Merchant's Daughter [Game Restart!]

[Celica]

Alright I'll bite, what question are you talking about?

I asked why you thought my posting made me look like an easy townread. That had me confused

Your style of posting is very easy for other players to townread, but it's possible you are capable of posting like that as scum, that's what I was thinking

Fair enough, I don't think you're wrong. I think it's best to look at the content of the posts though. Do you have a read on me?

Why are all the pretty people going for the guys I want. It's like my high school prom all over again.

A-Am I cute? o///o

Of course, you are! Have you seen yourself?

[Dunnstral]

I'm leaning town after seeing you make that push on Slaxx

[Reinhardt]

My my it seems a fair amount of discussion has already occurred! I’ll do my best to become appraised of the situation.

[Dunnstral]

I’ll do my best to become appraised of the situation.

I'm not sure that's how that word is used

[Krazy]

I think it's fitting given how coins work in this game

[Reinhardt]

I've now read posts 3-11 and realise this may have been a Bad Decision

Interesting, Will keep in mind going forward I guess.
Also a few questions for our gracious mod.

@FakeGod: the rules seem to imply each pair has 1 vote at least during First Dance, is this correct?
I also assume majority in the First Dance is based on total coins in the game?

[Slaxx]

My issue with Slax is all I really see in his iso is a lot of angry posts where he appears to get pissed off. If we take anger as NAI and just look at the content and context posts I really dislike his posts.

the read is genuine

This is a Trust Tell. A bannable offense and needs to be removed from the game.

Was this in reference to our mindmeld or separate?

separate
it was a shitpost

lol

do u see what i see

I'm suddenly starting to think maybe not

Wait you're not on Adel SR?

It is funny to me that once again you have scum read me, and it matters not what account I am on.

The fact you're an alt makes that way way worse tbh.

The fact I townread Adel coming back to this push on him from Slaxx really bad, the post I forgot to quote is him saying he scumreads Adel for Adel saying ‘did you claim scum the worst?’ That post may look bad yeah, but I don’t see why scum Adel even posts that. It feels like a really easy scumread to make and a push I can see Slax going for.

People jumping on fb already are probably scummy

I haven't read anything yet

Why even say that if you haven't read? Why not let it naturally progress instead of trying stifling it while you catchup?

Actually I really don't like Dunn's entrance as it processes.

The timing of these posts on dunn just strikes me as off. Feels like a way to discredit, not really trying to solve, but trying to stop reads.

Ank and Urist are null
Dunn is town

Why is Dunn town?

Good analysis, seems towny. Don't worry yourself, this is early on, reads can and will change.

...He had like four posts

Why does post count matter when it comes to a read? I don’t think it does at all. Seems like another reason for trying to stop reads.

People jumping on fb already are probably scummy

I haven't read anything yet

Why even say that if you haven't read? Why not let it naturally progress instead of trying stifling it while you catchup?

Because he's lynchbait

Read the past dance games

Being lynchbait doesn't make you immune to scumreads

My fucking god I might as well make it my sig.

Prob the only post of Slaxx I agree and call towny.

Okay

Allo and I agree on Krazy

Before this post he made comments on Allo being scummy/maybe scum. So if that’s true, you and your scumreading agreeing on a read doesn’t make you pause.

Gut read I think Adel is town

>_______________>

The people Slax scumreads right here. One of them (Dunn) calls the other town. (Adel) What makes me pause here is Slax does nothing about it. Not a call out, no questions why, nothing. I would expect Slax to call this out as town or at least question it. All we get is ‘>_>’

(Nancy Drew, The Worst)
(Ank, Clem)
(Allo, Celica, Alisae, FB, Jib, McQ)
(Dunn, PB, PVT)
(Krazy, Adel)

I think is where I’m at. Middle it’s rough, top two and bottom two I’m relatively confident in.

This is further shown by his reads list. So yeah this is why I sr him

Anger probably NAI for me but the read would be determined if you thought it was feigned.

I can’t respond to the off thing.

Post count definitely matters in reads that early. Maybe you could make an argument they wouldn’t if they were huge posts, but they weren’t, and writing “four short posts” seems redundant.

I think I’ve been more solvey than average so I’m not for sure where that’s coming from.

The Dunn thing is a good point, I probably should have pushed him but there was a lot going on. We’ve generated thirty pages in a day. I think your analysis comes more from town, ironically, as Dunn said.

[Dunnstral]

I think it's fitting given how coins work in this game

Guys only want 1 thing

[FakeGod]

Every player will have at least one vote.

Majority is always based on number of players alive.

