Booneytoonz IX - Under The Sea -- Game Over!

[Nancy Drew 39]

i give up, lynch molla and then lose the game for all i care

i lynched two scum, i did enough

Why are we not voting Jingle anymore? *confused*

[Wisdom]

because you all agree its molla/kaito

[Nancy Drew 39]

If we're going to assume four scum it's mechanically better to not lynch Jingle

Why?

so, then Kaito?

I disagree with Wisdom on him.

[Nancy Drew 39]

because you all agree its molla/kaito

I was voting Jingle.

[Nancy Drew 39]

I have two pieces of information related to my role pm on the game. one of them is extremely redundant at this point (millers exist!).

the other is only slightly useful if someone tries to fake claim it because I know it doesn't exist

.

If Jingle is scum here, than why does Fire say that, knowing that Jingle/sheep shot would probably claim a variant?

That’s been nagging at me, ever since Jingle claimed.

[Wisdom]

Jingle didnt claim a variant, he claimed the boon bank role.

[Nancy Drew 39]

I have two pieces of information related to my role pm on the game. one of them is extremely redundant at this point (millers exist!).

the other is only slightly useful if someone tries to fake claim it because I know it doesn't exist

.

If Jingle is scum here, than why does Fire say that, knowing that Jingle/sheep shot would probably claim a variant?

That’s been nagging at me, ever since Jingle claimed.

Fire scumslip or was he being on the level?

It reads like Fire knew Jingle/sheep’s role and was setting him up/ or he didn’t know Jingle/sheep was traitor.

Like why does Fire setup up his buddy?

Either Jingle is town here or traitor

.

So, if Jingle is scum, he can only be traitor, which means that he’s either town or there’s 4 scum in this game, so Creature is 100% right here.

Sorry Wisdom, you’re incorrect.

[Wisdom]

setup spec is not my good point. I've never designed or reviewed or otherwise participated in setup creating. I don't know why I am pretending to know better here, it's probably just ego. You all are probably right and it's Molla/Kaito.

[Wisdom]

nancy there is nothing that connects what you are quoting to Jingle. You don't make any sense.

[Wisdom]

he just said he supposedly had information that a certain role doesnt exist

How does that have to do anything with jingle?

[Nancy Drew 39]

Jingle didnt claim a variant, he claimed the boon bank role.

Okay, I used the wrong term but Jingle/sheep can only be traitor if scum because scum!Fire would never knowingly set up his buddy that way.

But even if Jingle/sheep is traitor, Fire would still have to know he’d fakeclaim, so I think Fire maybe spewed Jingle/sheep town here and I did initially hardtown read that slot.

Unless Fire is some diabolical scum genius, I think it has to be molla/Kaito.

Also Wisdom/Creature can check this, because Jingle will either have tpr or traitor as his result or Wisdom/Creature could check molla (which Wisdom 100% should have done, eventhough Clem probably gamethrew) and then we would know if FA miller claim was fake.

[Wisdom]

Jingle cannot be traitor because he is the boon bank role.

Fire's post had nothing to do with Jingle.

Think before you post.

[Nancy Drew 39]

he just said he supposedly had information that a certain role doesnt exist

How does that have to do anything with jingle?

Jingle claimed Willibooster, right?

That’s probably the role scum!Fire got info on.

And it reads to me that Fire was setting up Jingle/sheep as a potential mislynch.

It also explains Elsa traitor WIFOM, because Elsa is a genius, who rightly realized that someone would probably figure this out, so he setup up Jingle/sheep as traitor. Damn! Elsa is brilliant.

[Wisdom]

Jingle claimed Willibooster, right?

That’s probably the role scum!Fire got info on.

based on what?

you're seriously reaching. fire just added something to make his claim townier

[Wisdom]

like the setup is guaranteed to have a boon bank role. It would make no sense for fire to claim there isn't.

[Wisdom]

It also explains Elsa traitor WIFOM, because Elsa is a genius, who rightly realized that someone would probably figure this out, so he setup up Jingle/sheep as traitor. Damn! Elsa is brilliant.

no he didnt, nancy. cmon.

[Nancy Drew 39]

Jingle cannot be traitor because he is the boon bank role.

Fire's post had nothing to do with Jingle.

Think before you post.

*Sigh* you’re obviously not getting it.

Both Elsa and Fire setup sheep/Jingle.

I already explained Elsa. Fire by claiming

he knows a certain role doesn’t exist

- obviously not vt, rolecop, doc or miller.

[Wisdom]

no they didnt you're lost in your moonlogic.

[Nancy Drew 39]

like the setup is guaranteed to have a boon bank role. It would make no sense for fire to claim there isn't.

So, what is this about a non-existent role then? Why did scum!Fire tell us that?

[Wisdom]

Fire just added some bullshit to make his claim more believable, nancy. He wasnt setting up anything.

Traitor talk was just wifom to confuse us.

Cmon these arent hard. You are reading way too much into simple things.

[Creature]

The problem is it only reveals vanilla or not vanilla, pretty much.

Well, it can catch a few scum. Enough to be the key PR.

[Creature]

I have two pieces of information related to my role pm on the game. one of them is extremely redundant at this point (millers exist!).

the other is only slightly useful if someone tries to fake claim it because I know it doesn't exist

.

If Jingle is scum here, than why does Fire say that, knowing that Jingle/sheep shot would probably claim a variant?

That’s been nagging at me, ever since Jingle claimed.

Jingle didnt claim a variant, he claimed the boon bank role.

lmao if it is the Boon Bank Role that doesn't exist.

[Nancy Drew 39]

Fire just added some bullshit to make his claim more believable, nancy. He wasnt setting up anything.

Traitor talk was just wifom to confuse us.

Cmon these arent hard. You are reading way too much into simple things.

Boon Bank: 1 role.

So, Fire wanted us to think that Jingle/sheep would lie about their role/ or clever scum WIFOM, to makes us think the exact opposite, knowing he was flipping but still, it hurts Jingle/sheep because he’d have to count on us thinking that, so it does look like Fire was setting up Jingle/sheep.

Whether you want to argue set up or reverse psychology here, scum always WIFOM

for a scum agenda REASON

, so definitely NOT moonlogic in either case.

[Wisdom]

no nancy you are 100% wrong there. Fire was just adding some bs to his claim. He wasnt setting up anyone.

[Nancy Drew 39]

I have two pieces of information related to my role pm on the game. one of them is extremely redundant at this point (millers exist!).

the other is only slightly useful if someone tries to fake claim it because I know it doesn't exist

.

If Jingle is scum here, than why does Fire say that, knowing that Jingle/sheep shot would probably claim a variant?

That’s been nagging at me, ever since Jingle claimed.

Jingle didnt claim a variant, he claimed the boon bank role.

lmao if it is the Boon Bank Role that doesn't exist

.

Ding, ding ding. How aren’t you getting this Wisdom?