaging.

My I'm misunderstanding this but, why defend oath and then call him scum? Seems odd to me. Also, you only have one town read so far? If I wasn't convinced that scum is Oath and N_M I would say that it's you MM and Oath based on this post.

I'm voting to put you at L-1

VOTE: Trinity

I think you're definitely one of our scum.

[IcemanCh]

Uggg... /facepalm totally messed that up. The quote is from RC. Makes way more sense.

I'm still convinced you're scum though. You seem much more collected then any of the other games I've played with you. That's got to be a day chat helping you out.

[Not_Mafia]

I'm town

[Not_Mafia]

VOTE: RC

[IcemanCh]

I'm town

Oh geez... You're right you are town. I'm totally convinced now.

[Not_Mafia]

I'm town

Oh geez... You're right you are town. I'm totally convinced now.

Thanks

[IcemanCh]

I'm town

Oh geez... You're right you are town. I'm totally convinced now.

Thanks

So why RC? Why are you scum reading him.

[Marshmallow Marshall]

VOTE: Trinity

Hey Enigma, what’s the reason for the vote on me?

VOTE: Trinity

I don't have a reason

not to

at this point. I don't think MM is scum anymore.

I can get on this wagon, tbh. Usually, people having 0 reasons NOT to lynch them, out of someone being 100% AFK, are scum. I'll see that clsoe to EoD.

[Marshmallow Marshall]

Well that didn't take long lol. Here is my reads and where I"m currently at.

Rei - Town -

Pretty obvious.

RadiantCowbells - Slight Town - Good content and reads on everyone. Fairly consistent in his position.
Enigma - Slight Town - Has a lot of posts but honestly not a lot of content. I suspect town but, there's just not much to go on.
MarshMallow - Nuetral - A TON of content. Almost to much. Seems to be putting a show. Lots of posting, postulating, and moving about but not much productivity. I'm skeptical of town but, that might just be the cynic in me getting in the way. It just seems to be over the top.
Almost 50 - Nuetral - I want to lean town but, the confusion seems fake. Giving the benefit of the doubt and shoving the cynic aside I'm going to say Nuetral for now.
TrinityNZ - Scum Lean - I've seen her other games. Kind of all over the place when she's on her own. She seems slightly more together in this game. I'm wondering if it's because of being coached in the background.
Not_Mafia - Scum - Zero content. At this point has to be scum. Can't figure out any reason for the absolute radio silence.
Oath - Scum - Same as NM

What?? Elaborate please, I don't see how he's obvtown at all.

Not that many posts from Enigma.
MM - What do you mean about a ton of content but no productivity? How do you describe "productivity" in a nightless setup without any TPR way to confirm people? What do you expect to be the "good town play"? Not attacking you there, but wanting to understand your views.
A50 - Rip autocorrect, nuetral? personally I believe he is not faking the confusion. He could still be scum AND confused though ^^ not having read the game is not a town tell.
What do you think about Trinity's content?
I honestly believe Not_Mafia is town... it's his meta. He has done absolutely nothing but blank votes in the two games I played with him (and some image shitposts too), but was town. Surprisingly, he has good reads, apparently. He just won't post them. Of course, this is a META read, and should be seen as such... it is not enough to establish that someone is innocent or guilty.
Oath said he's in 6 games at once. It's a terrible idea to do that if you don't have time to contribute, but heh. What makes me think he might be town is that scum team is very rarely 100% lurkers.

List of reads, part 1

[RadiantCowbells]

If NM has good reads then he shouldnt be scumreading me

[Marshmallow Marshall]

List of reads, part 2 (My own reads worded by myself, not quotes & comments)

Town

because green = town

Enigma.

He screams town to me, I feel genuine scumhunting coming from that slot, and the reaction to my opener post was very town-like.

Iceman.

He was scummy at the beggining, but his posts show someone really trying to understand the game and help town.

Townish

Not_Mafia.

I know this will be seen as weird by most people, but I believe he is town a lot. However, that read is mainly based on meta, therefore he cannot go higher than townish in my mind.

RadiantCowbells.

He wanted to strategize on the lynches, which is pro-town. His general behavior is pro-town. However, I have a doubt on him, mainly gut, and the fact that he potentially tried to buddy me at start. Logically, he's town, but I have a doubt.

Null-neutral

- Rei, Oath.

A50.

I don't like the slot. We would really need you in, sir.

Trinity.

Is not contributing, but posts. In other words, he's active but not useful to town. I think someone said he usually was all over the place as town; we are not seeing that here.

Mafiascum

[TrinityNZ]

VOTE: Trinity

Hey Enigma, what’s the reason for the vote on me?

VOTE: Trinity

I don't have a reason

not to

at this point. I don't think MM is scum anymore.

Isn’t it better to try to find scum, rather than vote for a mislynch? Wouldn’t it be good to do some more scumhunting and build up some more posts for day 2? Why don’t you think MM is scum? What do you think of Enigma?

I’m not even sure what the case against me is, so I don’t even know how to defend myself right now.

[TrinityNZ]

Uggg... /facepalm totally messed that up. The quote is from RC. Makes way more sense.

I'm still convinced you're scum though. You seem much more collected then any of the other games I've played with you. That's got to be a day chat helping you out.

I’m not feeling more collected
Maybe it looks that way because this game is a lot slower, with fewer posts this game, and I haven’t felt pressure to put myself out there or defend myself until now. What do you think of Not_Mafia?