Mini Normal 2054: Winter's Sacrifice [Game Over]

[Sashaddin]

Really don’t like the “for now” out

Opinions can change, I didn't want people to think I was town!xwing all the way. Different ways of thinking I guess.

[Slaxx]

I’m not, but Egix brought it up so now it’s a pertinent topic of discussion.

Sorry. “Last holdout” means the last person arguing for a certain topic or last person to stop defending a certain stance.

Feel free to clarify any language barriers. It’s really important we don’t miscommunicate.

[xwing]

I think roster is town for the early game read change that Dann pointed out.

I’m interested in HC’s catchup

im not yet sold on roster town, but if you and dannflor vouch for it, must be so..anyway will wait for roster to comment some more..
im interested to hear from both HC and JC..
how are you reading gamma?

what did you mean by "not caring" then?

I (didn't) care ... about the L-1 since that was not the case anymore. My vote had less impact (4th I think) instead of sixth. But I was still suspicious of you.

makes sense, just wished you worded it more clearly, coz it read more as you not caring about voting for me..
can you elaborate on your egix/JC town read?
pedit: is french your first language then? i always assumed english coz you're canadian but yeah.. >_<

[Slaxx]

I’m mulling over Gamma. Not town or scum.

(Dann/Roster/Egix)
(X)

Everyone else is churning around in null/null-scum

[Sashaddin]

@xwing

JC: Roleplay made me think that she had nothing to lose so that she leaned town. Not always a tell, but I could fall for it. But it was an early game call, now I've found people more townier.

Egix: While in our previous game he was mostly absent, in this game he is quite on the offensive. First on gamma then on xwing. I have a thought that he might want to make a lot of distance between Gamma and him. His play towards xwing is not quite the same I think. A complicated slot to read right now, I'm not so sure he's town anymore. Could be, but then easily could not too.

I am a French Canadian indeed.

[xwing]

@slaxx: what do you make of percy? also, can you elaborate on your egix tr? i know you've been historically accurate with reading him, but just wanna know how you came to that conclusion in this game..

@sasha:
no questions on your JC read, though she's more null for me..
got a couple of questions on your egix read..
1) why would you expect egix to distance himself from gamma?
2) what do you mean by his play towards me being different? do you mean compared to his approach with gamma?

[Slaxx]

Egix noticed a content difference between your last entrance post in Schadd and this one, and his analysis seemed genuine. He’s more proactive and driving conversation which I generally read as town.

[xwing]

you missed the part about percy..what do you make of him?

[Slaxx]

Sorry. Not for sure if his pedantry is AI or not. Gun to my head, mafia.

[Sashaddin]

“Last holdout” means the last person arguing for a certain topic or last person to stop defending a certain stance.

Forgot to answer this one.

I think it's a question of timing, which led to rereading xwing. which led to a bit of sheeping
But his posts really got better in the meantime so I'm ok having my vote off him.

[Haschel Cedricson]

Gonna give my thoughts as they come in. Haven't read everything yes but I'll let you know where I am.

Biggest thing that jumps out on Page 4 is Tchill's entrance is very bad.

[Sashaddin]

got a couple of questions on your egix read..
1) why would you expect egix to distance himself from gamma?
2) what do you mean by his play towards me being different? do you mean compared to his approach with gamma?

1- Both would be scum
2- The angle he used wasn't the same for both people, imo.

[Slaxx]

VOTE: Persivul

I am having a boatload of trouble getting a damn scumread.

[Sashaddin]

I am having a boatload of trouble getting a damn scumread

Tight game, eh?

[Haschel Cedricson]

Page 5 and 6: Persival's case on xwing looks good, and BuJaber's 128 doesn't look great.

any more takers for a wagon on me?
really, i feel there's nothing much to comment on..
kinda disappointed no questions were thrown my way though..

What the hell is this? There's plenty of stuff to comment on. If the wagon on you is wrong, GIVE US A BETTER ONE. The rest of xwing's posts here are refusing to commit to stances.

[Haschel Cedricson]

Page 7: Stop asking other people about yet other people's metas.

Oh hey Gamma is back with some garbage posts. Egix offering reasons for not following the game isn't great, but admittedly it's not much.

Persivul is officially the towniest person in the game at this point.

