Overkill 1: Serenity/Firefly (GAME OVER)

[CheekyTeeky]

Chara you're next

[Gamma Emerald]

huh......
I either understand everything or nothing

[Elsa Jay]

Oh, so you're the real Simon I was worried would get shot and have everyone murder me. Glad I sided with you then.

[RightKnight]

Ok I'm a compulsive Doc who can only protect from 1- kill
N1 - Doc'd Chara
N2 - Doc'd RR
N3 - Doc'd RR

I had "a member of the serenity crew" in my role PM,

You must be Simon then?

But why weren’t you suspicious when Elsa claimed to have protected you?

Tora/I obviously thought he was the actual doc.

[RightKnight]

huh......
I either understand everything or nothing

[Elsa Jay]

Didn't someone bring up the fact that this series has multiple doctors before? I wasn't the one who ever said I was Simon, just claiming one of the random fodder doctors. You all assigned me as Simon.

[CheekyTeeky]

But why weren’t you suspicious when Elsa claimed to have protected you?

Because I can only protect from 1-kill, thought I'd be stronger if I was the real Simon. Anyway I wasn't outting at that stage of the game regardless.

[RightKnight]

Ok I'm a compulsive Doc who can only protect from 1- kill
N1 - Doc'd Chara
N2 - Doc'd RR
N3 - Doc'd RR

I had "a member of the serenity crew" in my role PM,

Toogeloo, was your lightening rod still in effect last night?

[Chara]

so you're a doctor, but also a crew member, which Simon according to Toog is not? hm. i don't know who you would be then or if that's right to begin with.

i'm also specifically a crew member. that's why i knew what Rational was referring to with the extra flavour.
and i'm Loved. that's all.

[Chara]

before anyone says "let's test that", at least make sure both Elsa and Mala are on the wagon before you take me to L-1? thank you.

[Chara]

oh and i'm not loved in mylo/lylo.

[Elsa Jay]

But why weren’t you suspicious when Elsa claimed to have protected you?

Because I can only protect from 1-kill, thought I'd be stronger if I was the real Simon. Anyway I wasn't outting at that stage of the game regardless.

... You can't only protect from one, otherwise the HoB and Thor would have killed Toog.

[RightKnight]

so you're a doctor, but also a crew member, which Simon according to Toog is not? hm. i don't know who you would be then or if that's right to begin with.

i'm also specifically a crew member. that's why i knew what Rational was referring to with the extra flavour.
and i'm Loved. that's all.

Toogeloo is probably taking things too literally like all the people, who insisted Nico/Tails couldn’t possibly be HoB, due to them not being in the Serenity movie trailer.

[Chara]

i don't agree. i think the flavour is especially relevant due to Rational being explicitly not a crew member.
but i don't know enough to say which of the crew Cheeky would fit as... besides the actual doctor.

[RightKnight]

But why weren’t you suspicious when Elsa claimed to have protected you?

Because I can only protect from 1-kill, thought I'd be stronger if I was the real Simon. Anyway I wasn't outting at that stage of the game regardless.

... You can't only protect from one, otherwise the HoB and Thor would have killed Toog.

But Toogeloo’s LR couldn’t have possibly been in effect N2 or Thor wouldn’t have been killed, right?

I think Toogeloo should specifically claim the modifiers of his LR. Like, was it non-consecutive or a 1-shot? That would tell us whether RR was actually targeted or not.

[Elsa Jay]

I mean't n1. That night, both Thor and the HoB attacked, I assume. How Didn't he die n1?

[RightKnight]

i don't agree. i think the flavour is especially relevant due to Rational being explicitly not a crew member.
but i don't know enough to say which of the crew Cheeky would fit as... besides the actual doctor.

I didn’t say it was irrelevant, otherwise we obviously wouldn’t have a flavour cop. What I’m saying is that we can’t interpret things too literally.

[Chara]

speaking of being too literal, does Simon

have

to be a doctor? Kaylee's a mechanic if i recall, that might work.

[RightKnight]

I mean't n1. That night, both Thor and the HoB attacked, I assume. How Didn't he die n1?

Something to do with either JK or doc. Either doc or HoB JK bring used on anybody but Toogeloo could have accounted for that.

[RightKnight]

speaking of being too literal, does Simon

have

to be a doctor? Kaylee's a mechanic if i recall, that might work.

If Cheeky is Kaylee, then who do you think is Simon?

Am I understanding this right?

[Reasonably Rational]

I mean't n1. That night, both Thor and the HoB attacked, I assume. How Didn't he die n1?

LR effect forced the HoB Jailkeep to target him. Since Jailkeeping prevents all kills and not just one, there is no mystery here. (I'm assuming Jailkeeper is the normal version of the role since the HoB were only precluded from jailing each other and given no other modifications/restrictions).

~D

[Elsa Jay]

Oh right, forgot about the Jailkeep being affected by the a LR weirdly as well. Thanks for that, Drixx.

[Jingle]

I would've commuted N1 if I were Thor, FWIW. But yeah, LR probably lived because of the Jailkeep, regardless of how many people tried to kill them.

[BuJaber]

I'm a seraph knight for Malcolm. I don't know who it is just that it's whoever Malcolm is.

I die in their place. Lynch or NK doesn't matter.

That's why it's doubly hard for Mala to win. I don't mess with lynchers I just mess with Mala specifically.

I don't have the crew member extra line thing. I also have a tendency to confirm my alignment to the mod when I confirm my role but since this game it wasn't explicitly stated I added something like I assume I'm town, to which A50 replied and his reply implies that town is made up of serenity + allies. Whatever that means.

That's all.. I didn't want someone to try to fakeclaim Mal somehow. I also wanted to keep the WIFOM of me being Mal as long as possible as that would literally be the best way to keep him alive.

[Gamma Emerald]

I'm a seraph knight for Malcolm. I don't know who it is just that it's whoever Malcolm is.

I die in their place. Lynch or NK doesn't matter.

That's why it's doubly hard for Mala to win. I don't mess with lynchers I just mess with Mala specifically.

I don't have the crew member extra line thing. I also have a tendency to confirm my alignment to the mod when I confirm my role but since this game it wasn't explicitly stated I added something like I assume I'm town, to which A50 replied and his reply implies that town is made up of serenity + allies. Whatever that means.

That's all.. I didn't want someone to try to fakeclaim Mal somehow. I also wanted to keep the WIFOM of me being Mal as long as possible as that would literally be the best way to keep him alive.

This got a small chuckle out of me, I had a similar role in a game from 2016 (Death Note Mafia). I can’t get into the best part though.