Booneytoonz IX - Under The Sea -- Game Over!

[Kaito Momota]

Doesn't look like town elsa to me

[Kaito Momota]

I'd vote Firebringer today

[Kaito Momota]

Actually maybe not

[Pink Ball]

Pink is probably town, sucks that he has to be dragged past the finish line by his feet if we ever want to win though

Thank you for carrying me <3

[Maki Harukawa]

You're smart enough to put 2 and 2 together that 1) If I was scum I wouldn't make a fake claim that means I can't make endgame
2) My role makes perfect sense for why we have so many millers in the first place
3) You've never gave any reasoning for why I'm scum besides me pushing you today. (Something you always do) You called me nullscum and said it's because I don't comment on your stuff. Strange you also stated in other games that scum me comments on all your stuff.

1) Sure you would, you had suspicion on you and you advance the scum wincon greatly in the process
2) That's why you could have fake claimed it
3) Untrue, I was calling you scum day 1

These answers are all you need to see why Kaito is scum btw. Instead of considering them he just gives convenient answers not even good ones either. His third answer is a blatant lie you can see that in his iso. His second answer is wifom because he has no other answer for why we have 5 miller claims. the first is just false and he knows it. He's just acting like he doesn't

[Maki Harukawa]

Anyway I'ma go read hopefully this thread is locked by the time I come back

[Elsa Jay]

the above has to do with my inability to read Elsa. he's just batshit and he likes it that way. maybe i should put in more effort since he's actually hunting today?

The school of Elsa is open to all who approach for lessons.

[Kaito Momota]

You're smart enough to put 2 and 2 together that 1) If I was scum I wouldn't make a fake claim that means I can't make endgame
2) My role makes perfect sense for why we have so many millers in the first place
3) You've never gave any reasoning for why I'm scum besides me pushing you today. (Something you always do) You called me nullscum and said it's because I don't comment on your stuff. Strange you also stated in other games that scum me comments on all your stuff.

1) Sure you would, you had suspicion on you and you advance the scum wincon greatly in the process
2) That's why you could have fake claimed it
3) Untrue, I was calling you scum day 1

These answers are all you need to see why Kaito is scum btw. Instead of considering them he just gives convenient answers not even good ones either. His third answer is a blatant lie you can see that in his iso. His second answer is wifom because he has no other answer for why we have 5 miller claims. the first is just false and he knows it. He's just acting like he doesn't

OK, let's go over these.

You say the first is a blatant lie. How? I say that you claimed as soon as you got into thread so you could later say "oh I had no reason to claim". Which, if you were town, you didn't. Why did you claim if you didn't think you were going to be pressured today? Did my push matter that much to you?

The second one is easy to explain. There's another role that interacts with the millers. They haven't claimed, either because they don't want to or they haven't read the thread yet.

Third one, you say it's a blatant lie, and that you can see it in my iso. Well, ok, so "Untrue, I was calling you scum day 1" is a blatant lie that you can see in my iso? Let's look at my iso:

Going to copy his list and replace the reads with my own:

Maki Harukawa - nullscums.

Maki looks like scum to me and the fact that she didn't comment on anything I did (I even called her nulscum) seems telling

I don't really believe clementine's claim and would be willing to lynch him today. Make him claim tomorrow and push that again. Then lynch him anyway. He's going to claim something you won't want to lynch - that's because he's scum

Nikk looks like town

Let's get maki or clem

Full on Maki is scum, I'll vote her if we're not doign CLem. But it looks like we can still do Clem. Can we?

Can we vote maki?

Regardless, if town has killing power I'd like to see it aimed at maki harukawa tonight

Wait, that sure is a lot of me calling you scum yesterday... actually, have you even read my iso? Why are you pushing on me? Chara? Hello???? ????

[Kaito Momota]

This is all because Maki called out the possibility of the Millers not being trustworthy. Which, frankly, I'd probably have done later considering I went for Alch the moment he claimed second Miller.

As for a Kaito lynch?... Guess we gotta look into it.

