[MARCH CHALLENGE]

[mith]

White Flag, The Coalition, My Name is Earl... I feel like this month's challenge was made for me.

[mith]

Ego
This should be stickied.

If I'm reading this right, does Lost Identity qualify? It has semi random generation and the IDs are like named townies. (I'll not be submitting that though because it's trash)

Yeah, this is one of those borderline cases.

I think conceptually lost identity doesn’t really feel like a semi open because there’s no actual distinction between the different possible setups that could be generated, because the roles (id numbers) are all equivalent except that they are different numbers. I’d certainly count it as having named townies. As for semi openness, if you wanted to submit something like it I’d personally squint at it but would just let the voters decide if it’s a good idea or not :p.

I wouldn't consider this semi-open, for what it's worth.

[mith]

I'm pretty sure scum should always choose 0-shot as it is.

[mith]

I have an idea for a setup that's perfect for this (it's an old idea), but I still haven't gotten it to work out. Boo.