[Slaxx]

It might be hard to explain it when you weren’t there IRT, but if you look at time stamps of posts it really looked like Adel was waiting for a cheap push while FB and TW were 1v1ing. He active lurked for a bit with Jib, disappeared, then came back promptly to make that “gotcha” post on TW which was clunky. He could have been prying them and asking questions while he was in the thread the first time, but seemed to wait until someone to make a low-hanging statement he could grab onto instead of actively sorting them. Surely that makes sense.

[mcqueen]

McQueen is a pretty easy townread when he's town, but he hasn't shown up yet. That's more an expected placement than an actual placement right now, as I kinda explained

I've been busy with university this week, that's why. Plus, keeping up with 20+ pages in a few days is hard enough on it's own. I'll make time over the weekend to catch up.

Also, I'm surprised you remember me, tbh. It's been awhile

[Slaxx]

What is my reads list supposed to support exactly?

[Adelbert Steiner]

@FakeGod I just got assigned to a trial at work, V/LA until Monday, please

[Slaxx]

Oh... I might know who Adel is, and if so, not cool Re: referencing an ongoing game. If not, ignore I guess.

[Slaxx]

Nancy, you can be the one that got away <3

Does anyone have issues with Slaxx/Dunn?

[the worst]

Ohhhhh same
I need to reassess this read

[the worst]

Nancy, you can be the one that got away <3

Does anyone have issues with Slaxx/Dunn?

I don't feel nearly as comfortable about Dunn as I do about you fam

[Allomancer]

*deep breathe*

Okay allo, you are going to have to be patient with me cause I am going to be as patient as possible with you.
I don't understand you at all, and I am going to try to understand you better. That means I am going to mess up a lot, and I am annoyed at things that are difficult to understand especially when they won't work with me. So we shall try this.

You have me as your biggest scumread. Can we go through that...development...for lack of a better word to talk about what got you to that, what has reinforced/weaken that so that we all understand why I am scum?

Would appreciate it.

Your annoyed friend,
Firebringer

All right.

In all seriousness though, FoS at FB and TW for pairing up so quickly. Someone isn't going to get to dance, and we have to strategize about who it should be. Now FB and TW live anyway, even if we suspect them.

Early on, I already was kinda sus of you and tw. Then later, the worst focused on solving the game, while you kept shitposting. You guys were some of my first reads, and nothing has changed that since. More to follow, got to go now.

[Adelbert Steiner]

Oh... I might know who Adel is, and if so, not cool Re: referencing an ongoing game. If not, ignore I guess.

Game I was specifically thinking of was about a year ago and was abandoned by the mod. Were you not dog person in that game, if you are so sure who I am?

[Dunnstral]

Nancy, you can be the one that got away <3

Does anyone have issues with Slaxx/Dunn?

I don't feel nearly as comfortable about Dunn as I do about you fam

And I don't feel as comfortable about you as I do about fire. Where's my veto power?

[Firebringer]

Early on, I already was kinda sus of you and tw. Then later, the worst focused on solving the game, while you kept shitposting. You guys were some of my first reads, and nothing has changed that since. More to follow, got to go now.

Can you go into this more? I am highly skeptical of a lot of what you are saying here because I can find cases of both me and the worst shit posting and us both solving the game and for you to just say this is very one dimensional.

[Slaxx]

Nancy, you can be the one that got away <3

Does anyone have issues with Slaxx/Dunn?

I don't feel nearly as comfortable about Dunn as I do about you fam

That’s the point though.

Nancy and I together would probably just draw the the kill.

Now, I might be begging for that two weeks from now but right now I quite enjoy the game. Allo actually made a lot of sense: Pair scummy people together and then pair each Town with a null.

[Slaxx]

Oh... I might know who Adel is, and if so, not cool Re: referencing an ongoing game. If not, ignore I guess.

Game I was specifically thinking of was about a year ago and was abandoned by the mod. Were you not dog person in that game, if you are so sure who I am?

Nah fam. I’ve only been back three months or so.

My last game before that was like... 2013 or 2012 or something.

[the worst]

Nancy, you can be the one that got away <3

Does anyone have issues with Slaxx/Dunn?

I don't feel nearly as comfortable about Dunn as I do about you fam

And I don't feel as comfortable about you as I do about fire. Where's my veto power?

About the same place as your suggestion that this entire phase is worthless

In the dumpster

[Adelbert Steiner]

Oh... I might know who Adel is, and if so, not cool Re: referencing an ongoing game. If not, ignore I guess.

Game I was specifically thinking of was about a year ago and was abandoned by the mod. Were you not dog person in that game, if you are so sure who I am?

Nah fam. I’ve only been back three months or so.

My last game before that was like... 2013 or 2012 or something.

Then I must withdraw my previous joking reference. I remember a dog in 2018. I am bad with names, not so much with images.

Now I must get back to deposition reading!