And if you dance around voting me for too long, you may draw Alchemist21's ire

Alchemist21 was killed in the night!

Spoiler: What was he?

Town Miller

Day 2 begins with a deadline of (expired on 2019-01-31 19:15:00).

[Kaito Momota]

Maki just demonstrated that she hasn't been paying attention to my iso at all actually

This isn't town maki looking to lynch scum me. This isn't how she plays

[Elsa Jay]

This is all because Maki called out the possibility of the Millers not being trustworthy. Which, frankly, I'd probably have done later considering I went for Alch the moment he claimed second Miller.

As for a Kaito lynch?... Guess we gotta look into it.

And if you dance around voting me for too long, you may draw Alchemist21's ire

Alchemist21 was killed in the night!

Spoiler: What was he?

Town Miller

Day 2 begins with a deadline of (expired on 2019-01-31 19:15:00).

Those are not my drugs, your honor.

Circumstantial/planted evidence gets us nowhere but dead, Mr. Momota.

[sheepsaysmeep]

what the fuck happened

[Elsa Jay]

Kaito scumclaimed. Vote first, read second, ask questions third.

[Lady Angel]

what the fuck happened

[Maki Harukawa]

Congrats on quoting 5 posts where you called me nullscum after 1100 posts? You'd have brought me up much sooner. Let's talk about your progression on me:
You vote me unvote me then say get someone else and then we get to...null scum? You said get me but you gave 1 single reason. So no you didn't call me scum on d1 because if you really thought I was scum you wouldn't have made only 4 posts about me.

[Maki Harukawa]

Also Kaito don't act like you know how I play given you've read me wrong over and over. You don't get the right to say you know how I play.
You want to know why I claimed? Because I know I'd get pushed today and knowing my role clears me I claimed to get the topic of conversation away from me before it could happen.

[Kaito Momota]

Congrats on quoting 5 posts where you called me nullscum after 1100 posts? You'd have brought me up much sooner. Let's talk about your progression on me:

None of that changes the fact that you saying it was a blatant lie was in itself a blatant lie

[Lady Angel]

Kaito seems to be in a 1v1 with Maki/Clem and lynching him is probably the best thing at the minute. I'm hesitant to vote and put him to L-1 now given how fast the day's going, but should Kaito flip town one of Maki and Clem is probably scum?

I believe Maki's claim as well, although more due to it making sense with the number of miller claims than the fact that scum wouldn't claim a role that wouldn't get her to endgame. I'm not sure if I believe Clem's, however, but given the level of emotion going through Clem this day I'm inclined just to leave it alone.

[Kaito Momota]

You want to know why I claimed? Because I know I'd get pushed today

ok.............. That's what I've been saying

[Kaito Momota]

And I believe you were saying the contrary earlier

That or someone was against that idea

[Kaito Momota]

Kaito seems to be in a 1v1 with Maki/Clem and lynching him is probably the best thing at the minute. I'm hesitant to vote and put him to L-1 now given how fast the day's going, but should Kaito flip town one of Maki and Clem is probably scum?

I believe Maki's claim as well, although more due to it making sense with the number of miller claims than the fact that scum wouldn't claim a role that wouldn't get her to endgame. I'm not sure if I believe Clem's, however, but given the level of emotion going through Clem this day I'm inclined just to leave it alone.

If I die get Maki then Clem in that order

Clem is 50/50 still, not sure if upset town or scum - the thing about 50/50's is we take those though

[Kaito Momota]

We should have Maki hide behind Clem, and if she's still alive we lynch her

[Elsa Jay]

... But if Maki hides behind someone we know about, then scum immediately can kill her AND Clem.

You just suggested we kill 2 PRs in one fell swoop.

[Kaito Momota]

Reread how her claiemd role works

[Kaito Momota]

... But if Maki hides behind someone we know about, then scum immediately can kill her AND Clem.

You just suggested we kill 2 PRs in one fell swoop.

None of what you're describing here is possible