Booneytoonz IX - Under The Sea -- Game Over!

[davesaz]

Maybe dave should have said something instead of letting sheep run his mouth

Did I miss something? I don't recall being mischaracterized but you have a different pov where you might notice more if it's about you.

[Kaito Momota]

Reviewing myself to bring this game back into memory.

Kaito suddenly hyperposts despite being in no personal danger.
Why did that happen?

I don't remember if I was satisfied that we understood this.

Go on

There's no evidence that you've read anything in thread past post 1260

i originally v read you for having a doesnt care vibe but youve kinda switched to really confident/aggressive since a wagon appeared on you which is sort of my idea of typical villa!mser to typical wolf!mser

Do you think these 2 statements are in conflict?

[davesaz]

What does playing as a team mean?

What do you mean by this?

[davesaz]

Reviewing myself to bring this game back into memory.

Kaito suddenly hyperposts despite being in no personal danger.
Why did that happen?

I don't remember if I was satisfied that we understood this.

Go on

There's no evidence that you've read anything in thread past post 1260

i originally v read you for having a doesnt care vibe but youve kinda switched to really confident/aggressive since a wagon appeared on you which is sort of my idea of typical villa!mser to typical wolf!mser

Do you think these 2 statements are in conflict?

Both our scumreads increased, seems to me that they're in sync.

[Kaito Momota]

You guys are saying polar opposite things, are you not?

[Kaito Momota]

Your 2 viewpoints cannot both be correct. Do you think it's time to reevaluate your own play, or is sheep in the wrong?

[Kaito Momota]

Both our scumreads increased

You never said that

Here's what you said:

Reviewing myself to bring this game back into memory.

Kaito suddenly hyperposts despite being in no personal danger.
Why did that happen?

I don't remember if I was satisfied that we understood this.

who

was

in danger at the time you noticed this, in your opinion? and why is this bothering you?

The sudden interest in what was going on felt like it might have been intended as a distraction, but it's no longer obvious what it was. I read over several pages before that point and can't tell from them.

[Firebringer]

What is up I am awake

[davesaz]

Only scum make distractions. As of 1261 I thought you were scum making a distraction to stop a wagon.

Sheep's statement is that he thinks a shift from quiet to aggressive is more likely to be scum.

They are completely different topics, but they both result in scumreads.

[Firebringer]

Pink, Clem: why the turnaround to Wisdom here?

'Cause I think that Wisdom's anti town attitude is the main problem with this game, and it will not be solved with him around. If he's scum, great, we lynch scum. If he's town, he either starts playing like a team or eats rope, 'cause his pushes are lame af

Naah Wisdom slot is mostly self resolving. Lynching him doesn't do much and I don't think we would get any associations from a wisdom scum flip anyways

I can get down with Pink's logic there.

I wont

[Firebringer]

Wisdom is one of those people like RC that if I ignore long enough it will just solve itself. I don't think I have ever been in a game with him where he was town and he wasn't night killed or it wasn't obvious he was scum in LYLO.

Also if I was scum I would nk him.

[Firebringer]

wow davesaz is scummy in the last few posts. especially that post about wisdom.

davesaz why you think wisdom is probing town for weaknesses?

[davesaz]

elsa/sheep/someone

im starting to consider chara

elsa/sheep/chara

oh yeah forgot about dave

he can be scum too

Trying on teams for size, to see if anyone bites.

[davesaz]

What exactly is scummy about the other posts?
Sheep and I are talking about two different points in time, before and after Kaito had votes.
Kaito's trying to call that an inconsistency where someone is wrong.
Then he's saying I should take Sheep to task? Why?

[davesaz]

Followup on Wisdom -- he's tossing all those one liners and doing nothing to try to convince anyone.

[Kaito Momota]

As of 1261 I thought you were scum making a distraction to stop a wagon.

Then why did you vote with me?

[Firebringer]

Followup on Wisdom -- he's tossing all those one liners and doing nothing to try to convince anyone.

have you played with wisdom before?

[Kaito Momota]

Sheep and I are talking about two different points in time, before and after Kaito had votes.

Can you explain to me where in the thread Sheep is referring to then? Since you seem to know

[Kaito Momota]

FWIW I stand by my stance that wisdom is posting but not actually doing anything other than probing town for weaknesses.

Followup on Wisdom -- he's tossing all those one liners and doing nothing to try to convince anyone.

Let's take a look at your voting history for a second

dave you should know better

Usually the people I don't think are scumhunting end up being scum.
VOTE: Wisdom

Kaito suddenly hyperposts despite being in no personal danger.
Why did that happen?

UNVOTE:

Wisdom, before the last 24 hours I was as sure on Maki being town as you seem to be on her being scum.
Now I'm not so sure anymore. Her play is fine to me, but not just one but two players popped up as possible partners.

Creature has crossed back into nullscum territory. It's just meta but the probably town vibe has disappeared.

I believe Nikk was saying "information" as a reason to lynch Maki over someone else. That seemed off when there were 4-6 days left.

Yeah, that's all disconnected. I suspect something important happened under the covers during that catchup. Not sure what. Don't know if it can be connected in the remaining deadline time.

Clemency and Elsa Jay felt weird around the mason talk. Town Clem who is townreading Elsa should go along, maybe deflect it with a "you mean we're

like

masons to each other right". Town Clem who thinks Elsa is scum should flat out refute it and vote there. That leaves us with scum Clem not wanting to get caught if Elsa flips.
Until I can unpack the other shifts while I was sleeping...
VOTE: Clemency

VOTE: Nikk

Wow that's surprising. Hey, why did you even lynch Nikk? You have so much to say about everyone else but seemed content to jump on Nikk by saying he felt "off" and leaving it at that

Sure looks a lot like you're probing town for weaknesses right now.

[davesaz]

Look at the post numbers. Iirc the sheep post you’re referring to is 300-400 posts later.

Nikk was a compromise to avoid nl.

You may be confusing the concept of past and present. At that point in time. This goes with first sentence but I’m on tablet and don’t want to move it.

Whether wisdom is always like this doesn’t matter. I think he’s scum, full stop.

[davesaz]

Btw the full text you quoted is the towniest post of all time. You’re just as bad at thinking as I remember.

[Wisdom]

no you dont think im scum
every game you play with me you "scumread" me for the same thing
you know by now its not alignment indicative

[Wisdom]

your team argument is also bs

i frequently try to guess teams as soon as d1

you are just trying to assign scum motivation to it out of nowhere

[Chara]

come to think of it, saying town Clem shouldn't have refuted Elsa's mason claim is weird. fakeclaiming masons can be a bad idea to begin with depending on who it is, even if you have a townread on that player. why is saying "no, we aren't" so much stranger than doing some pointless hedging like you suggest town Clem who is townreading Elsa should do?

[Chara]

above was to davesaz.