Booneytoonz IX - Under The Sea -- Game Over!

[Chara]

I feel like you were hinting at thinking I was scum before in the thread or at least said you'd vote me. The way you posted your mini case on me I was reading in a way that had a lot of confidence in it. So it didn't feel like you were second guessing anything at all.

ok, i guess i can see where you're coming from.
there isn't a lot of time left and i'm not scumreading Nikk. his response to your case especially doesn't feel like how i would expect scum trying to mislynch you (with you as the largest wagon and Nikk as the next popular option) to act.
and i did read your case.

about Wisdom: what was bad about his response to pressure? insulting the players scumreading him seems in character to me, but it sounds like you have more experience.

[Chara]

Chara is a nice lad, and Creature seems nice as well.

Total rating: nice/10.

i think you're nice too!

[Kaito Momota]

Chara coming in here and hard defending anyone who votes/susses me is really obvious by the way

Either scum motivated or extreme bias - or both

[Elsa Jay]

This is the part where I come in and point out how the above interaction makes Chara look worse, since if Elsa Jay is scum she isn't in a position to bus

And then you guys can do the same for me

Hey, you asked my opinion on Creature and Chara. I confirm I think they are nice people. How is that helpful to the game?

[Nikk]

Frustration does not suite you well.

[Nikk]

Also am I allowed to ask random questions like that as well? Maybe to fish for something to push on? Just 3 random names?

Nikk, Firebringer, Clemency


What are your thoughts on each other?

Firebringer has a low post count but seems to have some content when they post.
Clem has a high post count and sometimes has content when he posts.

Both are null atm because neither of those are AI

[Nikk]

This is the part where I come in and point out how the above interaction makes Chara look worse, since if Elsa Jay is scum she isn't in a position to bus

And then you guys can do the same for me

Hey, you asked my opinion on Creature and Chara. I confirm I think they are nice people. How is that helpful to the game?

I laughed. You finally got me.

[Elsa Jay]

The Elsa wincon grows closer, I can feel it.

Seriously though, I have no idea which way I want to go with this lynch. I'll abstain for now.

[Nikk]

I've given a read on both and I stand by those reads

Last post for tonight.

I've been through your ISO twice. You have not given a read on Dave. So what exactly are you standing by here? Please quote the exact post where you gave a read on Dave.

[Elsa Jay]

We got 1 day left to decide this all. No-Lynch IS an unfavorable option, but it's there.

Hopefully Gamma has a VC for us ready. Oh, and happy birthday Gamma.

[Kaito Momota]

first miller claimers are nearly always town. the later the claim happened the less credible it is since mafia will jump in when they see a lot of millers claiming

Disagree at the point you said this, I don't think the 2 players after th first 2 (sircakez and ladyangel) would fakeclaim miller there as scum

Chara claiming miller is suspect, especially since at this point claiming miller is akin to outting town power roles

I mixed up davesaz and sircakez and nobody called me out on it

Not really looking over my iso, just looking for something to push me on?

[Kaito Momota]

Maybe go through it a third time

[Kaito Momota]

We're going to end up no lynching at this rate, I think, I don't know the vc

[Lady Angel]

VOTE: Nikk

I think this feels best right now.

[Wisdom]

Hey Wisdom, please answer this honestly: how sure are you that Maki is scum?

pretty sure

[Wisdom]

Wisdom, Frozen Angel, Alchemist21


What are your thoughts on each other?

town and nulltown

[Maki Harukawa]

about Wisdom: what was bad about his response to pressure? insulting the players scumreading him seems in character to me, but it sounds like you have more experience.

It's the

only

thing he's doing. Any defense is just insults and 'you can't read me' it's just blah overall. Also he can only say he's sure I'm scum because hint: He has no real reasons.

[Wisdom]

ill sound like a broken record but this is bs from someone who knows me

[Maki Harukawa]

I'm flattered that you think I should know you yet you preach at the same time you act like town/scum all the time as either.

[Wisdom]

youve seen me withholding reasons a zillion times
arguing i dont actually have reasons cannot possibly be sincere

[Wisdom]

can we change that final word to "lynched"

rereading and i realized i mixed up games here

this was not me fluffing

[Chara]

Maki, i've decided to townread Kaito being unhelpful and snarky because he's seemed more logical and careful as scum in a few games, and "rougher" as town.
would you consider that an okay metric or a terrible one? i was going to vote him again due to being fed up but it doesn't feel right anymore thanks to that. +1 for pushing me more aggressively. relatively speaking.

Wisdom, no scumreads besides Maki? i'm just assuming no because you didn't answer, but what the hell i'll ask again.

Maki's whole line about mislynching her over and over again until i get it right hit me pretty hard, but she's still my preferred lynch out of what's currently on the table. it's true i've townread her as scum but what's more notable to me is i townread her when she's town also, and the mislynches were due to paranoia.
i could compromise on Nikk too. i don't believe there's enough time to be picky now, and i don't have any confident scumreads.

[Maki Harukawa]

youve seen me withholding reasons a zillion times
arguing i dont actually have reasons cannot possibly be sincere

You're right I've seen both. I wouldn't push you if that was the only factor

[Maki Harukawa]

Maki, i've decided to townread Kaito being unhelpful and snarky because he's seemed more logical and careful as scum in a few games, and "rougher" as town.
would you consider that an okay metric or a terrible one?

Terrible he did the exact same thing in a scum game a bit ago it's not something you should tr him based off of

[Chara]

don't feel like pursuing this today but now that i look, Elsa is playing survivalistically out in the open again (he was hunting for a bit but doesn't seem to have continued) and i choose to believe it's something scum Elsa would do with no proof whatsoever. no proof but my soul.
i'll keep it in mind either way.

pedit: mind linking the game?