Micro 851: Baby Too Much Scum (Game Over)

[GeminiTwin12]

Interesting.

[funkybike1]

That didn't take long. Sad Sheep was in this game for not even a day.

VOTE COUNT 0.8

4 of 6 votes are required to lynch. 3 votes are required to No Lynch.

Sad Sheep (4):

brassherald, Vedith, GeminiTwin12, Not_Mafia

Vedith (1):

Segaco

Not Voting (1):

Sad Sheep

Sad Sheep has been lynched.

Sad Sheep was a

Vanilla Townie

.
It is now Night. You have, once again, 48 hours.
If you want an accelerated Night, PM me. Should 4 of 5 players agree, Night will end early.

[funkybike1]

Another night, another death. This time, it was

GeminiTwin12

who was found stabbed to death by the Serial Killer. She was a

Vanilla Townie

.

It's now the last chance for the Town - you have only one shot remaining at finding the Serial Killer. Should you lynch wrongly, this game is over.

Day 3 has now begun.

VOTE COUNT 0.9

3 of 4 votes are required to lynch. 2 votes are required to No Lynch.

Not Voting (4):

brassherald, Not_Mafia, Segaco, Vedith

Deadline is in (expired on 2019-03-21 11:00:00)

[Vedith]

Okay so towns interest is in killing the SK.
I am claiming Mafia here so let's work out who's town out of you 3.

[Vedith]

Let's see what everyone says from here.

[brassherald]

Why are you deciding to out yourself? If we hit SK today, you still lose, because me and the other townie will lynch you tomorrow.

Also, I want to check into who might have thought that Gemini was mafia.

I still lean towards Ssegaco or this being a gambit from the SK but not confident enough to vote with NM being the probable other town and still being himself.

[brassherald]

Yes, that was hammer. We had an extra-long Twilight because there was a power outage and I couldn't get online.

VOTE COUNT 0.3

5 of 8 votes are required to lynch. 4 votes are required to No Lynch.

BBmolla (5):

Not_Mafia, Clemency, Vedith, brassherald, GeminiTwin12

GeminiTwin12 (1):

Segaco

brassherald (1):

BBmolla

Not Voting (1):

xRECKONERx

BBmolla has been lynched.

BBmolla was a

Mafia Goon

.
It is now Night. You have 48 hours to send your Night actions.

Also, why did you bus day 1 if you are mafia?

That's a losing strategy in this set up.

I'm not convinced that mafia you would do this.

[Vedith]

Because I don't want SK to win by me getting lynched.

[Vedith]

I have bussed in every single mafia game I have.

[brassherald]

I have bussed in every single mafia game I have.

Links?

Not to all of them.

[Vedith]

I can do it when at my PC but I have a lot of Scum games. None from this year but 2017.
I've even day vigged my Scum partner in a game for credit.

I'm not the best Scum buddy to have.

[brassherald]

I can do it when at my PC but I have a lot of Scum games. None from this year but 2017.
I've even day vigged my Scum partner in a game for credit.

I'm not the best Scum buddy to have.

Okay, if I have time today maybe I'll independently look, but the request is there still. I'd like to see with my own eyes.

[Vedith]

No problem.
I just tried to look via phone but it's annoying.

So why should I not think that you're the SK here Mr. Brass?

[Not_Mafia]

So we just no lynch and let SK kill Vedith right?

[brassherald]

So we just no lynch and let SK kill Vedith right?

I don't like leaving my fate in the hands of SK, but this may not be a bad idea.
d,
Also, it would be pretty much the same result as just lynching the SK. We dedicate today to finding the SK, SK kills Vedith, we wake up with 3 tomorrow. If we mislynch today it gives SK win, which is worse.

[brassherald]

No problem.
I just tried to look via phone but it's annoying.

So why should I not think that you're the SK here Mr. Brass?

Segaco is still alive, and Gemini was a terrible choice for me to pick because if I was SK, I had Gemini pocketed enough that I would have wanted her in any MYLO or LYLO situation with me. Even if I didn't kill Segaco, then, I would have shot you to narrow her lock towns to just me and see if I couldn't eke out a win that way.

I would have just needed her to vote with me rather than for me for one day phase and any kill tonight would win it for me.

[Vedith]

Okay Brass isn't the SK I think.
So nm, Segaco why should we not consider you as the SK?

[Segaco]

Rip Gemini

No problem.
I just tried to look via phone but it's annoying.

So why should I not think that you're the SK here Mr. Brass?

Segaco is still alive, and Gemini was a terrible choice for me to pick because if I was SK, I had Gemini pocketed enough that I would have wanted her in any MYLO or LYLO situation with me. Even if I didn't kill Segaco, then, I would have shot you to narrow her lock towns to just me and see if I couldn't eke out a win that way.

I would have just needed her to vote with me rather than for me for one day phase and any kill tonight would win it for me.

Actually, you killing Gemini as the SK does make sense.
Think of it this way: your win as SK is likely guaranteed, the thing is that some methods are easier than others,

1) Killing outside Gemini's town reads (aka between Cowy and myself) was one, but the most risky one because you had no knowledge of who the mafia was. If neither of us turned up to be mafia, you would have confirmed one of her townreads as evil, and from there there was a chance her suspicion could come back later in the day to bite you in your poor

br

ass and chew your win away. So in conclusion: too dangerous of a choice. There are way better options.
2) The next option was killing Vedith and having Cowy go against me like he had since the start of D2. There was this small chance either Gemini or Cowy would have suspected something, but it was likely I would be lynched in the end because neither of those two seem to like me very much :<
3) And then there's the last choice, which is killing Gemini herself. By doing this you would have an excuse as to why you wouldn't have done so: "I wouldn't have killed someone who town read me and I could have done option 2." It's a pretty believeable excuse, too, so it holds.

So yeah, option 2 and 3 led to a likely victory, your chances were pretty high. This means that it

does

make sense for a SK you to kill Gemini because it was one of the options that led to victory.

[Vedith]

Segaco why you no SK though?

[Vedith]

Okay Brass.
Here are my last 5 Scum games that I find via phone.
I excluded 2. 1 I was solo mafia in 5p and one I recently just finished being Scum but there was a hidden mechanic in the game making bussing worthless

viewtopic.php?f=52&t=71753

viewtopic.php?f=53&t=73108

viewtopic.php?f=84&t=72847

viewtopic.php?f=84&t=72441

viewtopic.php?f=84&t=72196

The 5th one I barely bus. But you can see a pattern.

[brassherald]

VOTE: no lynch

I'm 90% sure I gamesolved early Day 2 and just switched Vedith and Segaco. That being said. I like the idea of a LYLO tomorrow rather than a MYLO today.

[Vedith]

But we both know that doesn't work out for you Brass.

[Vedith]

I assume you read the games I posted, correct?

[Vedith]

To at least a skim over I mean.

[Segaco]

Segaco why you no SK though?

At least I wouldn't kill Gemini after focusing on them so much yesterday.
So unless you're expecting some kind WIFOM, I'm not the guy you're looking for.