Mini Normal 2035 : Duck Mafia Part 1 : GAME OVER

[Carcalilly]

maybe I wanna be lynched

ever thought of that gamma OwowoO

[Gamma Emerald]

Cool, bravado. I don’t buy it.

[James Brafin]

vote count 2.04

nonny

(0) :

FA_Q2

(0) :

UnaBombaH

(2): Reundo, Completely Trustworthry

davesaz

(0) :

Completly Trustworthy

(1) : UnaBomaH

Gamma Emerald

(0) :

Reundo

(0) :

Flavor Leaf

(0) :

Carcalilly

(2) : FA_Q2, Gamma Emerald

Tchill13

(0) :

wilky

(0) :

not voting:

nonny, davesaz, Flavor Leaf, Carcalilly, Tchill13, wilky

with 11 duckies alive, it takes 6 to lynch.

day two will end with no lynch in (expired on 2018-10-09 09:00:00)

mod notes:
- QuAcK

[Tchill13]

Oh damn I just thought of something.

[Gamma Emerald]

@mod there are multiple VC errors

Noted, though it would be slightly more helpful if you point them out to me/us

[Tchill13]

So carca...

I'd want that slot in lylo if I was scum. Oddly enough I'm not sure if that's the type of scum we are dealing with here. If carca was actually scum then it's make sense. Been a while since I played with her. I don't like her reaction to boons gambit at all.

BUT, if she's town I feel like scum is already voting her. I'm pretty much making this post so I can go back and see who was voting her at this time.

Thoughts on that?

[UnaBombaH]

Yes.
Was just about to ask what you had in mind, and I wholeheartedly agree with this idea - the problem being that only two players are currently voting Carca?

[Flavor Leaf]

Did somebody’s say l-1?.

VOTE: TiphaineDeath

@FA

I’m very lawful about when I do it. I don’t just do it out of nowhere.

I’ve also been known to hard hard hard defend people put up to L-1 early Day 1.

On the note of my gambit, I’ve done this gambit before, and nobody else was likely to investigate Profii. I thought it out beforehand. The reward was greater than the risk taken.

Plus, I’m nightkill bait, so I’ve been trying to push that further too. I get nightkilled nearly every one of my town game nowadays

[Flavor Leaf]

Great points FA. Does make me feel a bit better about you.

I don't feel like I've got a solid foundation for throwing a vote on someone yet.

FA’s someone I watched when I was new to the site because I thought his scum game was strong. Be careful. I even caught him out once because I was watching his scum game.

[Flavor Leaf]

I’m not getting ScumUnah vibes at all. He always does this “give Boon a chance”, explains me kinda thing, but when he’s scum he’s a little less into it, and does so in a way where I wouldn’t react to it as much. TownUnah has more of a “Boon, say stuff so they understand” kinda mentality.

I’m townUnah’ing this.

[Flavor Leaf]

Yes.
Was just about to ask what you had in mind, and I wholeheartedly agree with this idea - the problem being that only two players are currently voting Carca?

To be fair, I’m increasingly suspicious of both of those players right now, along with easing my scumCarca thoughts based on it being Carca.

Carcalilly is like if Mulch and Dunkerdoodles had a baby, and they saw Mafia as this new shiny object, so they started to play with it.

[Flavor Leaf]

So carca...

I'd want that slot in lylo if I was scum. Oddly enough I'm not sure if that's the type of scum we are dealing with here. If carca was actually scum then it's make sense. Been a while since I played with her. I don't like her reaction to boons gambit at all.

BUT, if she's town I feel like scum is already voting her. I'm pretty much making this post so I can go back and see who was voting her at this time.

Thoughts on that?

It’s a good thought process, but I don’t necessarily think that matters too much. Sure, it’s nice to bring a slot like that to lylo, but at the same time, you can have all the logical arguments in the world as scum, and someone like Carca will still vote against you, making it hard.

@Unah - this is similar when Vedith and I were in a hard 2v2 with you and Froggy, then 2inamillion showed up and couldn’t logic him at all.

[Flavor Leaf]

Also, FA’s 303 shades Carca, Gamma, and myself setting him up to go any way there, but yeah he baited is all in with a nice thing, then turned it.

Called my gambit terrible, but then said Carca reacted badly.
Called Gamma reaction valid, but turned it when he switched fast

This is a nicely hidden seemingly pushing a scum agenda.

VOTE: FA

That’s the ScumFA I like to watch.

