Open 742: C9++ (Game Over)

[Gnelf]

yeah except this game is what i mean

[PenguinPower]

Ok...

[Almost50]

We just finished that game...

What does that do to your Gnelf read?

I think the fact he is playing and didn't replace out is indicative of Town him still. I'm NOT saying Oka would necessarily replace out as Scum, but he brought in two newbies and let them play promising to stay at the background, so if they both flaked I'd expect him to either replace out if he didn't intend to play from the beginning, or replace in with his own account if he did. Staying in the hydra where either of the noobs could come back and post anytime could really mess him up if he is Scum, and especially so if he's is fake claiming.

[TTTT]

I'm voting overkill or Egix today unless someone gives me really good reasons not to

I think Egix is at L-2 but not voting until I know fo sho

cards on the table I prefer this...

VOTE: overkill

[TTTT]

notes on overkill:

139 - overkill with lazy questioning that looks like scum trying to remain active. asking A50 why he was convinced to vote Shema, then A50 answers with a smilie and there's zero follow-up from overkill
222 - overkill kinda defends gamma and a50 from Persivul’s 206
352 - overkill - TERRIBLE vote on LOLwagon. was overkills first vote since RVS and overkill's entire reason is "Sure, I null read the orginal player but LoL is doing some strange tunnel and not explaining anything." opportunistic 5th vote on LOL that looks fabricated
384 - overkill - what the heck bro nobody is talking about you why are you asking to be meta’d??
689 - overkill says Gnelf is definitely town -- overkills says "I might not be exactly new, but im still not good either" back in 185 but that's inconsistent with this total lack of paranoia over a possible Gnelf fake-claim

as of this post the game has more TTTT content than overkill content (both in quantity and quality)

[TTTT]

1- Against my better judgement, I'm going to take Egix out of my scum pool and put him at the bottom of my Town pile. DO NOT ASK for an explicit explanation. You won't get one at this time. (If you want one, do your own homework)

has this been explained yet?

Not yet, but if you can't decipher it yourself then you don't need to take it into account.

OK, so does whatever made you move Egix from scum pile to town pile back on day1 still apply right now or have you moved past this? This is so important to me that I'm capitalizing and punctuating.

Attention A50 your presence is requested back at post 788

[Almost50]

1- Against my better judgement, I'm going to take Egix out of my scum pool and put him at the bottom of my Town pile. DO NOT ASK for an explicit explanation. You won't get one at this time. (If you want one, do your own homework)

has this been explained yet?

Not yet, but if you can't decipher it yourself then you don't need to take it into account.

OK, so does whatever made you move Egix from scum pile to town pile back on day1 still apply right now or have you moved past this? This is so important to me that I'm capitalizing and punctuating.

Attention A50 your presence is requested back at post 788

It's bloody ongoing you stupid nerd.

VOTE: TTTT

[Almost50]

:ole, I said back then not to talk about it, and I repeated it when you asked the first time. Are you trying to get me booted off the game??

[Almost50]

This guy (TTTT) is SCUM. First, he won't reveal anything about his reads even when I explained why I wanted him to do.

Then he starts a wagon on someone new. I dunno if he's distancing with a p in 0verki11 or trying to save a p in Egix (and I have them both at the bottom of my reads currently, along with TTTT himself).

Then he pretends not to understand what 11 other people got the first time and stopped talking about.

[PenguinPower]

I mean, I said Lovebird was scum...

VOTE: TTTT

[TTTT]

:ole, I said back then not to talk about it, and I repeated it when you asked the first time. Are you trying to get me booted off the game??

i can't read your mind and there are other reasons for changing reads that don't involve ongoing games and you brought it up so don't put that one me chucky.
it coulda been crumbs, softing, etc.

this is important bc you voted Egix at day2 start when Gnelf acted like there was a guilty but you didn't seem to have any hesitation about the vote
that stood out to me given your prior statement in 399

[TTTT]

This guy (TTTT) is SCUM. First, he won't reveal anything about his reads even when I explained why I wanted him to do.

you are liar
you wanted full reads after i already named a scumpool
you aren't the boss of me

Then he starts a wagon on someone new. I dunno if he's distancing with a p in 0verki11 or trying to save a p in Egix (and I have them both at the bottom of my reads currently, along with TTTT himself).

