Open 740: Hope Plus One [Game over]

[BuJaber]

Vote Count 2.1:

ChibiBear (2):

bristep123, Almost50

ReaperOfSouls (1):

Alonzo

DS (1):

Gamma Emerald

Not Voting (7):

Clemency, ReaperOfSouls, DS, Bambietta Basterbine, Egix96, davesaz, ChibiBear

With 11 alive, it takes 6 to lynch.

Deadline:

(expired on 2018-12-13 08:20:00)

[Clemency]

real smooth

[ChibiBear]

You can atleast confirm we're not fucking up with you being a doctor? That'll save you until like, atleast day 3.

My play is inherently scummy because I'm a bad player. Stop focusing on me being a bad player and start considering if scum would gain anything from behaving as I have, that might actually get you somewhere.

My play is also inheritantly what people call scummy, but you don't hear me hide behind it being my style of play, you know.

You saw how everyone reacted to what I did. If you ARE town, for a little bit, worry about why some people were creeped out by me saving Egix96.

Speaking if that Egi, now that Clem confirms me, I expect a thank you now.

Yours is your chosen playstyle though, you say that like I'm actively choosing to be bad at this

[Bambietta Basterbine]

The Chibanana ignores the part about the doctor claim, so I'm just gonna go on a limb and say they aren't a doctor.

[ChibiBear]

Okay so D2, time to switch on the brain.

-Apart from Clem and Bambi, I'm liking Bri for town now.
-I'm not sure what to make of DS's cop claim, but I'm leaning troll-y town over ballsey scum.
-I was initially finding A50's tone possibly scummy but people who know him better than me don't seem to be of the same opinion so I'm probably wrong there. I still don't like his argument that I'm scum for refusing to vote for 'outed scum'. Confident town or scum looking for an easy mislynch? Could still go either way.
-Gamma is pretty much as I remember him to be as town, but his town play is not particularly towny so this is still a null for me.
-Waiting for RoS to post more, null.
-I was slightly scum leaning ofrhz iirc but I'll wait for Alonzo to post more.
-Dave I was town leaning on D1 but I'm feeling that less now. He voted volxen halfway through the wagon and then disappeared, I could definitely see him as scum who knew that volxen was getting lynched so he jumped on the wagon and left it at that.
-Egix is probably town I reckon, he feels like town.


@Alonzo: Why RoS?

[ChibiBear]

The Chibanana ignores the part about the doctor claim, so I'm just gonna go on a limb and say they aren't a doctor.

Oh I didn't realise that bit was aimed at me. Nah I'm just a boring ole VT.

Bananya master race! :3

[ChibiBear]

Bambi what do you think of DS? Trolly town or ballsey scum?

[DS]

Answer is neither: I was providing protective claim subterfuge


i thought that was obvious lmao

[Alonzo]

AHHH yeah!

Gratz on the Grandchild!

Now I 'member why I wanted to 'member ya

@ROS

Unvote

[ReaperOfSouls]

AHHH yeah!

Gratz on the Grandchild!

Now I 'member why I wanted to 'member ya

@ROS

Unvote

Thank you sir.

[Alonzo]

Gamma is pretty much as I remember him to be as town, but his town play is not particularly towny so this is still a null for me.

Tell me more about Gamma, How has he played before?

[ChibiBear]

I mean we were both in Boon’s game and I was in Witches’ Ball with him too. I initially thought he was scum in both games because of the way he posts (kinda minimally and stuff) and I found it hard to figure out his intentions in the early game. This time around feels about the same so far but since that play style can be easily done from either alignment, it’s NAI for now. Mostly it’s stopping me from automatically scum reading him based on tone again.

[DS]

Can we talk about who out of the people that voted AFTER the cop claim are most likely scum?

Im going to take a wild guess and assume its not SA.

Queue music

It's the....

FINAL VOTECOUNT (of day 1)

Vote Count 1.14:

volxen (7) (LYNCH):

bristep123, Bambietta Basterbine, Egix96, davesaz,

Gamma Emerald, Almost50, Sleepless Assassin

Bambietta Basterbine (3):

ofrhz, DS, volxen

ChibiBear (1):

ReaperOfSouls

Not Voting (2):

ChibiBear, Clemency

With 13 alive, it takes 7 to lynch.

