Large Normal 217 (Game Over)

[Gamma Emerald]

Lynch not_mafia

[joges]

I'm happy with my vote.

[Rob14]

Vote Count #5.4:

Not_Mafia:

joges, Gamma Emerald (2)

Gamma Emerald:

Not_Mafia, stan1ey (2)

Almost50:

Persivul (1)

Persivul:

Almost50 (1)

Not Voting:

None.

With 6 players alive, it takes 4 to lynch.

V/LA:

None.

Deadline:

(expired on 2019-01-10 00:15:00)

[Not_Mafia]

Lynch Gamma, it's obvious

[Almost50]

I'm happy with my vote.

And I'm not changing mine.

[joges]

I can't leave Not Mafia, his mislynch is tooooooo easy at this point if he is town. What case could you even begin to make that he is town and shouldn't be lynched?

[joges]

If he was town, there wouldn't be an issue at all right now to see that wagon finished. But it's not going anywhere. Not_Mafia is scum with either A50 or Persivul.

[Almost50]

If he was town, there wouldn't be an issue at all right now to see that wagon finished. But it's not going anywhere. Not_Mafia is scum with either A50 or Persivul.

Then why not lynch Percy?

I do not vote N_M

, and is certainly not the last of his kind, if he is scum at all.

[Almost50]

N_M -to me- is a 50-50 shot. However, Percy is +90% scum. It both are scum it doesn't matter which of them we lynch first, and if only Percy is scum we are throwing the game.

[Almost50]

I would rather lose to N_M than mislynch N_M. I probably won't be alive tomorrow so you can do that without me anyway.

[Gamma Emerald]

If he was town, there wouldn't be an issue at all right now to see that wagon finished. But it's not going anywhere. Not_Mafia is scum with either A50 or Persivul.

Then why not lynch Percy? I do not vote N_M, and

is certainly not the last of his kind

, if he is scum at all.

Pardon? Why would you need to specify this?

[stan1ey]

Any other explanations for Joges and clem night 2?

[Persivul]

I can't leave Not Mafia,

I'd rather lynch A50 today. His play has been actively scummy, whereas NM has been his typical useless self. But apparently that's not going to happen.

VOTE: Not Mafia

[stan1ey]

Can we not lynch anyone until we have decided what we think happened night 2

[Persivul]

Can we not lynch anyone until we have decided what we think happened night 2

How are we going to do that? It's just speculation as not everyone is being truthful with their claim.

[stan1ey]

Surely there is only a limited amount of scenarios which make 2 peoples night actions fail

[Not_Mafia]

I told you guys to lynch Persivul

[Persivul]

Surely there is only a limited amount of scenarios which make 2 peoples night actions fail

Feel free to run them out yourself.

When joges set up the 1v1, I noted that since (if his claim is true) town had a full tracker and an investigative JOAT, it's not implausible that scum have a RB and a JOAT with a similar function. I just don't see that talking about it more is going to help solve the game at this point. It's not like we're in an open or semi-open and can figure it all out.

[Almost50]

If he was town, there wouldn't be an issue at all right now to see that wagon finished. But it's not going anywhere. Not_Mafia is scum with either A50 or Persivul.

Then why not lynch Percy? I do not vote N_M, and

is certainly not the last of his kind

, if he is scum at all.

Pardon? Why would you need to specify this?

Because we obviously didn't start the game with 2 scums. It's a 14 players game, so 3 or 4 scums.

[Gamma Emerald]

Yeah but everybody knows that

[Almost50]

^^Btw, would yo9u consider this to be within the range of your "scum tell behaviour"?

[Almost50]

Yeah but everybody knows that

So? I'm arguing against his lybch, so making this obvious serves my case/argument

[Gamma Emerald]

^^Btw, would yo9u consider this to be within the range of your "scum tell behaviour"?

What specifically?

[Almost50]

The "why specify this" post. This feels like nitpicking on nothing. Busy work. Posturing. Fluff. Call it what you want.

[joges]

So N_M has 3 votes and no one has hammered. So either he is scum, or both scum are on his wagon currently. Fair?