[Flavor Leaf]

Reundo on the other hand, hit every single point FA was making except they went deeper and brought up the other side, and why it’s less likely to be coming from scum or at most they were NAI, whereas FA was clearly shading the three of us, which brings more doubt and discredits the slots.

[Gamma Emerald]

Also, FA’s 303 shades Carca, Gamma, and myself setting him up to go any way there, but yeah he baited is all in with a nice thing, then turned it.

Called my gambit terrible, but then said Carca reacted badly.
Called Gamma reaction valid, but turned it when he switched fast

This is a nicely hidden seemingly pushing a scum agenda.

VOTE: FA

That’s the ScumFA I like to watch.

VOTE: FAQ2
I thought the same about that post
Would like thoughts on Carca from you though (in this game, not general)

[Flavor Leaf]

So...I'm seeing a connection between Reundo and Completely Trustworthy here.
I think they both see a good potential mislynch for today, and furthermore might have been alerted by the way I answered Boons query about last nights actions..

What actually makes my Boon-paranoia rise here is the fact that I think he ought to have jumped on my answer, but didn't.
And it's not beyond him to coach his buddies (Reundo and CT in this scenario) to do the jumping instead of him!

@Boon

- wanna comment?

I can see Completely Trustworthy as scum, I can’t see Reundo there.

However, he could be trying to setup potential TownFA’s shade and be like “don’t worry, you three, mama’s home.”

To make the three of us they lowkey defended on their side. If I didn’t know you better, it might have worked.

But I kind of understand Reundo. CT is scummy to me however.

[Flavor Leaf]

And yes, I would coach even if I didn’t mean to.

[Flavor Leaf]

Also, FA’s 303 shades Carca, Gamma, and myself setting him up to go any way there, but yeah he baited is all in with a nice thing, then turned it.

Called my gambit terrible, but then said Carca reacted badly.
Called Gamma reaction valid, but turned it when he switched fast

This is a nicely hidden seemingly pushing a scum agenda.

VOTE: FA

That’s the ScumFA I like to watch.

VOTE: FAQ2
I thought the same about that post
Would like thoughts on Carca from you though (in this game, not general)

Carca’s Carca. I think she’s just silly, and more likely town than scum here. I don’t see her having that, as you called it, “false bravada” as scum. I imagine she would stress out a little more.

[Flavor Leaf]

You said cool bravado, whatever, you got what I meant

[Gamma Emerald]

There was a comma there lol

[Flavor Leaf]

FA being scum might counteract the statement made about one of Unah/Gamma/Tchill being scum. FA’s definitely the most old school player in this game, which means he might have automatically expected me to self implode and hurt the town in a massive way. His comments towards the gambit show that was his mindset anyways, so that’s likely to be truthful even if he is scum. That is actually a good scum play because it’s pushing a perceived flawed town play.

However, I did feel comfortable enough due to knowing certain players here know me so well.

I can see Unah/Tchill/Gamma as all town with ScumFA.

@You 3 - If I’m scum, I’m taking my boldness to a whole new level with this one.

[Flavor Leaf]

And I can’t really explain it, but I expect one of Dave/Wilky to be scum.

[Flavor Leaf]

Honest question here FL: If I remember correctly you were the "did someone say L-1" and then hammer guy every time. Should we expect you to turbohammer anyone at L-1 or has that changed?

This is the only thing that holds me back from potential ScumFA.

[UnaBombaH]

I'm really liking Boon for town now.
Chill feels very strongly like his town-self. (I have had a knack for scumreading him correctly whenever it has been the case)
Carca is always somewhat "surface-level" scummy, or as someone else might put it, lynchbait-y, so not gonna townlock them, but not seriously scumreading them for now.
Gamma has seemingly been very on-point with their analysis so far (the way I see it), and vocal enough to get some solid towncred from me for now...

I'm off to bed now, but I'm starting to like our chances already. (plz get a wagon rolling before I wake up! )

[UnaBombaH]

Lol, one more thing before I'm off to bed - I love me some actively posting Boon!

Honest question here FL: If I remember correctly you were the "did someone say L-1" and then hammer guy every time. Should we expect you to turbohammer anyone at L-1 or has that changed?

This is the only thing that holds me back from potential ScumFA.

I was going to look for this post in the morning too, but since you already brought it up.
I feel like this promotes a towny mindset(?) in a way that feels like an odd thing to ever fake..errr...if that makes sense?

Like

"a thing I don't see a scum bringing up just to appear as towny"

- and it really feels like it's coming from a towny pov, so..?