Deadline:

(expired on 2018-11-27 20:00:00)
[/color]

[DS]

Also, just as a note of something that stood out to me:

Dave voted Volxen but totally threw shade on Clem literally the post before Volxen's fake claim and the counter that came quickly after.

[DS]

from my pov: Scum is either 2/3 of ofr, Reaper, & Chibi - or someone bussed. Did that potential bus happen before or after the cop claim? After makes more sense to me

[DS]

Good enough for me!

For reals though, currently based on last day and what we know I have Clem, Bambi, A50, Egix and Gamma as town leans right now (conf town in the case of Clem and Bambi) plus me obv, that leaves Davesaz, DS, Alfonso, Chibi and Reaper as null or scum, out of that Chibi is my strongest lean.

okay but who is null and who is scum because you just basically split the game in half and said half are town leans and half are null/scum

there are two scum. Who are they?

[DS]

To be fair you saying you're a bad player only really works if we know your meta to verify that. I've said often that this is the first game I've played in around 5 years but I wouldn't for a second use that to defend a read on me.

Also - would scum have anything to gain from behaving as you have, if they can successfully play it off as inexperience or bad play then yes, i think they would.

Anyway, I'm voting for you, not tunnelling on you right now so also looking elsewhere.

Volxen's wagon is interesting. Assuming that 1 of his scummates was on the wagon there's only one name on there that I don't currently town read and that is Davesaz. If he's not scum that means the other reads were either on Bambi, Chibi or not voting and we had a total town wagon on Volxen (which if true then yay town!). Normally I'd say no way but in a lurky game like this it's possible.

If Reaper is scum with Chibi then his EOD vote would be some lovely distancing since if Chibi was lynched and revealed as scum then that's good 'look guys town' evidence for them to use.

DS - I dunno man, I get some terrible vibes but that late fakeclaim at the end of the day was lunacy to try and pull if scum.

Did what i was trying to accomplish with that claim at EOD really fly over everyones heads or are you all just horrible at mafia

[DS]

The Chibanana ignores the part about the doctor claim, so I'm just gonna go on a limb and say they aren't a doctor.

Oh I didn't realise that bit was aimed at me. Nah I'm just a boring ole VT.

Bananya master race! :3

ugh, why do people claim Vt. Youre narrowing the field.

[ChibiBear]

I mean maybe I'm just not understanding, but I thought that for a protective claim to work it has to be ya know... Believable

Wait

from my pov: Scum is either 2/3 of ofr, Reaper, & Chibi - or someone bussed. Did that potential bus happen before or after the cop claim? After makes more sense to me

ugh, why do people claim Vt. Youre narrowing the field.

If you think I'm more likely than not scum then why is my claim narrowing the field? I'd only be narrowing the field if I'm town.

[DS]

I mean maybe I'm just not understanding, but I thought that for a protective claim to work it has to be ya know... Believable

Wait

from my pov: Scum is either 2/3 of ofr, Reaper, & Chibi - or someone bussed. Did that potential bus happen before or after the cop claim? After makes more sense to me

ugh, why do people claim Vt. Youre narrowing the field.

If you think I'm more likely than not scum then why is my claim narrowing the field? I'd only be narrowing the field if I'm town.

Sorry if that wasnt clear. I severely doubt that 2/3 of you are scum. I definitely think someone bussed there. I thought I had kinda made that point by asking about the wagon in my first post of that sequence

[DS]

I mean maybe I'm just not understanding, but I thought that for a protective claim to work it has to be ya know... Believable

yeah but idk why people are sussing me by calling it a "fake claim" - it wasnt really. It was cop cover not a fake claim

[DS]

Personally I feel like there is a distinct difference, but maybe thats just my own meta

[ChibiBear]

Ah that makes sense, sorry, day drinking because it’s a Friday

Considering the trajectory of the volxen wagon I also would assume that at least 1 scum is likely to have been on the wagon. Also like just statistically too.

[ChibiBear]

That was @944 btw phone posting sucks.

[Gamma Emerald]

vote:RoS

A50 sent me

Why not chibibear

U know something I don't?

Nope
Chibi is A50’s Lessing scumread so you sheeping the secondary read is shady