[MARCH CHALLENGE]

[BBmolla]

I'd Take a Bullet

14 Players

1 Mafia Goon
1 Mafia N2 Suicidal Goon
1 Mafia 0-shot Vig

11 1-shot Fixated Elite Bodygaurds

• Fixated: This player may only target the player their vote ended on at the end of the day.
  
• Elite Bodygaurd: During the night, select a player. If that player is targeted for a nightkill, both you and the nightkiller will die.
  
• Mafia are all Multitasking.
  
• If a Mafia player is lynched, any players on the wagon gain +1-shot. (This affects both Town and Mafia.)
  
• At the start of the game, Mafia may choose to give their vig additional shots, but changes their win condition and the Suicidal Mafia's Role. Town is not informed of Mafia's choice.
  • 1-shot Vig: Mafia win condition becomes White Flag, Mafia Suicidal Goon becomes a Mafia Goon.
    
  • 2-shot Vig: All Mafia become Lovers, Mafia Suicidal Goon becomes a Mafia Roleblocker.

Spoiler: 3/6/19 version

I'd Take a Bullet

13 Players

1 Mafia Goons
1 Mafia Shotcop
1 Mafia 0-shot Vig

10 1-shot Fixated Elite Bodygaurds

• Fixated: This player may only target the player their vote ended on at the end of the day.
  
• Elite Bodygaurd: During the night, select a player. If that player is targeted for a nightkill, both you and the nightkiller will die.
  
• Shotcop: During the night, target a player. You will be informed how many shots they have left of their ability.
  
• Mafia are all Multitasking.
  
• If a Mafia player is lynched, any players on the wagon gain +1-shot. (This affects both Town and Mafia.)
  
• At the start of the game, Mafia may choose to give their vig additional shots, but receive negative effects as a result of it. Town is not informed of Mafia's choice.
  • 1-shot Vig: Mafia become White Flag.
    
  • 2-shot Vig: All Mafia become Lovers.

[BBmolla]

@cfj's: smalltown is a nice idea. It's something I think hasn't really been innovated on in recent memory. I've never really thought about the principles that would go into a good smalltown game. And I don't think I've ever seen the idea for a 2:7 smalltown. It's a cool idea. Definitely hard to evaluate, but very intriguing.

@bb's: Also neat. And kudos on making it both semi-open and have alternate win conditions :p

It's actually a really interesting idea for a setup... and it actually matters what the answer to this is: are you using NL at deadline or plurality? I assume NL? I *think* it might be scumsided if scum don't give the vig any extra shots, maybe. But I really, really like the ideas in it.

NL at deadline

Might toy with giving scum more power at 1-shot and 2-shot

[BBmolla]

Okay the setups should now be 4 mislynches, 3 mislynches, and 2 mislynches if I did the math correctly. Still suboptimal to choose option 3 but that is ideal.

[BBmolla]

Setup B is way more townsided imo even though Watcher is better than tracker.

What if the Bodygaurd was a Bodyblocker?

[BBmolla]

Yeah I made same mistake, it’s one of not both ahaha

[BBmolla]

You need one of the roles from the OP

[BBmolla]

I'll vote tonight

[BBmolla]

Life is a mess. Sorry I dont have time to vote.

[BBmolla]

Grats! Was a good group of Setups.

I swear to mafia god I’ll vote this next month.