Mini 2036: Charging Up! - Game Over

[BNL]

VC 3.1

Vaxkiller (1): Gamma Emerald

Not Voting (8): Vaxkiller, Lady Angel, Flavor Leaf, Porkens, ManateeDude, Kokichi Oma, GuiltyLion, theslimer3

With 9 alive it takes 5 to lynch.

The deadline is 13 November 10am UTC-4, or in (expired on 2018-11-13 10:00:00)

Mod Notes:

[Kokichi Oma]

So we wait

[Vaxkiller]

I really want to hear from the slim3r

[Porkens]

@Porkens did you target RC n1?

nope

[Vaxkiller]

See I told you porkens would town up day 2!

[Gamma Emerald]

See I told you porkens would town up day 2!

It’s day 3
And what has he done that is “towning up”

[Kokichi Oma]

See I told you porkens would town up day 2!

It’s day 3
And what has he done that is “towning up”

^

[Gamma Emerald]

Didn’t you object to my vote on Porkens d2
Did you change your mind or do you suspect him and just think the point I made was bad

[Kokichi Oma]

The point you made was bad. But the statement Vax made was worse, since Porkens has done nothing that anyone should consider towning up.

[Vaxkiller]

It was a joke... that fell flat apparently. I thought it was apparent he has done literally nothing. Hey porky you got anything to tell us?

[Vaxkiller]

I'm rather suspicious of slim3r right now btw. I fell like he is crafting an answer

[BNL]

ManateeDude

and

GuiltyLion

have been prodded

[GuiltyLion]

lol I just realized it's 36 hours instead of 48 hour prods, that explains a lot

I don't buy the slimer tracker claim at all, I agree that looks like they literally just forgot that DS was a tracker. There was nothing in their posting after DS claimed tracker that indicates that they had the same role either

VOTE: slimer

at work right now but will be around again later today / this afternoon. also I have some light role related reasons to think LA is scum as well - it's not 100% indicative and I don't want to disclose fully yet but just want to note that I am surprised that nothing seemed to change for her overnight, I was expecting that she would re-evaluate or have some more substantial new thoughts to offer in response to my opening poke on her

[Gamma Emerald]

Tell me how slimer’s posting doesn’t indicate Tracker actually? I checked and he did push DS quite a bit post-claim

[GuiltyLion]

also I'm not sure what to think of that Gamma+Kokichi tag team on Vax above... I thought it was pretty obvious Vax's 1454 was a joke

scumreads are still generally Slimer, Lady, then someone in {Kokichi/Manatee/Vax}. Vax feels towniest of the three though he isn't actually doing much game-solving, his tone/posting feels honest, especially that reply to me end of D2. Kokichi is skating by on the cop claim but I am hoping night actions can help to resolve that in some way

p-edit @Gamma:

You're reacting to this pretty poorly.. consider me voting you, but I wont actually do it till you're at l-3, or a hammer if it's late enough in the day phase and I'm totally convinced.

The way you're taking everything is just so overdramatic and unnecessary. Claiming so early was such a poor decision, and your ranting at us being such a bad town reeks of omgus and desperation.

Of course you wouldn't claim scum tracker, who does that? And its day one, even if you're lynched there's so much more time. No ones listening to Rc, most people are either being an idiot or came to the conclusion on their own

if I'm town tracker and I think scum is lying about claiming my role, I do not make this post. It's far too waffley both in the first and last sections. They also say "claiming was a poor decision" which in hindsight can only come from someone who is townreading the other player/knows they are town... if slimer thought there was a possibility that scum!DS was fakeclaiming then they wouldn't say it was a "poor decision".

DS also made this post:

No I'm town offended for your site that they consider this good scum play from you. I'm pretty obviously town,

just claimed a pretty decent town role with no counter

, and not a single vote came off of me. There is 100% scum on my wagon and you have been saying "NDG is lock scum, Slimer is scum, DS is lock scum" all game just waiting for someone to sheep you and that's not a town mindstate

with no direct response from slimer. At the very least he should/would have

implied

a possible counterclaim. instead there's a total absence of any kind of claim-related suspicion.

one other thing I had noticed in reviewing their ISO:

I just realized something. Day 4 is going to be fun if we make it that far

what kind of townie says "

if

" we make it to Day 4??

[theslimer3]

I'm still alive. I'm gonna respond slowly though since I cant multiquote

[theslimer3]

Did anyone charge Not Mafia night 1?

I claim tracker.
And I say this because I thing we were in a pool, number drawn for roles. Scum included.

My theory is they have any chance to get any roles we do. Even cop/doc

???

Wasnt DS tracker?

Oh wow that’s some stupidity
I DOUBT two trackers in a game this small, even technically one shot

Who the hell would charge nm? Hes been trolling all game and didnt take anything seriously. and I'm under the impression that he hasn't used his ability night one despite its effectiveness.

Also yes, DS did claim tracker. That's really observant of you.

I claimed because I have a feeling that we were on a roll sheet and our roles come from what number we pull.

[ManateeDude]

No way theres 4 TIs even if theyre 1-shot

[theslimer3]

Setting up something would probably entail me having some sort of plan and acting upon it, not saying that im tracker then giving info about the setup. If that's the way I was taking it, that probably wouldn't benefit me as scum.

I tracked Vax night 1. However, instead of being told what happened regarding you, I was just told that you haven't charged anyone

[Gamma Emerald]

Ok here’s the thing:
There is a marginal thought in my mind that slimer is town and just fell victim to circumstance. How long have you had the thought of the roles being pulled from a list slimer?
Thing is if slimer is town I doubt Kokichi is, and vice versa. I doubt we’d have cop and two trackers, it just seems a little out of setup feng shui. I think a Tracker alone is kinda weak thought so one is probably town

[Gamma Emerald]

No way theres 4 TIs even if theyre 1-shot

Wait 4?

[Gamma Emerald]

Setting up something would probably entail me having some sort of plan and acting upon it, not saying that im tracker then giving info about the setup. If that's the way I was taking it, that probably wouldn't benefit me as scum.

I tracked Vax night 1. However, instead of being told what happened regarding you, I was just told that you haven't charged anyone

Is your role name Tracker or something else?

[ManateeDude]

No way theres 4 TIs even if theyre 1-shot

Wait 4?

DS, kokichi, N_M and Slimer

[theslimer3]

@guilty: why would I not try to go against the grain and think there could he a scum tracker? I'm covering up myself to not out myself as another tracker. Or at least wondering why they're claiming tracker when it's my role PM.

@gamma: when ds flipped, I was sure that the only way we have 2 trackers is by role mapping.
And it's just straight tracker

[Gamma Emerald]

@guilty: why would I not try to go against the grain and think there could he a scum tracker? I'm covering up myself to not out myself as another tracker. Or at least wondering why they're claiming tracker when it's my role PM.

@gamma: when ds flipped, I was sure that the only way we have 2 trackers is by role mapping.
And it's just straight tracker

So you were skeptical of DS but not ready to full counter? I can understand that. And how do you get results about chatging if you’re straight Tracker?