Booneytoonz IX - Under The Sea -- Game Over!

[Wisdom]

The biggest issue with balance I have is the 2.5 investigatives with a 2-shot doctor as well

That might necessitate 4 scum, 1 being a traitor, with this being a 15 player setup. Does that sound balanced?

yes but why traitor and not goon

[Creature]

nancy creature and jingle cant be both town in this setup. You need to understand this.

How certain are you of molla/FA town?

Because I don’t believe Creature can be scum here. This is just totally out of his scumrange.

i dont care about what you think people's scumrange are

look at the setup

we dont have all these town roles

I've seen more stacked town than that.

[Creature]

sigh i wanna cry we are going to repeat the same things forever

Do normal scumhunting instead.

[Kaito Momota]

For balance, traitor is slightly weaker than a goon, makes it harder to coordinate etc, and possibly doesn't win if they're the only person alive

[Pink Ball]

Just wanted to remind you guys that Creature made a townbloc on D1 and he scumread sheep sincr a long time ago. Hopefully this helps to solve who is scum

[Wisdom]

sigh i wanna cry we are going to repeat the same things forever

Do normal scumhunting instead.

ok normal scumhunting;

jingle does not randomly target clem on a whim without reading. he's better.

[Kaito Momota]

Starting to lean towards lynching Jingle between Jingle/BBMolla here

[Kaito Momota]

VOTE: Jingle

[Kaito Momota]

Didn't realize Jingle replaced sheep or I'd have been voting there earlier

I have no choice but to assume that Maki targeted Clemency because that's where I told her to target. Either way her play here was disgusting.

VOTE: Clemency

If you guys want to lose the game due to not listening to me (we're halfway there) then be my guest, I don't care enough about you guys to try to save the game if you won't do it on your own

See you next prod

I suggest Sheepsaysmeep.

As promised, we will be lynching Maki today. That's certainly wher Chara would have been voting

VOTE: Maki Harukawa

After that, we can sweep around and clean up Clemency as well

Maki Harukawa has been lynched!

Spoiler: The Reveal

She was a Town Desperate Neighborizer.

Welcome, Player, to Booneytoonz IX: Under The Sea! Your role is as follows.

You are a

Town Desperate Neighborizer

. You have your voice and your vote to influence the discussion. You may also neighborize a player each night. If they return a mafia result to an alignment cop, your ability succeeds, otherwise your ability will fail and you will die.
You win when the mafia are eliminated and at least one town player is alive.

It is now Night 3, you have (expired on 2019-02-05 18:25:00) to submit night actions.

Where are you getting this all from @Kaito? It seems to me, that you’re making a helluva lot of assumptions?

You're right, actually. I misremembered. It's Sheepsaysmeep we should be getting, because that's where I said to go

VOTE: Sheepsaysmeep

[Wisdom]

Just wanted to remind you guys that Creature made a townbloc on D1 and he scumread sheep sincr a long time ago. Hopefully this helps to solve who is scum

why so passive

who do you think is scum

[Creature]

The biggest issue with balance I have is the 2.5 investigatives with a 2-shot doctor as well

That might necessitate 4 scum, 1 being a traitor, with this being a 15 player setup. Does that sound balanced?

or maybe your setup spec is just bad and we should focus on finding scum instead.

[Creature]

thats his point, creature. the universal backup DOES backup same alignment

The same way you don't see scum getting rewarded a roleblocker for killing the town roleblocker.

[Kaito Momota]

Stop saying setup spec is bad - it's not bad

[Kaito Momota]

And no I don't care for your one-off example in a game where it didn't work for xyz

[Kaito Momota]

thats his point, creature. the universal backup DOES backup same alignment

The same way you don't see scum getting rewarded a roleblocker for killing the town roleblocker.

This is setup spec, by the way. Saying you're not scum because backup roleblocker wouldn't be a scum role is SETUP SPEC

[Pink Ball]

Just wanted to remind you guys that Creature made a townbloc on D1 and he scumread sheep sincr a long time ago. Hopefully this helps to solve who is scum

why so passive

who do you think is scum

My heart says Creature, but my brain says Jingle. I don't trust my heart, he's a whiny little bitch

[Wisdom]

can you elaborate

[Kaito Momota]

Nobody hammer anything until Maki comes in and says who she is targeting: There is zero reason for her to be keepingj this information a secret.

We lynch her if she lives to tomorrow

I suggest Sheepsaysmeep.

This is good enough for a vote from me

[Wisdom]

you suggested. she didnt accept.

[Kaito Momota]

She passively accepted by not declining

[Wisdom]

nah. probably did her own thing.

[BBmolla]

I still kind of think Kaito is a goon tbqh

[Wisdom]

if kaito is a goon someone has to be a scum pr who blocks

ie jingle

[Kaito Momota]

They don't have to be a scum pr who blocks, Clemency could have blocked you

[Wisdom]

no because in that case the willbooster is useless