In post 129, tris wrote:@hawkleader, you haven't really given any reads yet. Care to share?
@Allomancer, you haven't really either, unless you count choosing to vote for joges over Overkill.
I'm not really sure what to make of Chateau.
In post 132, Allomancer wrote:townleaning on hawk but he hasn't posted enough for me to be sure
Yeah I will admit that I have gotten busy the past few days. I promise myself that I will stay up late tonight to reread all of these posts and give my reads on everyone in this game.
In post 130, Allomancer wrote:I really didn't like 111 and 114. the fact that chateau changed their mind so quickly is suspicious. If you just have a question about someone's logic, you shouldn't be voting them for it. The fact that he was willing to unvote after a post explaining a single statement means it wasn't really a valid scumread in the first place.
this. And his baiting me to help him hammer Overki11 yesterday.
Keep in mind, I'm not placing a townread on Overki11 right now, I'm just saying CL looks pretty bad, too.
Do you not think Overkill is clear?
Mechanically, no. There’s still the possibility of 3 other Hated’s: townie, Cult Leader, and Survivor. What if he’s the Cult Leader?
Readswise, yeah I’m not sure I’d place a “cultread” on him, but he’s under close inspection.
Theres only one setup with a one shot doctor, and that is one with a hated townie. I dont see how overkill claims hated without knowing the setup at all. That and the fact that he was attacked, makes him confirmed town to anyone who believes me.
Age of Empires Elo: 1500 something in DE, 1800 in HD
Formerly Dongempire
By the way, there are jesters in the game. Chateu's play and typing style doesnt match up with his previous games at all, so i think this might be a possible jester. However, it also might be a double WIFOM to make us believe he is jester. There isnt much downside to lynching him but we do lose a lynch which is huge in a bastard game, so i figure we shouldnt be lynching him right now.
Trying to figure out the setup right now. Came up with this:
One K
Two T's
Two S's
If we can figure out the jester and kill the cult leader (if there is one) then im pretty positive we can ride this out. So if jester claims right now, i am willing to play to his wincon after we get rid of cultist.
Age of Empires Elo: 1500 something in DE, 1800 in HD
Formerly Dongempire
In post 52, mcqueen wrote:Why are people asking for claims of a cult leader? As if they’d really claim that?
I get why anybody who’s hated would want to claim, but even then... I still wasn’t super fond of it. Reason is it could also be a scum gambit not to get pushed too hard.
I’m feeling Overkill at the moment, but with someone else asking for a possible claim, and others claiming hated, I need some time to sort out who I think is scum, rather than bandwagoning somebody.
In post 64, mcqueen wrote:Also, I messed up. There could also be a hated SK. But, if Overkill flips green, then joges remains the target (Cult/SK isn’t good for town).
In post 76, mcqueen wrote:I mean, I’m fine lynching scum today and one of you tomorrow. Scum still has to go, y’know.
In post 79, mcqueen wrote:Mafia and scum are usually interchangeable, as far as I’m aware. If you’d prefer me to use the term mafia, that’s fine; yes, I do mean mafia.
In post 130, Allomancer wrote:I really didn't like 111 and 114. the fact that chateau changed their mind so quickly is suspicious. If you just have a question about someone's logic, you shouldn't be voting them for it. The fact that he was willing to unvote after a post explaining a single statement means it wasn't really a valid scumread in the first place.
this. And his baiting me to help him hammer Overki11 yesterday.
Keep in mind, I'm not placing a townread on Overki11 right now, I'm just saying CL looks pretty bad, too.
These are all posts
from a scum member.
I was "baiting"
McQueen to see if
he would flip
on me.
He did.
Scum Playing 101.
He slipped with his
scum/mafia thing.
Don't just brush that under the rug.
Lynching me
is
VERY BAD
for the town.
Very bad.
Besides
I can not
be lynched the normal way...
Everyone LOVES me
You will see
one at a time!
So why try?
ur bad, and I can almost 100% guarentee that you would going to hammer me.
And I can understand why he flipped on you, thwt was so not town motivated.
In post 153, Donempire wrote:Theres only one setup with a one shot doctor, and that is one with a hated townie. I dont see how overkill claims hated without knowing the setup at all. That and the fact that he was attacked, makes him confirmed town to anyone who believes me.
Is there? When I looked I only saw the possible roles (the big list with all the letters, like “CCCC”), not the possible setups. My mistake, honestly. If what you said is true, then yeah, Overki11’s cleared.
In post 154, Donempire wrote:By the way, there are jesters in the game. Chateu's play and typing style doesnt match up with his previous games at all, so i think this might be a possible jester. However, it also might be a double WIFOM to make us believe he is jester.
There isnt much downside to lynching him but we do lose a lynch which is huge in a bastard game, so i figure we shouldnt be lynching him right now.
I agree. UNVOTE:
Trying to figure out the setup right now. Came up with this:
One K
Two T's
Two S's
If we can figure out the jester and kill the cult leader (if there is one) then im pretty positive we can ride this out. So if jester claims right now, i am willing to play to his wincon after we get rid of cultist.
The setup has been modified, so we can't know exact letters.
Last edited by Maestro on Wed Feb 06, 2019 6:54 pm, edited 1 time in total.
In post 154, Donempire wrote:
If we can figure out the jester and kill the cult leader (if there is one) then im pretty positive we can ride this out. So if jester claims right now, i am willing to play to his wincon after we get rid of cultist.
In post 154, Donempire wrote:By the way, there are jesters in the game. Chateu's play and typing style doesnt match up with his previous games at all, so i think this might be a possible jester. However, it also might be a double WIFOM to make us believe he is jester.
There isnt much downside to lynching him but we do lose a lynch which is huge in a bastard game, so i figure we shouldnt be lynching him right now.
I agree. UNVOTE:
Trying to figure out the setup right now. Came up with this:
One K
Two T's
Two S's
If we can figure out the jester and kill the cult leader (if there is one) then im pretty positive we can ride this out. So if jester claims right now, i am willing to play to his wincon after we get rid of cultist.
The setup has been modified, so we can't know exact letters.