What specifically do you disagree on? I got the gist of why you voted CT -- his lack of activity, plus possibly the fact there was already a wagon building up on him -- I just think it's a shot in the dark with so many players doing the same thing, especially when you've already expressed concerns about what some players were doing.In post 123, Tchill13 wrote:I disagree with your issue regarding activity. You really have no idea why I voted that person?
Anything else you don't like from Carca?
For the first two points, I thought they were anti-town, but it's blatantly anti-town in a sense where I don't see why scum would want to openly ask something like that. I also got the impression they were said on impulse, which also doesn't play into it being scummy to me. As for the last point, it's fairly apparent through her ISO why she placed her votes where she did, especially w/regards to Tiphane -- not sure why "naked votes" are particularly scummy. What were you initially town-reading her for?In post 143, profii wrote:asked for vt peeps
and suggested a no lnych
followed 2 wagons with pretty naked votes
it seems pretty bad to me but idk 6 pages in
Why would you jump to a new wagon without reassessing your read on nonny? Are you satisfied with her response, do you think she's not as scummy anymore, or is there another reason why you shifted wagons?In post 146, Completly Trustworthy wrote: Something just feels off about profli to me. He initially came out of the gate trying to direct the town into voting Nonny and constantly gave advice as to what the town should do, then he just started asking others where his vote should be placed. Also, 69 seems very odd to me as well.
VOTE: profli
It was more a response to you asking "Where should we be looking for example?". It seemed like he did mention players to look at -- specifically you and "lurkers" -- after he made the post you quoted, so that part felt weird to me.In post 147, nonny wrote:Did not see a need to quote all three just to ask about the weird posting style. He mentioned me but that was it. Otherwise he didn't mention much at all. It was feigning activity so trying to flesh out why.In post 122, Reundo wrote:In post 84, nonny wrote: Do you always post in haikus? Can you give a little more please. Where should we be looking for example?
Considering profii mentioned you in the post right after this I don't see what your concern is. You expressed concern over three players in your post -- why didn't you vote any of them?
I'm not feeling the profii or Tiphaine wagons. I feel their play is more strange/unorthodox than actually scummy. Davsez jumped up a few pegs in towniness for me, CT dropped a few.