Mini Normal 2035 : Duck Mafia Part 1 : GAME OVER

[the worst]

vote count 1.08

nonny

(1) : Reundo

profii

(4) : davesaz, TiphaineDeath, Completly Trustworthy, nonny

FA_Q2

(0) :

UnaBombaH

(0) :

davesaz

(0) :

Completly Trustworthy

(3) : UnaBombaH, FA_Q2, Tchill13

Gamma Emerald

(0) :

TiphaineDeath

(3) : Gamma Emerald, Carcalilly, profii

Reundo

(0) :

Flavor Leaf

(0) :

Carcalilly

(2) : Flavor Leaf, wilky

Tchill13

(0) :

wilky

(0) :

not voting:

with 13 duckies alive, it takes 7 to lynch.

day one will end with no lynch in (expired on 2018-10-02 09:00:00)

mod notes:
- quack

[Reundo]

I disagree with your issue regarding activity. You really have no idea why I voted that person?

What specifically do you disagree on? I got the gist of why you voted CT -- his lack of activity, plus possibly the fact there was already a wagon building up on him -- I just think it's a shot in the dark with so many players doing the same thing, especially when you've already expressed concerns about what some players were doing.

same though

Uh this is an odd question but is anyone a vanilla townie

I don't like this question at all.

Anything else you don't like from Carca?

asked for vt peeps
and suggested a no lnych
followed 2 wagons with pretty naked votes

it seems pretty bad to me but idk 6 pages in

For the first two points, I thought they were anti-town, but it's blatantly anti-town in a sense where I don't see why scum would want to openly ask something like that. I also got the impression they were said on impulse, which also doesn't play into it being scummy to me. As for the last point, it's fairly apparent through her ISO why she placed her votes where she did, especially w/regards to Tiphane -- not sure why "naked votes" are particularly scummy. What were you initially town-reading her for?

Something just feels off about profli to me. He initially came out of the gate trying to direct the town into voting Nonny and constantly gave advice as to what the town should do, then he just started asking others where his vote should be placed. Also, 69 seems very odd to me as well.

VOTE: profli

Why would you jump to a new wagon without reassessing your read on nonny? Are you satisfied with her response, do you think she's not as scummy anymore, or is there another reason why you shifted wagons?

Do you always post in haikus? Can you give a little more please. Where should we be looking for example?

Considering profii mentioned you in the post right after this I don't see what your concern is. You expressed concern over three players in your post -- why didn't you vote any of them?

Did not see a need to quote all three just to ask about the weird posting style. He mentioned me but that was it. Otherwise he didn't mention much at all. It was feigning activity so trying to flesh out why.

It was more a response to you asking "Where should we be looking for example?". It seemed like he did mention players to look at -- specifically you and "lurkers" -- after he made the post you quoted, so that part felt weird to me.


I'm not feeling the profii or Tiphaine wagons. I feel their play is more strange/unorthodox than actually scummy. Davsez jumped up a few pegs in towniness for me, CT dropped a few.

[Tchill13]

I voted CT just so we'd have two main wagons. I don't think either grew though...

[profii]

VOTE: Profii
Coasting in the form of bleating about activity while adding basically nothing to the discussion.

Pedit: Eh, if you're suggesting a NL it doesn't sound right to me.

So this is wrong as I pointed out earlier

Acceptable response from reundo, gonna but him and lily in my bother them more later category VOTE: Profii

naked vote

Tchill, why did you vote me, I don't think you've explained?

Something just feels off about profli to me. He initially came out of the gate trying to direct the town into voting Nonny and constantly gave advice as to what the town should do, then he just started asking others where his vote should be placed. Also, 69 seems very odd to me as well.

VOTE: profli

Dave is my greatest townread at this moment, his playstyle this game seems to match up with his towngame.
I also have a favorable opinion of Reundo now, I've liked his logic and thought process so far.

”something just feels off” - right ok

At this point I’m not even sure if it would be beneficial to lynch anyone today?

What's the benefit to a NL? It'd be better to flip someone, just currently hard to pick who. But really don't get why you'd jump to NL. I'm sure you know the % of it being helpful.

Uh this is an odd question but is anyone a vanilla townie

Trying to shrink the possible PR pool? Who would actually answer this, like what was the plan with this?

Reundo seems like town
Carcalilly also seems Town
We should look elsewhere

Do you always post in haikus? Can you give a little more please. Where should we be looking for example?

Considering profii mentioned you in the post right after this I don't see what your concern is. You expressed concern over three players in your post -- why didn't you vote any of them?

Did not see a need to quote all three just to ask about the weird posting style. He mentioned me but that was it. Otherwise he didn't mention much at all. It was feigning activity so trying to flesh out why.
Posts 135, 140-143 is just off and weird. Not sure what to make of profii at this stage but so far don't like it.

VOTE: Profii

just off and weird





I’m the leading wagon because “something just isn’t right” basically


If that doesn’t scream to town that scum is within one of you lot then I don’t know what will

We lynch any of you 4 today, probably Dave as priority 4 but the rest of you are diabolical

[profii]

Tchill, why did you vote me, I don't think you've explained?

Something just feels off about profli to me. He initially came out of the gate trying to direct the town into voting Nonny and constantly gave advice as to what the town should do, then he just started asking others where his vote should be placed. Also, 69 seems very odd to me as well.