[Haschel Cedricson]

Page 8: Thread: Let's talk about what exactly "tryharding" means some more!
aaaaaaaaaaaaaashutupshutupshutupnoonecares

LMAO it's been a while since this argument was used on me. I don't think you actually believe this tbh, and are just spouting trite garbage.

Alright, why don't you think Persivul believes this? This vote on Persivul is awful btw.

Mhm, I think I found the scum from the xwing wagon, the way you care none for which of us is lynched tell me both are equal in your eyes. This also indicates xwing is town, which I wasn't sure of yet.

You believe the scum on the xwing wagon was the first player on the wagon? Do you think the xwing wagon is bad?

I'll meta dive on Egix later because I'm stuck on him being scummy

I noted that a lot of people expressed interest in voting xwing before voting. Vote order doesn’t matter that much because of that.

Woah woah woah, there's a lot to unpack here. People expressed interested in voting xwing before actually voting? Cool.

Show me an example of this happening before the very first vote on the wagon. This is not a rhetorical question.

Also, you completely ignored the question about whether or not the xwing wagon is bad.

The xwing wagon also piled on super fast and had two naked votes on it so that should be making you suspicious of its intentions

Are you pushing those naked votes for elaboration? If not, why not?

[Haschel Cedricson]

Page 9: Why is tchill in your sights, xwing?

Ah good, Dannflor noted the problem in Gamma's statement about the xwing wagon.

Quoting across games is stupid painful on mobile. I'll have to cite my xwing stuff later.

Please don't.

Do, however, elaborate on your Persivul "look[ing] like scum for other reasons" since I'm not seeing 187 as particularly strong, especially considering what's going on with xwing and Gamma.

[Haschel Cedricson]

Alright, those are pretty much the main things that jumped out.

[JunkoChan]

@xwing Gamma is scum, kill tyvm

[xwing]

@HC

Page 5 and 6: Persival's case on xwing looks good, and BuJaber's 128 doesn't look great.
can you elaborate why?

any more takers for a wagon on me?
really, i feel there's nothing much to comment on..
kinda disappointed no questions were thrown my way though..

What the hell is this? There's plenty of stuff to comment on. If the wagon on you is wrong, GIVE US A BETTER ONE. The rest of xwing's posts here are refusing to commit to stances.

i expected town to be trying to sort me more by questioning me..but im really disappointed it didnt happen..also i wanted to see more takers so we can out at least one scum, so this was intentional..
is your view of me still as someone refusing to commit to stances after finishing your reading?

Page 7: Stop asking other people about yet other people's metas.

Oh hey Gamma is back with some garbage posts. Egix offering reasons for not following the game isn't great, but admittedly it's not much.

Persivul is officially the towniest person in the game at this point.

why is percy townie for you?

Page 9: Why is tchill in your sights, xwing?

Ah good, Dannflor noted the problem in Gamma's statement about the xwing wagon.

Quoting across games is stupid painful on mobile. I'll have to cite my xwing stuff later.

Please don't.

Do, however, elaborate on your Persivul "look[ing] like scum for other reasons" since I'm not seeing 187 as particularly strong, especially considering what's going on with xwing and Gamma.

i feel like there's at least one scum on my wagon, though it didnt reach L-1..
tchill is on my sights because he's one of those in my wagon, and i dont have much of an opinion towards him, and most other people also dont (correct me if im mistaken)..
roster at least has some people tr-ing him, though as i said, im not convinced of his townie-ness yet..
sasha, im currently engaging with..

[xwing]

@xwing Gamma is scum, kill tyvm

why do you think so again, JC? you changed your avi!

[BuJaber]

Mhm, I think I found the scum from the xwing wagon, the way you care none for which of us is lynched tell me both are equal in your eyes. This also indicates xwing is town, which I wasn't sure of yet.

What does it indicate to you about sashaddin?

Probably town too
Also noting Persivul is pushing the same logic but didn’t see fit to respond to my vote

You think Persivul is scum and choose to name only townies in his lynch pool?
What is your case on him exactly? I get you think there's scum on xwing but what makes you think it's persivul? He's one of the main players driving this game forward.


Slaxx how experienced are you?

[Slaxx]

Not even going to buy me dinner first?

Idk, 30 games maybe?

[Mewtaph]

-