I'll lynch either one if it comes to it

Then he pretends not to understand what 11 other people got the first time and stopped talking about.

see last post

[PenguinPower]

UNVOTE:

I actually want to reserve my vote for now. Still think Lovebird slot is scum though.

[TTTT]

things I'm thinking about that others can help me with:

is a careless A50 AI? share meta if it's relevant cuz he keeps making careless mistakes

is anybody TRing Overkill or is he just skating by bc everybody was distracted by shiny objects? by shiny I mean RoS and Gnelf

Don't want this lost in the recent mess...

[Almost50]

you wanted full reads after i already named a scumpool

I don't want a bloody scum pool. ANYONE can come up with a 5-person list and say scum is in that pool. It's

how you reached that conclusion

that matters most to me.

[Almost50]

@TTTT: You said you can't read my mind. Why do you think I can read yours? Like, maybe you know something I don't, or maybe you faked a read list. How am I supposed to tell if I don't see how you got there and why you cleared X, Y & Z?

[TTTT]

you wanted full reads after i already named a scumpool

I don't want a bloody scum pool. ANYONE can come up with a 5-person list and say scum is in that pool. It's

how you reached that conclusion

that matters most to me.

@TTTT: You said you can't read my mind. Why do you think I can read yours? Like, maybe you know something I don't, or maybe you faked a read list. How am I supposed to tell if I don't see how you got there and why you cleared X, Y & Z?

1. I haven't cleared anybody
2. 804 is how I got to my current vote
3. if you have questions then ask them... but I'm not wall posting all my thoughts

[0verki11]

I'm here

Im here now. The reason i dont want to lynch Gnelf is that I cant see a new player are scum do that kind if Gambit.

1st why are you answering a question i never asked?
2nd Gnelf is a three-headed hydra so "new player" notsomuch
3rd i don't have a third just OCD so you have to have a 3rd

1 I quoted the wrong thing.
2 Two new players are in that hydra

[davesaz]

Votecount 2.2

Egix96(3)

~ Gnelf(41), Gamma Emerald(15), ReaperOfSouls(9)

TTTT(1)

~ Almost50(30)

ReaperOfSouls(1)

~ Dunnstral(26)

0verki11(1)

~ TTTT(27)


Not Voting (4): Egix96(14), Clemency(8), 0verki11(7), PenguinPower(34)

With 10 alive it takes 6 to lynch.

Day 2 deadline is in (expired on 2018-12-21 20:59:53)

[Egix96]

VOTE: Reaper
I don't think it makes sense for maf!Dunn to vote town!me and then immediately switch.
Aorn ROS is my main suspect but I'm fine with lynching A50 or T4 instead.

[Clemency]

VOTE: TTTT
i agree with a50's points

[TTTT]

i think we find scum here:
Egix
Clem
Overkill
RoS
A50
(in no particular order)

least confident about A50 and Clem

<<SNIP>>
VOTE: TTTT

<<SNIP>>
Aorn ROS is my main suspect but I'm fine with lynching A50 or T4 instead.

<<SNIP>>
VOTE: TTTT

[TTTT]

At this point I really just want to hear Dunn, Gamma, and Gnelf's take on Overkill

[TTTT]

A50 is just manufacturing shit. There is no real intent to sort my slot it's just dump your reads and you're scum if you don't

which is stupid AF and exactly what scum would want an experienced player who is replacing into a game to do -- dump all their thoughts so they'll know how to play them

A50 has done only 2 things day2:
1) setup spec that as far as I can tell has been useless
2) annoy me with demands to posts all my reads, without even asking me a

single

question about what I've already posted
^this is literally true do check his ISO

I posted a rather large scumpool early on that includes A50. one would think there might be some follow-up to do with the replacement player on that. But no. A50 demands all my reads and my thoughts behind them. that's scummy as hell.

I posted my notes on overkill after I voted. One would think there might be questions about that post. But no. A50 acts like it never happened, tries to manufacture drama over 788 (which he still hasn't answered even though he could without breaking rules about ongoing games), and votes me. that's scummy as hell.

[Dunnstral]

At this point I really just want to hear Dunn, Gamma, and Gnelf's take on Overkill

He seems towny to me, though voting lolwagons was bad