Open 740: Hope Plus One [Game over]

[ChibiBear]

I said I don't want to talk about it any more.

If you think my behavior is scum indicative then that's fine. If you want to criticize my attitude then you can do that after the game ends. The last thing I want to do is discourage people from posting, I just want this game to be done with.

[ReaperOfSouls]

Vote Count 3.1:

ChibiBear (2):

bristep123, ReaperOfSouls

Gamma Emerald (1):

ChibiBear

Not Voting (6):

davesaz, Bambietta Basterbine, Clemency, DS, Gamma Emerald, Alonzo

With 9 alive, it takes 5 to lynch.

Deadline:

(expired on 2018-12-22 19:35:00)

8 players left.
Cleared:Clemency, Bambi, Alonzo(if I am leaving someone out please inform, I am trying to get this plant started backup after this winter storm)
Cleared by inference: davesaz
I have a TR on bristep123.
Leaving Chibibear, Gamma, DS, and myself.
I know what my alignment is. But I understand you all can't take me at my word.
Leaving DS, Gamma, and Chibibear.
I prefer to lynch Chibibear. But I will go with town consensus.
We sit at 9 left with one scum. Let's process this and end it with the next lynch if possible. If not let's set it up where we maintain the overwhelming advantage we have. And yes I understand what that could mean.

[bristep123]

I'll actually correct myself. If you aren't scum Chibi then 1 player might try to advantage of bad play to push a mislynch. That's their job though, and this is a game where every town player suspects everyone (until they die/get confirmed) so really you should still try to participate. Lynching town is bad, if you're town then fight for a town win! Giving up because you think everyone is against you isn't the way to go.

ANYWAY. Bold move, but lets take a chance that we have a frustrated town, and a pocketing scum.

UNVOTE; VOTE : Reaper

[ReaperOfSouls]

You have town who is willing to help. I am a team player and if this is the course of action that the town feels like it needs to do to clear things up then I will accept my fate and hope that it helps work for a town win. Means I win too. But I would hope that the time left in this phase goes towards vetting everyone that is not clear so that if I am the plan at this stage there is a course of action that follows when I flip town.

[davesaz]

I did an ISO on bristep123 and saw several things to make him a town read. It had been unclear because earlier his posting had seemed a bit manipulative, but in retrospect those things look much better. I don't think it helps town at this point to go into too much detail.

[ReaperOfSouls]

I did an ISO on bristep123 and saw several things to make him a town read. It had been unclear because earlier his posting had seemed a bit manipulative, but in retrospect those things look much better. I don't think it helps town at this point to go into too much detail.

Agreed.

In your opinion the course of action to take?

[davesaz]

According to the potential Gamma tell I was working on before, it's coming up a big negative, as in not town. I would prefer not to explain in depth because he'd know what to do to fix it.
I think Gamma is our last scum on that meta. On top of that I'm seeing some things that are independently scummy.

He was a weak initial supporter of scumreads on Volxen and Egix, then late (2nd half) onto both wagons. He at one point called them as the team.
If you do some iso reading, you'll see that he has weak scumreads all over the place but never seems to really push any of them. This seems to me to be planting seeds for later -- to be able to say yeah I thought they were scummy but just now getting to pursuing it. It also feels like he lacks conviction, like he knows it's going to be hard to make a case so he'd rather see others do the lifting.

[davesaz]

Right now my course of action is to do some heavy reading.

[ReaperOfSouls]

I could follow that road.

[Alonzo]

Same potentially, will rr Gamma later when back at pc

[Gamma Emerald]

Lolwut
Also have seen 0 towncasing of bristep

Gam, why are you twitchy about me? Do you think I'm likely to be scum ahead of any of the others? It kinda bugs me but I'll tell you what's up, I led the charge on Volxen and got on board with Egix on D2. You look at my ISO initially it'll show you I'm not experienced enough to be playing that isolationist a game if I was scum.

You've had reads of your own and I haven't seen any cases from you either so lets go catch scum, Chibi or Reaper which way do you fall?

Chibi - Nobody is complaining that you're a bad player. They are ANALYSING YOUR BEHAVIOUR. You are the only one who has called yourself a bad player, or discounted your own reads. sorry if you had a bad experience in another game but as Dave says you are on day 3 still going on process of elimination with no analysis. People who are voting for you are doing so because they think you're scum. Nobody is putting you under the spotlight because they think you are a bad townie, that's totally on you I'm sorry.

