Open 745: 9:12 [Game Over]

[CultOfAthena]

I'm not exactly sure why I'm seen as SA's number one partner or even a likely partner of his at all, but whatever. I mean, I think I remember reading that it's because I didn't vote him after Slaxx's claim, but I would have been immediately hammering him had I done that.

Cuz there's only 3 people scum could be and i townread the other 2 more.

Also my vote on SA was the third (ie right after slaxx's claim and right afrer you said you didnt cc)

Yeah.. so like I said. I would have been hammering when I made 740.

If you expected me to

immediately

be like "oh well guess Slaxx is conftown and i'll just head down the list then"... I'm not sure why you would expect that.

Also, goes to show how much just being around and being present is a factor in not getting lynched. It aligned with actually being scum in the case of SA—not that that was why he was lynched—but not so much here.

This is explicitly not an acticity based read

I'm not saying it is. I'm saying that people who are active tend to just by osmosis tend to be more townread while people who disappear for a while tend to, even without

that much

reasoning behind it, get more scumread.

It's just something I've noticed spectating games recently.

[kitcat]

Yeah i thought u might've; rooroo too, and pinkball too, which is why it was getting silly. you townreading me threw me off tho?

Historically Town!you can't read me, scum!you gives me a townread.

(If youre who i'm thinking of obvs)

No idea why you don't nk me? But that happens a lot in a holistic sense so i don't give too much credence to me not being nk'd anymore really

[kitcat]

If you think I would do the classic newbie scum "scumread your partner but say there are better lynch options" and do it in a way like I did it then just lol

Well, its more the lack of voting him at any point

[kitcat]

If you think Eragon deserves to be townread for his Gamma Emerald catchups and posting animal pictures or gifs or whatever... lol.

Yeah his catchup was townie

His associatices with SA were meh

But just being so *accepting* of the necessity of his lynch today is incredibly townie too

What do you think of vizzie

[CultOfAthena]

You know the funny thing? The duck thought the same thing recently regarding "historically can't townread" and such when it came to an early read — as if I can't learn from recent games, especially given that you're both thinking of basically the first game together after coming back from a break. It was wrong then, it's wrong now.

No idea why you don't nk me? But that happens a lot in a holistic sense so i don't give too much credence to me not being nk'd anymore really

Be honest with yourself. This is cop-out reasoning.

[CultOfAthena]

If you think I would do the classic newbie scum "scumread your partner but say there are better lynch options" and do it in a way like I did it then just lol

Well, its more the lack of voting him at any point

I outlined my reasoning fairly clearly. What does not voting him have to do with anything when that would literally have gone exactly against what I was thinking?

If you think Eragon deserves to be townread for his Gamma Emerald catchups and posting animal pictures or gifs or whatever... lol.

Yeah his catchup was townie

You really shouldn't think so.

His associatices with SA were meh

But just being so *accepting* of the necessity of his lynch today is incredibly townie too

Not really.

What do you think of vizzie

I sincerely doubt he's scum, and I've thought so for a while.

[kitcat]

Uh think of thr last game i played with scum!you. When did i die again?

P-edit bleh you got me on mobile

[kitcat]

Ok, why isnt eragon's catchup townie; and why should i not townread him accepting his lynch?

[kitcat]

Uh think of thr last game i played with scum!you. When did i die again?

P-edit bleh you got me on mobile

Obvs i'm not expecting you to answer this here

[CultOfAthena]

Well, I'll qualify that. I think in

most

situations I would townread someone directly suggesting that they be lynched in order to solve the game further. I have encountered situations where it's come from scum, but for the most part I think it comes from town.

Someone accepting "if my death is what it takes then so be it" or whatever as just sort of an acceptance of themselves as being scumread, however, I would

not

townread – in fact, I would say that it's a common move for scum in this kind of situation.

[Slaxx]

I'm fairly sauced at this point

I know that doesn't help

But everyone is townreading vizzy so lets pull off the bandaid brand bandaid and just do our lynch

If he's scum we can nominate him for a scummy or w.e he has everyone including the actual mafia fooled apparently

[skitter30]

I don't understand the distinction you're drawing, or why eragon embodies the lattter

[kitcat]

I don't understand the distinction you're drawing, or why eragon embodies the lattter

[CultOfAthena]

Uh think of thr last game i played with scum!you. When did i die again?

P-edit bleh you got me on mobile

You died the first opportunity after a Mason and conftown. That's when you died.

Consider that this game is happening after that game, when I know for a fact that you'd be averse to the same thing happening twice (which is obvious from what's going on now, but I digress).

[kitcat]

I mean yeah. There's fwo lynches for three people and nobody thinks vizzy is scum so yeah i think it's basically auto

[Slaxx]

I don't think whatever this conversation is matters but maybe I lack context

[CultOfAthena]

I don't understand the distinction you're drawing, or why eragon embodies the lattter

There are situations where people directly suggest their own lynch. In my experience this has come from town more often than scum.

There are situations where people accept "my lynch doesn't matter because I think we win anyways". Not only do I do not think this comes from town any more than it comes from scum, I think in some situations this is scum's

only

option.

[CultOfAthena]

Uh think of thr last game i played with scum!you. When did i die again?

P-edit bleh you got me on mobile

You died the first opportunity after a Mason and conftown. That's when you died.

Consider that this game is happening after that game, when I know for a fact that you'd be averse to the same thing happening twice (which is obvious from what's going on now, but I digress).

Also, let's flip this on its head: why do I kill PB?

[Slaxx]

I swear on my right lung and left private part that no matter what I follow the protocol of lynching Eragon tomorrow no matter what

chibi is across the pond and I bet she's on, lets get that flip

MOVE THAT BUS

[Slaxx]

@slaxx using your same metric:

Inv->Slaxx->Eragon-> /// kitcat->CoA->rooroo /// SA

Why do you have rooroo so up?

p-edit you already answered. I really think I can get a better read on rooroo on D2, but the way she's playing pings me. She could argue it's because of being an alt, but some things never change

[CultOfAthena]

Whatever. It actually fucking makes me mad that this guy gets away with his terrible associatives being called meh, and I make one singular mistake on a 50/50 when it comes to my two top scum suspects and get called partners for it.

[Slaxx]

Flip the flip on the head on the head: why does inv kill PB?

[Slaxx]

I guess it could be eragon but you should be HAPPY because we will lynch him tomorrow if your flip doesnt end it

[CultOfAthena]

@slaxx using your same metric:

Inv->Slaxx->Eragon-> /// kitcat->CoA->rooroo /// SA

Why do you have rooroo so up?

p-edit you already answered. I really think I can get a better read on rooroo on D2, but the way she's playing pings me. She could argue it's because of being an alt, but some things never change

6. Sleepless Assassin
7. Slaxx
8. kitcat
9. Pink Ball

Actually isoing Eyes maybe Cult should be the first

Don't start with the conclusion and look for reasoning after the fact.

Flip the flip on the head on the head: why does inv kill PB?

I don't think invis is scum.

[kitcat]

Uh think of thr last game i played with scum!you. When did i die again?

P-edit bleh you got me on mobile

You died the first opportunity after a Mason and conftown. That's when you died.

Consider that this game is happening after that game, when I know for a fact that you'd be averse to the same thing happening twice (which is obvious from what's going on now, but I digress).

I died like the night before lylo

But yeah rhe second paragraph is fair.
I'm a little wary of you talking me out of lynching you by being reasonable sounding