Trying to start to collect my thoghts
Stronger townreads
Mcqueen -- curious about the scattered scumreads of this slot, because through thought process and effort he's seemed pretty town to me
Alonzo -- wasn't sure about this slot most of d1 but I think the timing of his pressure on EFN was very likely town-indicative
RCEnigma -- thought process/effort seems very town
Weaker townreads
Nero Cain -- Nancy seems adamant on this and I'm going with her read for now
Kokichi -- I've played with Kokichi enough times now to know that he doesn't read me very well and doesn't understand why I read him the way I do, and that makes me think the activity tells I've been using for him might still be decent.
BrightEyedFish -- While I find his reaction to my win of the boonus a bit annoying I think it's probably T.I.
Something_Smart -- Looked at another scum game for this slot and think he plays more "normal" as scum
Gamma Emerald -- misread Gamma several times before but still feeling fine for him as town for now
Davesaz -- liked
2715 Nulls
Karmeleon -- I was liking Karmy enough to dance with him yesterday but his activity tanking toward the end of yesterday and start of today makes me less certain on his towniness. That being said we're still coming off the holidays so we'll see what happens when he comes back properly. Maybe I should keep him as townlean for now but I kinda need to see his thought process post-flips more.
Profii -- wasn't liking this slot most of yesterday and trying to understand why he claimed inventor today. The claim could be TI but I don't know that the way he did it is TI
The Last Knight -- I don't know he's town based on the claim but I also wasn't strongly scumreading him before that so idk, not a big fan of his reads but not sure that they're "scummy" and not just "wrong" quite yet
Elsa Jay -- At some point I need to figure out what is actually town indicative for Elsa but I haven't yet. Thinking about his annoyance at the Boonus round talk. Maybe that could be? I'll think about it
Xtoxm -- I know his reads as town can be good sometimes, so I'd like to hear more about the reasoning in his reads in
2761. I think it's important to explore the strength of townreads and if I'm wrong on one of mcqueen or ss I'd like to know why.
Scum side of null
Emperors New Groove (PenguinPower/Aristophanes) -- I liked Ari's
2070 but the rest of this does not look like it's outside Penguin's scumrange and Ari hasn't really kept up the analysis
Theta Alpine -- This is basically below null just due to LAL; the content doesn't give me a read outside of "no signs of town yet"
"Hmmm" category
Cheeky Dancer (CheekyTeeky/Performer) -- I liked the vote on Flippy. I also find it weird that Cheeky wants to townread people on the TLK wagon, when TLK's alignment is unknown, but hasn't really re-evaluated our slot based on the FlippyNips vote. idk, Performer should remember that even if he can't sort my scum range, that Shoshin's solution is to townread me based on whether town is winning--and town is winning right now. Still it's kinda hard to tell what's going on with this slot given Performer is kinda not here rn
"Hmmmmmm" category
Thanos (Lamees/Auro) -- kinda losing interest in whether lamees is tunneling or scum and while I saw a few whiffs of town Auro in our 1v1 d1 I still wouldn't say this slot reeks of towniness
Nev and Max -- I've been liking this slot for town d1 but flipping his read of us because... Nancy admitted she was commenting on stuff people was saying before really processing the flip? idk I know he admitted it's still early day but given Thanos and Cheeky were coming at us at the time I'm kinda like that's a bit scummy gents. He's entitled to take his time in sorting us but that seemed like an odd thing as being indicative of a scum agenda
"Hmmmmmmmmmmmm" category
Ramcius -- BEF actually has a kinda decent point about the winners of the boonus being day reps and that means Ram, regardless of alignment, was probably a scum nomination. That does not in and of itself make him lockscum. However, what I dislike a lot more than the setup spec stuff is the reaction from
2909 to
2915. IDK maybe he's just still stressed out from the pressure on d1 but that seemed like a strangely melodramatic reaction to BEF's post.
I'm putting our vote on Ram for the moment but I haven't had a chance to really talk with Nancy at length in a few days and it tends to help me a lot talking with her about my list.
-D