I have a read on you but I’d prefer to hold onto it until someone posts an actual towncase
As for who I’d pick out of those two initial leaning is Chibi but I haven’t looked at RoS as much

[BuJaber]

Bambietta has been prodded
Clemency has been prodded a little early (has 26 hours to respond)

[Bambietta Basterbine]

Just stayed quiet since trolling around would distract you all. Seems Clem had the same idea.

Chibi, you confirmed yourself as not being the doctor. The real second doctor is hiding among the rest of the people you are accusing.

I don't want to run up the real doctor by accident. You seem like the only choice. If we are wrong, we have a much better chance to win still.

[Alonzo]

Game how do you compare chibibear here to chibibear in the last boony game?

[Alonzo]

Gamma*

[Gamma Emerald]

Game how do you compare chibibear here to chibibear in the last boony game?

Not sure
I just remember feeling they were suspect
Plus they’re the last of the D1 predictions A50 gave iirc (could be someone else’s predictions)

[Clemency]

Just stayed quiet since trolling around would distract you all. Seems Clem had the same idea.

Chibi, you confirmed yourself as not being the doctor. The real second doctor is hiding among the rest of the people you are accusing.

I don't want to run up the real doctor by accident. You seem like the only choice. If we are wrong, we have a much better chance to win still.

all of this^

[Elsa Jay]

I'm just gonna vote for Chibi since it seems like the right thing to do.

VOTE: Chibibear

I hope the other doctor comes out tommorow, but it's their call or whatever.

Sorry Chibi, but we have to get rid of the ones that'll help us win the game.

[Bambietta Basterbine]

I'm just gonna vote for Chibi since it seems like the right thing to do.

VOTE: Chibibear

I hope the other doctor comes out tommorow, but it's their call or whatever.

Sorry Chibi, but we have to get rid of the ones that'll help us win the game.

... Honest to god fuckup, Jabs. No ban plz.

VOTE: Chibibear so it's in the correct ISO.

[bristep123]

I'll claim right now if you want, there's sod all else going on in the game. At least it gives us 4 town for the scum to go for at night meaning at worst we get to lylo (if we keep mislynching) with 1 conf town still intact if my maths are right (5 unconf-4 conf now, 4-3 tomorrow, 3-2, 2-1)

[Bambietta Basterbine]

You didnt have to reveal, but it REALLY helps since unless the last scum is stupid, they're garunteed to kill the Cop tonight because mechanics. It'll be 3 confirmed town and 4 people who are unknown, but I'm positive we can read them well enough.

I think it still seems decent the Chibi ends the game, but hey, we get to be very sure

DS tried to murder Egi day 1 and helped hammer both scum. Nearly confirmed by actions alone.

If we hang Chibi-Reaper-Gamma-Dave in that order we win this no matter what.

[bristep123]

In case anyone doesn't believe me, I've bolded the important bits from below for clarity since I done breadcrumbed my role.

It kinda bugs

(bunny)

me but I'll tell you what's up

(DOC)

, I led the charge on Volxen and got on board with Egix on D2.

You look at my ISO initially it'll show you

I'm not experienced enough to be playing that isolationist a game if I was scum.

I

don't know any of you. Or do I?

Vote Sleepless Assassin

A

h well that maybe.

M

aybe just me but I don't get what you mean.

D

oes anyone?

O

k, 9 pages to catch up on.

C

an't say it's from a place of experience (or skill!) but it's an attempt to. Like I said, maybe I'm seeing something in nothing, but it's certainly piqued my interest.

T

hanks! Happy to be back, but so much to learn/re-learn.

O

k, so initial reads.

R

eally? Interesting how, what have I bumbled my way across?

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=K7VmOZ4Ppj8

and sure, I can get on board.

UNVOTE; VOTE : Chibibear

[Bambietta Basterbine]

Well if the scum claimed doctor at this point it would be suicide, so no reason not to believe you.

Do you have any arguments for Dave-Reaper-Gamma being town? The order can change a bit.

[Clemency]

i can hammer that before i go to sleep rn

[Clemency]

but i'm thinking the time would be well used thinking and planning