I was townreading Persivul by hood posting but his response here killed thatIn post 268, Persivul wrote:Is the scum team {pers, dunn, ruby}?In post 257, Plotinus wrote:Get a Room: Plotinus, Flavour Leaf
Point 1: Across the games that I've moderated with this setup,70% of scum players complained in public about rooms. Town were usually enthusiastic about them or at least neutral, though a few townies struggled to keep up if they were in fewer rooms than most people.
If not, you're using a stat disingenuously to push me, probably because I made a case on you to which you haven't responded.
Except that had nothing to do with my case on you. I just think your attitude and wording was rude.Point 2:Selective listening: When Persivul is trying to smear somebody and it turns out that his point is false, he completely ignores this information. For example, in 178-183, he ignores the clarification that Clemency's post restriction was 5 minutes away from expiring when I made that comment, so what I and Clemency understood my comment to mean was "I don't expect an answer in the next five minutes, but when you're free to talk about, please tell me..."
Continues to act like it's scummy? I made one point about your push for rooms being scummy: 220 "His first post is bad. I get using rooms for a reason. But, just making rooms to make rooms eventually sows confusion, and that benefits scum."He also continues to act like it's scummy that I'm pushing rooms when I've clarified multiple times that having modded this setup gives me insight into what the best strategy for town is. He has to do this because he knows that rooms are making it harder for him to control the game as scum.He's not trying to find out the truth, he's just trying to push his agenda.
Note that I was paraphrasing an argument that I had made several days previously in a room, and that referred to your first post on rooms. My main reason for scum reading you is your push on Dunn, as is apparent in that post.
After you clarified your reasoning on rooms, I actually agreed with you in part: 106 "Huh? Plot wants rooms with a specific purposes: "for town to have places to work together out of scum's eyes,: and to "scumhunt people in private differently from you can scumhunt them in public."
I agree with the first,"
So, you're misrepping me when you act as if I'm inflexible in my assessment of your position on rooms.
Do you have examples?Point 3:Tone. Persivul tends to use a different tone when he's town than when he's scum.
I had both a town game and a scum game end yesterday:
viewtopic.php?f=2&t=77928
viewtopic.php?f=83&t=78139
Please, show how my tone in this game is clearly the same as my tone in the scum game, and clearly different from the tone in the town game.
I've been a little nasty in this game. Anyone who bothers to read these is going to see I wasn't like that at all in the scum game, but did show some snark in the town game.
So, either your memory is bad, your meta is out of date, or you're just making things up because I'm pushing you.
Especially the first part, scum don’t have to be in that set for one scum to complain about rooms being set up. That’s some very blatantly wrong logic.
