In post 161, Completly Trustworthy wrote:I like Nonny's explanation of why they made the "lynch happy" comment in
84 Reundo. I still don't feel that well about her though, especially with the follow up vote on Profii literally one post after I did with similar reasons to other people who voted him in
147. If I change my mind about Profii, I'll probably go back to voting her.
The reason I thought that Profii''s comments were weird is because he said there should be a counterwagon in
111, then didn't vote anyone until Gamma asked him to despite saying he found both Tiphaine and Carcallily suspicious in
140 and
143. He also said he would vote Davesaz if he didn't see his point in
117, but didn't despite Dave only continuing to push him in
125. I felt like he was appeasing Gamma by voting who he wanted, especially since he had not talked about Tiphiane at all before that post.
I don't agree with the people voting Carcallily, I've seen people do supposedly anti-town things before while ending up having a perfectly good reason to have behaved that way. I have a suspicion as to why she made those posts, but will not say what it is for now.
there should be CWs
As per what Tchill said - force people to take stances - in a scum game I got caught saying “oh I’d lynch my partner” all of day 1 but with no wagon I never had to do it
If there is momentum on people 3 things happen
-people vote
-people say they won’t vote
-people say they will vote and hesitate
If there is no wagon then you can say “oh yeh I’d vote ____ if a wagon starts” and just hope no one wagons
At the time when nonny was wagoned it was page 2 and this game has been relatively low content- picking someone for delaying game seemed the best idea
Not sure why you reference 140 - gamma said check Tiphaine, I did, I voted
143 was bait - I think I know what Lily is doing so I’m actually town reading there - note lack of voting!
In reference to Dave - I know he is a tough lynch so unless he does something really bad that a lot of people jump on him for then he is not a day 1 lynch - saying that, doesn’t mean we can’t probe him for later as per that post
