911: What's Your Emergency? (Postgame)

[rosterfoster]

UNVOTE:

This is a bad wagon because Insomnia’s not going to be here.

[Invisibility]

what was insomnia at

[ofrhz]

I think insomnia is town

[Invisibility]

also school trip lol

[rosterfoster]

It was L-2 I think. Normally I would be ok with it but the pressure isn't going to do anything.

[Invisibility]

what makes this situation different

[ofrhz]

Thinking tris is town too

[ofrhz]

VOTE: insomnia

Why?

[rosterfoster]

I have a family emergency and I won’t be able to post as much as I have for the next few days. I’ll just say please don’t wagon me to death carelessly, or cap my wagon at L-2 at least. I’ll try to give as much input as possible..although I doubt i’ll be able to

There's literally no point in wagoning Insomnia, and tbh I also don't want to cause him more stress at this moment.

[Elbirn]

GL what do you think of Elbirn’s 18

not a fan of it

Oh no not fun

[Invisibility]

ok i missed that post
pedited was respindngin to roster

[Elbirn]

Insomnia is overly defensive but probably town

Rooster had a weird entry to the thread and I dont know why THAT wasnt the reason for insomnia's vote.

I get the impression that insomnia is enthusiastic tryhardy newbtown who demands substance for everything but he'll grow out of it I hope. I dont really agree with his reasoning but i get it from a newbtown perspective

[GuiltyLion]

Rooster had a weird entry to the thread and I dont know why THAT wasnt the reason for insomnia's vote.

you think insomnia's town and there's yet another separate more valid reason to be voting roster

yet you are not voting roster?

[Elbirn]

I mean I could. Would that make you happy?

VOTE: RoosterFooster

How are you Lion?

[GuiltyLion]

well no that vote doesn't make me happy because I think roster's townie

I'm more just asking why you have to be prompted to vote an apparent scumread

[MariaR]

.

[light_ganski]

Vote Count 1.2

insomnia (4)

- tris, insomnia, Invisibility, Yes Mafia

ofrhz (1)

- skitter30

Baezu (1)

- GuiltyLion

Yes Mafia (1)

- volxen

Enigma (1)

- ofrhz

MariaR (1)

- Baezu

rosterfoster (1)

- Elbirn

Not Voting (3)

- Enigma, MariaR, rosterfoster

As there are 13 players alive, it takes 7 votes to lynch.

You have

(expired on 2019-04-16 23:24:30)

until the deadline.

[Elbirn]

well no that vote doesn't make me happy because I think roster's townie

I'm more just asking why you have to be prompted to vote an apparent scumread

I assure you I don't.

I tend to free form babble what's in my head and I just wanted to get a word in edge wise when making that post frankly and I wasnt super concerned about my vote. Rooster struck me as tonally awkward and I dont see how he would think that anyone was "onto something" based on

Hi all!

VOTE: MariaR

She’s a list mod duh

Or why you think that he "saw what you did". Why are you townreading him exactly?

[GuiltyLion]

Or why you think that he "saw what you did".

well at this point he has explicitly stated that he did:

several people had already posted, you didn't engage with any of them or any of the page 1 content, instead voting somebody who hadn't gotten to the thread yet with an explanation that pinged me as awkward

Ya. I thought the same when I read it so I was happy when you had the same reasons

and since his post 30 is consistent with this explanation, I don't see a reason to disbelieve that.

Why are you townreading him exactly?

I would say it's far more important to argue for scumreads than townreads right now. If you think rooster's scum because you think he's tonally awkward, the responsibility is on you to vote him and make your case to everyone else. I'm not interested in giving reasons for my townread, I expect you will argue with them and the result will be to drag this game into a noisy disagreement that's of no real value. further, he has ~75% odds of being town in the objective sense, so to calling him scum is the claim that's less likely to be true by default and the one that requires justification.

unless/until rooster's at risk of lynch, my focus is on finding scum, not defending town.

[MariaR]

VOTE: GuiltyLion
*yawn*

[MariaR]

Insomnia and ofrhz are town.
Rooster is towny
Invisibility is a valid vote as well
hm well, that was easy.

[GuiltyLion]

Maria - read on tris? She's worth a mention if you're gonna give that many reads

[MariaR]

Why do you think I should be talking about tris out of all the people in the playerlist?

[GuiltyLion]

she's one of the more active slots and several of your townreads have stated townreads on her

so I don't know why she was left out

[GuiltyLion]

like if you're trying to townblock then tris should be in your townblock IMO, the fact that she wasn't is mildly sus