I agree, Nips isn't my first choice but he's a fine second. While I didn't have the hardest scum read on him before the wagon, the way he's reacting to the wagon is troublesome to me.In post 793, Chara wrote:i certainly understand the "i want a wagon" mindset but if you don't care too much who the wagon is on, it's going to hit town. scum are going to vote to lynch town and with that mindset it's so very easy to vote for a mislynch and say "i wasn't townreading him, that's all."
i dislike the Flippy wagon because it feels exactly like that sort of compromise. he isn't a major scumread for anyone as far as i can see.
I really don't get why some people are hesitant to slam the mighty hammer of justice on one of these guys. Sandal has been outwardly scummy most of the game, I don't think that's really a topic for debate at this point. Not many have said too much against this. Nips is transforming into a very plausibly scummy persona through the wagoning process. We're not going to get any definite information without some kind of lynch. I don't think the case against Scepticism/TLK is strong or necessary in our discussions right now. While they may have done some scummy things, I feel it would be better to come back to that another day once we have some actual information, and we can see their reactions to the lynch's outcome.Chara wrote:in the end i'd prefer a wagon that wasn't Burke or Flippy. TLK is better, Scept is also better. i disagree with Flavor that Scept is a fall guy. doesn't feel that way to me with the way that Flippy and Burke's wagons are.
Also, it isn't necessarily that I don't care where the wagon is. It's more about me not caring who the wagon is on between Sandal and Nips. I'm pretty certain that its at least one of them. Truthfully if we lose a town during this wagoning process it wouldn't be the end of the world in my opinion. It's possible that the night kill could be blocked (no idea what the special role set up is) and then we are only one town down. That's 8 or 9 towns left (depending on if the 4 mafia number is correct) with a lot more info about what's going on. This will just lead to a more informed decision come D2.