Mini Normal 2052: Mixtape Mafia [Game Over]

[Elbirn]

VC 1.01

The Breathing Effect - Mars Is A Very Bad Place For Love

votes

[3] Clemency

:

EGL, Jenga, Clemency

[2] Trekkie99

:

ofrhz, texcat

[1] ofrhz

:

Munchmellow

[1] Vorkuta

:

PvtUrist

[6] Not Voting

:

Trekkie99, Vorkuta, 0verki11, Springtrap, ZombieStriker, singletonking

With 13 alive, it takes 7 to lynch

The Day 1 deadline is in

: (expired on 2019-01-14 13:00:00)

Mod Notes

[EGL]

@board is there any chance of a scum being neighbors with a townie or no?

[ofrhz]

@board is there any chance of a scum being neighbors with a townie or no?

Yes, they can be S+T, but they can also be T+T. I don't think they can be S+S though, or at least, I've never seen a hood with only scum in singleball.

https://wiki.mafiascum.net/index.php?title=Neighbor

[EGL]

UNVOTE:

[ofrhz]

Did you guys discuss and agree to out your neighborhood together?

No, no discussion.

What was your initial reaction in seeing 10?

[EGL]

@board is there any chance of a scum being neighbors with a townie or no?

Yes, they can be S+T, but they can also be T+T. I don't think they can be S+S though, or at least, I've never seen a hood with only scum in singleball.

https://wiki.mafiascum.net/index.php?title=Neighbor

I mean yeah that sounds like it would be just a normal scum team. Scum + scum neighborhood I mean.

[Vorkuta]

VOTE: PvtUrist
are you scum this game?

[Vorkuta]

Out of curiosity- does town require proof that they're actually neighbors? Or do we take that at face value?
Idk- getting both of them to post some random copypasta at exactly HH:MM:SS to confirm that they have access to neighbor-exclusive chat?

[EGL]

I don't know. Whether or not they're town is one thing, but why should we believe they randomly fake claimed about being able to talk to one another?

[EGL]

Although it would be fun to see them prove it.

[Vorkuta]

Wishful thinking: if they can't prove it, then we have 2 liars in our town and the game is more or less solved

[Munchmellow]

Did you guys discuss and agree to out your neighborhood together?

No, no discussion.

What was your initial reaction in seeing 10?

I was really surprised. I guess there is logic behind it and overkill will explain it.

Out of curiosity- does town require proof that they're actually neighbors? Or do we take that at face value?
Idk- getting both of them to post some random copypasta at exactly HH:MM:SS to confirm that they have access to neighbor-exclusive chat?

Are you suggesting we should copy paste sth from our private thread, because that would be clearly against the rules.
I mean, the only reason to think we are both lying about it is, if we would both be scum. In that case we would have private thread anyway even if we copy paste sth that wouldn't prove anything.

[PvtUrist]

Are you suggesting we should copy paste sth from our private thread, because that would be clearly against the rules.

Overly defensive. Not the best first impression here, Munch.

[Munchmellow]

Are you suggesting we should copy paste sth from our private thread, because that would be clearly against the rules.

Overly defensive. Not the best first impression here, Munch.

Oh, hi, PvtUrist. Of course you would think I'm overly defensive. I see you changed your avatar pic. I kind of liked last one better.
You don't find it odd for someone to suggest you break rules? The "are you suggesting" part actually gives him benefit of the doubt, that I misunderstood sth.
And again, why would I be defensive about it? The only reason that I would be defensive about it is, if I would be lying. And lying about neighborhood would only make sense if we would be S+S. But I don't see what a scum pair would gain from claiming neghborhood, since you don't neceserilly have to have T+T.

I am ready to prove it when we agree on acceptable way. But I don't know what good that will do, it will still not be clear if we are T+T or T+S or just S+S lying about neighborhood.

[Vorkuta]

we should copy paste sth from our private thread

No no, nothing of the sort.
Instead- USE the neighbor chat to coordinate something (idk- post like the same random 20 digit number, the first/last half of a random sentence/quote, left/right half of an image...) that can't otherwise be done using town/general chat.

or just S+S lying about neighborhood.

Yes- it would solve that issue (again- wishful thinking- if only mafia were that easy ), but it would ALSO guarantee at least one town between the two of you.

and it'll be hilarious

[Munchmellow]

No no, nothing of the sort.
Instead- USE the neighbor chat to coordinate something (idk- post like the same random 20 digit number, the first/last half of a random sentence/quote, left/right half of an image...) that can't otherwise be done using town/general chat.

Ok, that makes sense, I'm up for that if overkill agrees.

[EGL]

How does it prove at least one town between them?

[Munchmellow]

It actually just proves that we have a private thread.

[EGL]

Sorry I should have @ed vorkuta.

[singletonking]

A neighborhood? Do they have day and nightchat or is it just during the day?

VOTE: Springtrap
I don't like that he opened with a question regarding whatever's been discussed, rather than coming up with his own content.

I also dislike PvtUrist for calling Munch overdefensive.

[singletonking]

I don't think neighbours can be S/S, but they can very well be T/T or S/T.

I also definitely think they're true claiming about the neighbourhood, fakeclaiming it is just silly as it's confirmable. As such, I find the whole "post at the same time" thing completely pointless. Also, I think that asking them to copy something out of the thread would be rulebreaking.

[singletonking]

I think I slightly like Vortuka for suggesting the idea, though.

[PvtUrist]

Well singleton, is there anything here you

do

like?

I don't think neighbours can be S/S, but they can very well be T/T or S/T.

I also definitely think they're true claiming about the neighbourhood, fakeclaiming it is just silly as it's confirmable. As such, I find the whole "post at the same time" thing completely pointless. Also, I think that asking them to copy something out of the thread would be rulebreaking.

I get that, I just don't know where the idea of "copying PMs/out of thread info" came from.

ninja'd

[PvtUrist]

I also dislike PvtUrist for calling Munch overdefensive.

hmm, care to explain why? I'm interested in your reasoning on this.

[singletonking]

I also dislike PvtUrist for calling Munch overdefensive.

hmm, care to explain why? I'm interested in your reasoning on this.

Because I disagree that Munch was being overdefensive, and I felt that you were stretching.

Why do you think Munch was overdefensive?