Kind of feels strange that us 3 are getting shoved into a room that none of us asked for, without any logic behind it beyond "everybody should be in a room"
How bout each of you get first dibs on the second batch of rooms this day phase, then? Who would you most want to be in a room with out of everybody here, Dunn?
The rooms are a tool. We should use all the tools we have available to us.
In post 23, tris wrote:Mostly to make a wagon. I also was interested in your assigning scum points to Flavor Leaf's post. I doesn't seem scummy to me, so I was interested in knowing why you thought so. Of course, the more direct way to do that would be to ask you, but I felt like putting a naked vote to make a wagon instead and see what happens.
Don't you find Flavor's post to be self-conscious? Scum start the game thinking about themselves. Town start the game thinking about everyone else.
In post 41, Dunnstral wrote:Kind of feels strange that us 3 are getting shoved into a room that none of us asked for, without any logic behind it beyond "everybody should be in a room"
In post 16, Plotinus wrote:Since the rooms stay open for the whole game, it is optimal to create as many as possible.
Why is that optimal?
I've modded a bunch of games with this mechanic. It's optimal for town to have places to work together out of scum's eyes, and you can scumhunt people in private differently from you can scumhunt them in public.
With 4 rooms and everyone in a room, at least two of them and possibly 3 of them will be masonries. If the people in the masonries can figure out that they are in a masonry, synergy will ensue.
I'm not strongly against the room, it's just weird that we took this sudden change in approach. The previous rooms had people asking for them
I'd rather that people asked to be part of rooms, rather than assigning them for them. Also, do you not think that scum can pocket people inside of rooms?
I've played with your mechanic before (a long time ago) For the most part it worked out, but there was always a bit of paranoia, and people only got rooms with people they wanted to