In post 2294, Cheeky Dancer wrote: In post 2286, mcqueen wrote: In post 2278, Cheeky Dancer wrote:So mcqueen I don't think Profii is scum. He just seems disengaged at this point, like the majority of players. I'm not sure I get why you're so confident there?
~ C
It’s the best case i have rn other than TLK.
Here’s a small list of other players that are scumread/wanted for lynch, that i DONT
- ram
- CD (you)
- efn
- rce
- eng
Either profii, or I’m up for a PL on AC. Didn’t like how they said they wouldnt disclose reads and feel that’s a huge liability to town
So people believe the TLK claim to be town? AC holding info close to their chest D1 isn't worrying ime. (Well it is for Chara but not A50). I think I'd rather keep them incase they are town because they're a great team when more info comes up.
EFN sounds fine tonally but is just lurking like most people who dont need to wade through the rubbish. ENG is pretty typical for Ari/Peng to be useless so I wouldn't scumread either of these yet either.
I will have to relook at ram but what I've caught seems fine. What are your thoughts on RCE?
I think the Super Saint claim is more likely to be town, yes. However, TLK was scumread early on, and I just don't want to gamble with a potential scum SS in the game. As I said earlier, the longer the SS is alive, the more unkillable he becomes. No one will want to lynch a SS later on for fear of being killed, and the same goes for nightkilling him. So it's best to get rid of a scummy player claimed SS now while we have the chance.
That doesn't mean I've, or anyone else, has voted him since his claim. No one wants to die (well, except maybe Ram, lol). See what I'm saying? That could be why I'm skeptical of such a claim to begin with; it almost makes him immortal.
I townread RCE earlier. Didn't find much issue with him while everyone else did during his interaction with BEF. He's [RCE] lurking a bit recently, but he's definitely not someone I'm going after atm.
What about you? RCE reads?