How did you put it before?In post 474, Persivul wrote:Exactly.In post 470, Clemency wrote:where's the rest of it
CL's response to that:I don't mind votes...but I'd like actual cases to go along with them. Kinda helps people sort things out later after flips.In post 375, Chateau Lobby wrote:Less is more.
In post 451, Chateau Lobby wrote:Yes, you agree with xt, who agrees with overkill.In post 450, stan1ey wrote:No i agree with xtoxm, i think he could be scum but we might as well wait as see and lynch elsewhere
A=B
B=C
A=C
Do you agree with Stanley's rebuttal?In post 452, stan1ey wrote:Nope youre wrong: xtoxm doesnt agree with overkill. Overkill says his role is self confirmable, xtoxm says that because overkill role is confirmable we might aswell wait and see, and thats what i agree.
That does not xtoxm agrees with overkill and therefore i agree with overkill
Three things:In post 477, Xtoxm wrote:Pers. You've posted enough that I feel like I should have got something town from you. What's your vote on springtap about?
The rebuttal isn't based on the truth of overkill's claim.In post 479, Chateau Lobby wrote:No. Overkills claim was fake.
I trust Not_Mafia because in the games I've played with him, he had a really good eye. His style is unorthodox, but so far I'm sure he's town and can be relied on. Call it 50/50 experience and gut feeling. But I admit he's hard to read.In post 437, stan1ey wrote:UnAh makes a very good point in 407. Sasha says he scumreads Overkill because he trusts those on the wagon but his post suggests the only one he trusts is NM:@Sasha why do you trust him?In post 412, Sashaddin wrote:Not_Mafia: third game with him iirc, I trust him the way he posts again. I don't see why he's not trustable (well I thought that the first game but now I know him).
All he is done all game is push for overkill and post memes, and youre scumreading overkill based on this? i cant see how anyone can have anything other than a null read on NM so this looks like youre covering up for 407
Ofc you dont, but its what you said here:In post 412, Sashaddin wrote:You are right I didn't add Clemncy. Must I absolutely townread everyone on my wagon? You said yourself that there could be scum on it...In post 389, Sashaddin wrote:Right now, I'd go for Overkill or A50. The first one because I trust some on the wagon and his situation seems murky., and at first I didnt think much of Sashas reply to my question but UnaH has made a very good point in 407 and sashas reply didnt do him any favours so id be willing to vote hereIm also pretty sure UnaH is town this game based on my (albeit limited) experience playing a game with him before
...and if we get a townflip I get a free t-shirt with this mislynch.
Una gives reasons for what he does. NM doesn't. Big difference.In post 482, Sashaddin wrote:But... you say yourself above you trust UnaH playing 1 game with the guy; while this is at least the 3rd time I play with N_M. Yet you scumread for all this? Come on.
What was different?In post 485, stan1ey wrote:I played a game with UnAh where he was mafia and it was incredibly easy to spot and he is playing a lot differently here.
So far he's done exactly the same as before: piling on good wagons and pointing out the bad ones; the guy got good reads usually. I imagine if he were scum one of these would change and since he plays a lot someone would probably have had some doubts on him too. It's more of a environmental situation than an isolated read on the guy, if you can understand what I'm trying to express (English is my second language).In post 488, stan1ey wrote:He was acting very confident and his posts were patronising and suggested he knew more than others even though his arguments made no sense and were clearly manufactured, very very different to how he has played this game
Now since you asked me and I answered, what makes you think NM is town this game based on your experience?? Because it seems to me he plays the exact same way every game
You're not helping my case, dude!
My current lynch order is Sashaddin -> anyone and everyone else.
![:]](./images/smilies/icon_smiling.png "Cheerful Smile"){kind=icon}
)
I'll be snickering in the dead thread when you take that cop hat off.In post 493, UnaBombaH wrote:Sashaddin should be lynched because of a very telling and obvious scumpost.
I made this post with the idea of "Overkill is going to be lynched D2 anyway".In post 444, Chateau Lobby wrote:Last post quoted strange.In post 323, UnaBombaH wrote:Overki11 is likely never able to conf.town to us anyway, so delaying their lynch until ??? seems stupid.
Stupid phone posting.
This is quote I wanted.
Sure, you can do that no matter what you flip.In post 494, Sashaddin wrote:I'll be snickering in the dead thread when you take that cop hat off.In post 493, UnaBombaH wrote:Sashaddin should be lynched because of a very telling and obvious scumpost.
Posts like these only make me want to lynch you more.In post 495, Sashaddin wrote:Hey, UnaH, look at my meta and tell me if I had a game with a good Day 1. Hint: I never do.
Basically this.In post 460, Xtoxm wrote:Doesn't matter if he's the scummiest scum who ever scummed. He literally has bought himself 1 day. If he's scum he has scumbuddies we can lynch today. And he comes with bullshit tomorrow we turbo lynch him. No big deal.
Why are you protecting Sash?
