windkirby wrote:armlx wrote:I'm with Dodge here. This is definitely town GS to me, based on Adel's mountainous open.
Don't understand this post. Could you explain?
I'd also like to point out that JDodge's latest post is further confirming the way he's tossing votes around like they mean nothing: does he actually believe that every single person on the GS bandwagon is scum? Of course not! Rather, he tries to scare the people off of the wagon by threatening to vote for them simply because he doesn't agree with their suspicions. In this case, wouldn't voting them be more of a result of a desire not to get GS lynched than the result an actual belief that the offending players are mafia? Then again, perhaps it's just so he can say, "Now look! This many more players I'm voting for are voting for me back!"
Again, I'm not saying that he 100% confirmed scum, but if we all played like JDodge we would have seventeen simultaneous lynches. You cannot seriously tell me that a townie would believe another player to be scum because he was "asking about something without knowing the context of it."
The other three I can see why you would think them scummy I suppose, but I don't see why you included this one in your list. It seemed that JDodge was continually looking down at the players, and whenever they did something he didn't like, scummy or not, he would "punish" them by voting for them. This seems to me as a very ineffective method of scumhunting, if it is even considered scumhunting, and I figured a player like JDodge wouldn't be doing this sort of thing as town. I was wrong, of course, but I don't understand why my hypothesis was scummy.
I have two primary reasons for voting GS: first and foremost, he waited
less than an hour
after ZS's very reluctant denial to kill him. It was so fast, I wasn't even aware that we were close to a lynch until it was already night. He has been here for three months; I believe he knows better.
Secondly, the reason-that-must-not-be-named, the slip. I can very easily see a scenario in which GS recieved a role that wasn't a pikmin, and then, being so excited about it, he runs into the game and makes a smug remark, "You Pikmins are way too uptight. No wonder the mod called you stupid." (Or something along those lines.) Also note that there was no sign of anyone being uptight, anyway. This signifies, to me, that he wished to perhaps "brag" about his non-Pikmin role, and so he tried to fit it in the game's context as best he could, winding up with a rather awkward slip indeed. It was not until when we brought it up that he realized that by calling us, "you Pikmin," he had accidentally revealed that he was not one.
With all of the school projects being piled on, I hadn't gotten time to examine Pyrodwarf as I had been meaning to, but I believe I have time tonight.
