Merchant's Daughter [Game Restart!]

[mcqueen]

I posted once and never read it. Game ended so quickly I never got replaced

[Slaxx]

Okay. Still having a hard time believing you think getting into heated one on ones is a towntell but I can’t use that game as an example.

[mcqueen]

I do because if you look at my older games, a lot of them I got heated and I was mostly town

[Nancy Drew 39]

it's not rare for people who don't know how I play to scumread my playstyle

it's generally not hard to see who genuinely thinks I'm scum for it and who's just trying to push an agenda on it

the way he handled the read was annoying but I don't think it came from a scum agenda, no

Well I obviously wouldn’t link you from Necromancer game.

yeah but it's a good example of me knowing what I'm talking about with this kind of thing, since that's kind of how I got an obvtown read of you that game

(also naturally the read changes if Urist hides behind the read all game since he's done very little else besides snipe at me and try to get people to talk about me)

Yeah, well he promised to check out the links I posted, so we’ll see if that changes anything.

[Slaxx]

I do because if you look at my older games, a lot of them I got heated and I was mostly town

And you think everyone plays the same way you do?

[Slaxx]

Also regardless of whether you read it or not I’ve provided an example of scum getting heated. Does that do nothing for your opinion?

[Nancy Drew 39]

I'd still rather Nancy dance with Urist

it's probably the best shot we have at getting him out of his tunnel on me

I would rather dance with McQueen, since I think he could be town here. I just want to wait for Krazy replace in. So McQueen, a

tentative

yes for now?

How does Urist pairing with me help his tunnel on you?

[mcqueen]

You know any smart person would say no, so why ask? Of course I don’t, but I found the exchange between Celica/PB to be on the more towntell side of things.

Pedit: i skimmed your iso. No offense, and i have no idea who celica is, but you’re a stronger player. You got mad but not “damaged” per se. i felt like Celica was genuinely hurt, and that’s town.

[Ankamius]

Because having an extra influence on him outside of the thread is probably a much better way of getting him to shift his mindset than having conversations in the main thread where he will have to see my posts there too

[Nancy Drew 39]

People said McQ is an easy read... not seeing it.

I don’t know why anyone would think that but he does seem to be really townie here.

[Slaxx]

People said McQ is an easy read... not seeing it.

I don’t know why anyone would think that but he does seem to be really townie here.

I’d like him to be.

Explain?

[Slaxx]

You know any smart person would say no, so why ask? Of course I don’t, but I found the exchange between Celica/PB to be on the more towntell side of things.

Pedit: i skimmed your iso. No offense, and i have no idea who celica is, but you’re a stronger player. You got mad but not “damaged” per se. i felt like Celica was genuinely hurt, and that’s town.

Alright. I don’t know if I buy the genuine hurt bit but I think you believe it and that’s good enough.

[Slaxx]

Also I asked because I never bank on anyone being smart 100% of the time.

[Nancy Drew 39]

Because having an extra influence on him outside of the thread is probably a much better way of getting him to shift his mindset than having conversations in the main thread where he will have to see my posts there too

True but I prefer to dance with someone I at least have a townlean on and tn, I’m feeling better about McQueen than Urist.

I think the Rein slot looks the worst rn. We’ll see what the replacement brings.

[Nancy Drew 39]

People said McQ is an easy read... not seeing it.

I don’t know why anyone would think that but he does seem to be really townie here.

I’d like him to be.

Explain?

His thought process, is seeming townie to me, you disagree?

[Slaxx]

@Mod

Can you fix my name in the dance pairs?

Idk if that’s petty or not but it’s weird seeing it like that lol

[mcqueen]

That’s true, I got a bit snarky.

I’m glad we’ve reached an understanding.

Can you reiterate why Krazy was scum? Still havent looked through his ISO, but I’d like to know what you saw.

[Slaxx]

People said McQ is an easy read... not seeing it.

I don’t know why anyone would think that but he does seem to be really townie here.

I’d like him to be.

Explain?

His thought process, is seeming townie to me, you disagree?

Trying to figure that out.

Anything specific?

[Slaxx]

That’s true, I got a bit snarky.

I’m glad we’ve reached an understanding.

Can you reiterate why Krazy was scum? Still havent looked through his ISO, but I’d like to know what you saw.

Heavy emphasis on mechanics talk, any actual scumhunting he did was bad (pushed me for suspecting him even though he realized what he was doing could be perceived as scummy, pushed PVT for the order he listed his reads in). His list made sense from a meta perspective, he put easily readable people up top, but made no sense from a within-game perspective. Dozens of pages went by and almost every conversation we had was framed in regards to mechanics and lists without him really trying to solve for alignments.

[Slaxx]

“Pushed me” is way dramatic. Sorry on break on mobile.

Mentioned he was worried about me

Is a better way to phrase that.

[Nancy Drew 39]

People said McQ is an easy read... not seeing it.

I don’t know why anyone would think that but he does seem to be really townie here.

I’d like him to be.

Explain?

His thought process, is seeming townie to me, you disagree?

Trying to figure that out.

Anything specific?

His reads on Celica/PB, seem to be pretty nuanced, IOW, not surfacey.

[Slaxx]

I could probably be convinced upon his replace out it might be a playstyle thing but I’m still irked he avoided telling me how he came to a specific decision about Dunn and I. Feel like town in that situation just says oops didn’t have the info I thought I did, but he instead said I was throwing a hissy for after he didn’t answer me straight for a few posts, then came back to it later. Felt dodgy.

[mcqueen]

Ok. Just one question; how is doing/saying something that you already know could be perceived as scummy more scum AI than town AI?

[Slaxx]

And the more I pressed him the more he asserted I shouldn’t make it to x point in the game without ever taking a stance on my alignment, while still having someone with barely any content up top. Really just didn’t make any sense even from a mechanics-town-solve perspective.

[Nancy Drew 39]

“Pushed me” is way dramatic. Sorry on break on mobile.

Mentioned he was worried about me

Is a better way to phrase that.

Since you already “broke my heart” by choosing Dunn, who you do you think is the towniest unpaired gent?