VOTE: profli

Dave is my greatest townread at this moment, his playstyle this game seems to match up with his towngame.
I also have a favorable opinion of Reundo now, I've liked his logic and thought process so far.

Ok I’ve looked back at what you’re saying and this is the reason I do a post shtick because I don’t expect people to assume the worst in my posts but I figured scum would

What you have called “directing the town” is what I would call a reminder that we have a 7 day deadline so given the early lack of activity we needed to resolve that otherwise we get to day 5 or so and start to panic wagon

I voted nonny on the principle that he said what’s the rush - this goes against my last point which was anti town - given the lack of activity by the time I placed the vote, that was the best move we had imo - it _was_ page 2 so we needed something to realistically transition people out of RVS and I think that achieved it.

Again - 69 - we still lacked activity - if more people got involved in the nonny wagon- even just to say “not voting here, I like him because _____” it moves the game out of RVS


So yeah, you are the way to go because as I’ve pointed out you’ve come to the wrong conclusion about me at every turn which can be a sign of Scum manufacturing a reason to vote town

That is especially likely to be the case when you have 3 votes rn and could do with a counter wagon


VOTE: Completely trustworthy

[Carcalilly]

Profi and CT are likleu SvT
Mainly because I think their vote posts are slightly scummy in a way but there is no way scum buddies would do that to eachother at this point and time.

Tbh I'm slightly suspicious with the setup on this game. I have a suspicion that scum might have a minor PR if there aren't a butt load of vts.

[Carcalilly]

Also a NL would be bad at this point but if we have to decide during RVs, man cmon.

[Flavor Leaf]

Profi and CT are likleu SvT
Mainly because I think their vote posts are slightly scummy in a way but there is no way scum buddies would do that to eachother at this point and time.

Tbh I'm slightly suspicious with the setup on this game. I have a suspicion that scum might have a minor PR if there aren't a butt load of vts.

Why

[Carcalilly]

I'm not telling lol

[the worst]

vote count 1.09

nonny

(1) : Reundo

profii

(4) : davesaz, TiphaineDeath, Completly Trustworthy, nonny

FA_Q2

(0) :

UnaBombaH

(0) :

davesaz

(0) :

Completly Trustworthy

(4) : UnaBombaH, FA_Q2, Tchill13, profii

Gamma Emerald

(0) :

TiphaineDeath

(2) : Gamma Emerald, Carcalilly

Reundo

(0) :

Flavor Leaf

(0) :

Carcalilly

(2) : Flavor Leaf, wilky

Tchill13

(0) :

wilky

(0) :

not voting:

with 13 duckies alive, it takes 7 to lynch.

day one will end with no lynch in (expired on 2018-10-02 09:00:00)

mod notes:
- FA_Q2 has been prodded.
- quack

[profii]

I'm not telling lol

you're doing this on purpose lol

[Completly Trustworthy]

I like Nonny's explanation of why they made the "lynch happy" comment in 84 Reundo. I still don't feel that well about her though, especially with the follow up vote on Profii literally one post after I did with similar reasons to other people who voted him in 147. If I change my mind about Profii, I'll probably go back to voting her.

The reason I thought that Profii''s comments were weird is because he said there should be a counterwagon in 111, then didn't vote anyone until Gamma asked him to despite saying he found both Tiphaine and Carcallily suspicious in 140 and 143. He also said he would vote Davesaz if he didn't see his point in 117, but didn't despite Dave only continuing to push him in 125. I felt like he was appeasing Gamma by voting who he wanted, especially since he had not talked about Tiphiane at all before that post.


I don't agree with the people voting Carcallily, I've seen people do supposedly anti-town things before while ending up having a perfectly good reason to have behaved that way. I have a suspicion as to why she made those posts, but will not say what it is for now.

[profii]

Makes sense - I can’t be bothered to go through everything you said about me but seems like you are interpreting things in a logical / fair way

VOTE: Tiphaine/v]

[profii]

Doh

VOTE: Tiphaine

[wilky]

@reundo I also didn't like the no lunch theory and now the backtrack on that.

VOTE: Tiphaine Wheeeeee.

[Completly Trustworthy]

Wilky, has your opinion of Carcalilly changed for the better? Also, why are Tchill and Dave town to you?

[Gamma Emerald]

@profii and Wilky: reasons? Especially Wilky

[profii]

As per prior vote when you said I should vote there I read the ISO and I felt some reasoning was manufactured, didnt get that vibe from Trustworthy

And I think my wagon coming out of nowhere was bad so I’ll go for one of those

[UnaBombaH]

WOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!

[UnaBombaH]

I'm in!

[UnaBombaH]

Will do a proper read and catchup-post tomorrow morning, seven pages is nothing to me!

[Tchill13]

VOTE: ptofii

L-2. What you gonna do?

[davesaz]

@CT do you think 125 is continuing the same angle as 117?

[davesaz]

Correction, 104

[davesaz]

Profii's posting just feels wierd and off to me, and it's not the haiku's. I'll see if I can explain this more later. I also don't like the sequence of reads and votes and when they happened.

This has way less foundation than mine. If profii is town this is a good candidate for scum sheeping me.